Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Best finish for Poplar?

Posts

Best finish for Poplar?

#1

Best finish for Poplar?

Victor Parisian

>Looking to the collective wisdom of the board for help.

I'm just finishing up a small table with drawer (my beta test) made of poplar. Some of the boards used have the green areas of wood. I'm thinking I may want to stain it possibly forest green. Then use a wipe on poly.

What are your thoughts and why?

Keep in mind, this is the beta version, and unless the finish is really outstanding it will likely end up as Doublewide's (my cat) feeding or liter table.

Regards,

Victor - enjoying another fine Sunday in Houston

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#2

Hey Victor, I like...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Milk paint topped with BLO.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#3

Little more info...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Take a look at Real Milk Paints "earth green". One of my favorites.

Any top coat will darken the milk paint, so keep that in mind when choosing a color.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#4

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

John Pappas

>Victor, I did something in poplar where I wanted a dark red (think Oriental look) finish. I mixed a red and black water dye. The red kills any of the green in the poplar, thus the color was very even. I topcoated with a wipe on varnish. I thought it turned out exceptionally well.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#5

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

ThomD

>I have mentioned here before that I had these 2 5 gallon drums of furniture oil. I don't use oil all that fast, so over the years they had probably rusted, and all of a sudden what was a clear oil started to produce some nice dark tones. I did my current bench's base in poplar and finished it with this stuff and it looks great. I'm sure any oil finish like Watco, with some added colour to it would tone over the poplar. Of course you can use an opaque finish if you want, but poplar can look very cover shotish if you want it to.

The pictures with flash only, in a dark room don't do the colour or eveness of tone justice. A number of people have come to my shop for consults and when asked what sort of wood tone they were looking for, have pointed at either the top or the base and said "like that". It is funny for me, because I am normally pretty hostile to stain.

By Watco with colour added to it, I am thinking of some stain colours worked in there (try some rust, who knows). There are Watcos that come with stain added to them, but as with any such products they often need a little final playing with to really get good results.

Whatever you do run some samples first on scraps of your stock.


img

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#6

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

Victor Parisian

>"but poplar can look very cover shotish if you want it to."

Translation por favor...

Victor

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#7

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

Victor Parisian

>I'm planning on running some samples first. Just returned from Lowes, and they have nothing, zip, nada that caught my eye.

Victor

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#8

Thanks Scott.

Victor Parisian

>I'll make a run to Woodcraft in the A.M. I kind of like the tavern green. SWMBO just informed me that it will be the cat's feeding station and she wants that dark green color.

Beta may just be the new Omega.

Victor

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#9

green poplar is fleeting.......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>it quickly turns brown in the sun.

I have finished acres of poplar in all sorts of ways. Milk paint, or its equivalent, looks nice on poplar. One can stain poplar any shade. For years I thought my mother's silver chest was mahogany. Then one day I looked more closely and it was stained poplar. All the doors in my house are 6 panel poplar stained with Bartley gel stain and varnished. Depending on the piece it looks nice just finished natural. But more often than not what I build out of poplar gets stained or painted.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#10

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

Stuart Hough

>Victor, I believe he means that it looks VERY nice.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#11

Re: green poplar is fleeting.......

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I built a saw bench about three years ago out of poplar. The green color was on most of the wood. Now it is a very pleasing caramel brown. I didn't finish the bench at all. A few weeks ago I built another saw bench using the same wood. When I planed the board, it was green underneath the nice caramel brown. I'm giving no help here except to say that the green does turn to a beautiful brown shade.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#12

Re: green poplar is fleeting.......

Victor Parisian

>Thanks, I have seen that myself on some of my work from several years back. It is a very pleasing color. For now, I think I'll play around with the milk paint and see if my samples come up with something really nice.

Assuming for a minute that my milk paint experiments do not result in anything usable, would you recommend BLO and wax or just a clear poly satan finish?

Victor

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#13

Satan finish?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Would that be one of those toasted finishes?

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#14

I always recommend shellac

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#15

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

ThomD

>Well, say, like the nice walnut on the cover of Pop Woodworking this month. It has strong contrast, and when stained it can look like walnut or cherry etc... Not to say it shouldn't be left as Poplar, but if one is looking for something different.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#16

Re: green poplar is fleeting.......

Victor Parisian

>Hey Patrick,

How is that slab work bench coming? Or is that slab going to have to sit for a couple of years to dry our?

Victor - Looking forward to seeing that beast.

Re: Best finish for Poplar?

#17

Re: green poplar is fleeting.......

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Victor, I had a major coniption fit after I talked to the guy and chickened out. There are just too many unknowns using green wood. The sawyer cut the tree into 4" slabs anyway because he said they could be rendered into 4"x4"'s and he was interested to see what would happen also. So now I'm waiting for the summer to end to go take a look at the slabs after they've dried a bit. I'm still probably going to make something more like the Dominy benches no matter what I use.