Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Posts

Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#1

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Hi everyone,

I'm doing some research for my next project and wanted to get some input from y'all.

As you can see from the rendering and drawing below I'm trying to design a Krenov style plane around an old tapered laminated Sorby Iron I have. It's not so much that I prefer the Sorby over a Hock. I just want to use what I have already. I mean, what else am I going to use this old iron for?

Krenov Smoother Rendering

Krenov Smoother Drawing

Before you get all rabid on me, don't mind the grain orientation in the rendering. :>) I can't control that without doing a lot of extra work.

Anyway, I plan on making the body of the plane from bubinga and the wedge from some (soft) maple. If I'm feeling up to it, I MAY inlay the mouth area with some ebony or rosewood.

As you can see in the preliminary drawing, I made the plane 10" long x 2 7/8" wide x 3 1/2" tall. The height is influenced by the length of the iron. I made the bedding at 50 deg because I wanted a high angle smoother. The mouth is located per the reccomendations in Finck's book which is 5/9 from the back of the plane.

Now that I look at the design I can see that I need to soften up the corners considerably. But what concerns me if the miniscule amount of room for my hand at the back. I'm thinking of extending the body and making it a "long" smoother. And to top it off, the profile seems a bit tall as well. I'm wondering if it will feel, "top heavy".

I realize that I should probably just make the damn thing as see how it feels, but I wanted to get some feedback from those of you that have made their own planes.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#2

Wait a minute

wilbur

>Do you mean to say that there are folks on this forum that would get all hot and bothered because of grain orientation in a tool that you made? :@)

There's probably more room on the back of the plane as you've drawn it than you think for the back hand. My hands aren't particularly big, but the 2.62" that you have between the blade and the back end of the plane should be more than enough room.

The easiest and most direct way to see if your design would work would be to take a chunk of wood, bandsaw it to that shape, and push it around to see how it feels.

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#3

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Wait a minute

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Mocking up the plane is a good idea Wilbur! I may try that out.

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#4

Re: Wait a minute

Victor Parisian

>Nice rendering of the design. Good work as usual.

Victor

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#5

Don't know, but . . .

steve mackay

>sure is purty so far !

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#6

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Dom ...

Back in the bad-old-days (before Ron Hock and others) I used to use old Stanley irons and breakers. I found the length to be too great for comfortable use so I ground off a few inches so that the iron protruded about an inch above the top of the plane.

I found 2.75 - 3.00 inches to be a good heighth (for me).

I like to have at least 5" for my back hand (unless it's going to be a block plane) and I usually shape the front like a bun (kind of like an in-fill).

I love wooden planes - about the only metal planes I have are a mitre, a couple of blocks, several shoulder planes and a small "hag's tooth". Over the last several years I've probably given away 50 wooden planes and I still probably have 25 or 30 (only one of those was bought - a lovely Clark and Williams that I must admit outperforms every plane I ever built).

Good luck ... rj

PS .. one piece of advise: tune the plane and then worry about the final shape; take off a little at a time until it's comfortable in your hand.

PS.2 .. the thicker irons available from Hock, LN and other make a big difference in performance.

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#7

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

James Watriss

>Dom, your bowsaw is proof positive that you learn so much more by doing.

My best story about the pitfalls of digital rendering came from my days in retail... Some poor contractor called, looking for 800 sq feet of walnut burl to do a floor. I'm sure the rendering the client got was spectacular.

I say when it comes to things like planes, the above suggestion about mocking it up is a much better idea. When you make a drawing, draw the relevant things, like how to lay the plane out so you have enough room for the iron AND the cap iron. Or how far apart the bed block and the front block need to be so you don't have to plane off 1/4" of the sole before the blade pokes out. The rest is much better done in person, by eye and intuition.

Last suggestion... Make one or two practice planes out of cheaper materials first to make sure you have the mechanics down first. I had a gorgeous razee jack I made out of purpleheart that didn't work worth a damn. Waste of pretty wood, that. Don't be like me... Do it smart.

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#8

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I wonder how wise it is to deviate from a traditional design for your first plane. Once you have a time tested design in your hands it is easier to visualize alterations.

A traditional smoothing plane is about 2 3/4" high and 7 3/4" long and has the mouth about 2 1/4" from the front. I cannot imagine why one would want a 5/9 ratio. Any rationale? A long iron is not a problem in a traditional smoother. Since I have used some irons enough to lose more than an inch of length, I think it foolish to have the iron just a little longer than the wedge. What if you end up liking the thing and really putting some mileage on it?

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#9

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Dom,

Well in my humble opinion you need to design the plane not only around the iron but around one of my fancy DIY stainless steel infill kits : )as pictured below

LOL,

Andy


img

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#10

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>You wrote:

"I wonder how wise it is to deviate from a traditional design for your first plane. Once you have a time tested design in your hands it is easier to visualize alterations."

Actually, I'm following Krenov/Finck's designs which seem to work quite nicely although I'm designing the plane around the iron I have. From what I can tell from Finck's book, this is an acceptable practice. This is mentioned when he discusses the use of irons found at flea markets and from old planes. They would have to have been of a similar size to the one I have. But to answer your question, one of the design schemes is I have (not shown here) is a more traditional shape although it is based on dimensions I got from John Whelan's book, "Making Traditional Wooden Planes". That version is at least 9" long. That's on page 29, chapter 6, "Bench Planes by the classical method (Coachmakers Smoothing plane)"

You wrote:

"A traditional smoothing plane is about 2 3/4" high and 7 3/4" long and has the mouth about 2 1/4" from the front. I cannot imagine why one would want a 5/9 ratio. Any rationale?"

If you read my original post it says, "The mouth is located per the recommendations in Finck's book which is 5/9 from the back of the plane." To be exact I got it from page 74 of David Finck's book, "Making and Mastering Wooden Hand planes" where it states, "...a throat opening located five-ninths of the total length will do."

"A long iron is not a problem in a traditional smoother. Since I have used some irons enough to lose more than an inch of length, I think it foolish to have the iron just a little longer than the wedge. What if you end up liking the thing and really putting some mileage on it?"

Foolish? Wow, don't candy coat it, tell me really how you feel!

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#11

Hi Andy!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Yeah, that's my next move Andy! AFTER I get this project under my belt!!

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#12

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>James,

You've got a good point about using scrap wood first! I mean, it's not as if I'm immune to making mistakes......In fact, I'm pretty damn good with coming up with new and inventive ways to screw up! :>)

I was thinking of just using some scrap 2x4s to mock up the shape and to see how it fit my hand. And I have enough Cherry or hickory for my Mark I version of this plane.

Thanks again for the advice. I appreciate it.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#13

suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the first few planes I made I went for fancy designs similar to yours in shape. Then I needed a plane quick and made a simple rectangular prism with rounded corners. Actually the rounded corners came later when I got around to that part. The rectangular prism shape is easier on the hands and easier to make, but it won't win any design contests. I noted in Finck's shop that his planes are simple softened rectangular prisms. Then I got tired of screwing with the finicky things and bought a cast iron plane and went back to smoothing with an air driven orbital sander. It doesn't care what direction the gain lays. I still use the Krenov block planes because they are so nice in the hand compared to the steel alternatives. I'll bet it has to do with dampening vibration; the wood planes feel very nice in use.

Its about time to put these tools to work making something useful.

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#14

Re: Hi Andy!

Craig D

>>Yeah, that's my next move Andy! AFTER I get this project under my belt!!

That stainless is both a blessing and a curse but sure is pretty.


img

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#15

strength

paul womack

>you seem to have a narrow, quite sharp corner, where the side cheek curves just before the front (wear). In other planes I've seen the wear and cheek work together to provide a grip a lot like the front bun in a Spiers/Norris shape.

http://www.ukworkshop.co.uk/forums/viewtopic.php?t=16643&highlight=

(I think the nose is a little too long in that one)

BugBear

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#16

Seems to me that somebody...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Has way too much time on his hands at work.

;^)

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#17

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

Marv

>Some beautiful machining there Andy

Marv

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#18

You're just jealous!.

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>:>)

Actually, most of this was designed at home. I have the "At home license" so I can work at home if needed.

Dominic

Re: Designing a handplane around an old Sorby iron

#19

Re: OP

ThomD

>I'd keep the plane lower. High planes normally make for less stable feel in this style and more dofficulties in chip escapement. Takes about 45 minutes to make that kind of plane, so I wouldn't waste too much time on planing. I like Krenov style planes a little on the long side, and with the mouth centered on the block, or leaning in that direction.