Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Posts

Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#1

Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Hi All,

As I am able to work more often in the shop I find my skills/equipment lacking in the work holding department.

As one of my options I would like to either build a board Jack or a

bench slave.I figured I would ask the collective wisdom here and get the pros and cons of each before wood touched a sawblade.I have standard metal screw face vise on the left side of my bench and a Veritas Twin screw vise on the right end.

Thanks,

Andy

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#2

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Stuart Hough

>Andy, I think you would do well with a sliding deadman on the front of your bench. Go to popwood.com (Popular Woodworking's website) and look under the plans area. Chris Schwarz has included this on an upgrade to his "$175 workbench" plan. Happy woodworking!

One possible caveat...the last time I looked at it was over a year ago, but it should still be there.

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#3

Here is the link, Andy

Stuart Hough

>Here is the link that addresses the deadman directly. I went back and looked, but it was not on the article that i told you about. This should take care of just about any support needs you have for working on the front of the bench.

http://popularwoodworking.com/article/Bench_Deadman/

Good luck!

Stuart

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#4

Re: Here is the link, Andy

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Thanks Stuart.I found it after your first post and I think it is just what I am looking for.It came about because yesterday I was frustrated trying to hold some interior door slabs I was replacing in the house.Now tonight after spending most of the day in a major cleaning frenzy I am recycling the doors I took down and salvaging the stiles and rails of those to make the deadman parts.It just ahppens to work out that a common dimension of the deadman is 1 3/8" which just happens to be the thickness of the old doors.must be fate..

Thanks for the info,

Andy

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#5

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

James Watriss

>Other alternatives...

I think if you do some head scratching, there are always other alternatives. I've seen...

-People adding dog holes to the legs of their benches, and clamping to the legs.

-People adding dog holes to their bench legs, and making a support that slides into corresponding holes on two legs

-People (like me) working at a bench with a chest of drawers built into it, and pulling out drawers of different heights to support work as needed.

-Some people will wrap a rope around the work, tie the other end to their dog, and throw a steak over to the other end of the shop. (Nobody I've ever met, but surely, someone has tried this by now, right?)

-People (again, like me) routing a groove in the edge of the bench, or adding a skirt if the edge isn't thick or wide enough, and intalling a T-track, to be used with toggle clamps. IF this is set back from the vise a bit, you can add a sliding piece to meet flush with the vise, or a sliding deadman, or...

-I made a dovetailed shaker step-stool once upon a time. It did a great job of supporting work, in addition to being a step ladder, lunch stool, improvised saw horse, and other things.

-My shop mate made a bench slave without holes... instead he uses t-track, and an old tool rest from a defunct bench grinder. Works fine for him, he says. He also bought the Kreg hold down that's like half of a vise-grips pliers, with a plate that mortises into the bench... and then we discovered that swapping the bolt will allow the vise grips part to be used in a T-track anywhere.

At the moment, my bench has dog holes in the legs, I still have the step stool, and I use the twin screw on the front, as a face vise... it's incredibly powerful, so supporting the work is still necessary, but the success of the task isn't determined by the quality of that support... because that vise doesn't let ANYTHING go if I don't want it to.

Side note... as a face vise, the Veritas twin screw is great. But I've also gotten used to slippage from the set screw on the cog that lets the chain keep everything in line. In the end, I think I actually like it better that way. The chain engages when there's nothing in the jaws, when the jaw starts to rack. So it will move in and out pretty easily. But I do have to tighten each handle individually, which is great... it's like tightening two individual vises on the work. Twice the holding power... excellent! AND, I can pinch things in the right side of the vise in a similar fashion to using a hand screw... tighten the right screw in to hold the piece, and thread the left side out. It uses the mechanical advantage of the screw to really lever the left side away, and pinches really hard on the right side. (It works this way whichever side you feel like using as a pinch point, but I designated right and left for purposes of clarification.) That's a trick you can't do with the wooden screwed versions, I don't think.

In short, the twin screw is a bodacious piece of work holding equipment, and I think I prefer having it as the primary work holding vise... not an end vise. Thank monsieur Schwartz for that idea.

Work holding is an ongoing journey. I think there are a few things that do a good overall job of handling most things. But sometimes it's just as easy to use an auxiliary clamp to just hold something to the bench... or better yet, put a board across your work, and screw the board down to the bench with screws that are long enough to compensate for the thickness of whatever you're holding down. Don't be afraid to get creative when you need to... I like to think that the more creative you are, the more involved your projects will be, and the more involved your work holding solutions will need to be.

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#6

Some excellent suggestions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Your perspective is often so useful, James - the "git 'er done" of someone who's got to get the work out the door at (with luck) a profit.

I've got a Record vise as my end vise (not the permanent solution, but a worthwhile experiment), and I've occasionally clamped a stick in that, extending past the face of the bench, to support work the right length (five-six feet in the case of my bench) and width (four to six inches) for that to work. For wider pieces, like assembled doors, I've been known to use those plastic milk crates that are so useful around the shop as a rest, but, again, this works only if the stock is the right width.

You mention, "Some people will wrap a rope around the work, tie the other end to their dog, and throw a steak over to the other end of the shop." But you leave out the value of cats as a workholding device - kind of a furry paperweight.

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#7

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Victor Parisian

>I have a sliding deadman on my bench, and I do not find it as useful as I thought it would be. This is mainly because the holes for the pegs are always just a bit to low or high for the work I'm doing. I resolve this with a large clamp at the deadman or on the right front leg.

my $.02 worth

Victor - wishing everyone a great 4th of July- Be safe and enjoy

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#8

Or...

James Watriss

>Tie one end around the woodworker, and throw some profits to the other end of the shop...

I do what I can, and the jobs are starting to come in. But it's a hard time to get a small business going... especially one that's not known for paying well in the first place.

Still... one day at a time. : )

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#9

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Andy,

You might try a silent apprentice, adjustable and doesn't get in the way.

Stephen


img

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#10

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Norman

>Victor,

Just saw your post. A solution I found for this is to both have more holes along the length of the sliding deadman in 2 parallel rows, but offset from each other, so the distance between holes is much reduced..

Along with this, in the attached photo you can see that the 2 round pegs have square faces attached. I don't have an up to date photo of these particular pegs, but what I did was to make them eccentric. This I did by offsetting the 3/4 inch hole along the face of the square portion of the peg. When you rotate the faces of the peg now, they each have a different height, not a large difference but enough to keep the boards strung from the face vise level.

Norman


img

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#11

Ellis Walentine

Are you a southpaw?

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#12

No, the benches are

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#13

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Victor Parisian

>Thanks for the post. unfortunately, my deadman slides on front stretcher flush with edge of bench as on the Roubo bench. I'll add an extra hole or two, but they will likely still be too low for most of my work. I think I'll drill a series of dog holes in face of bench and plug when not in use with decorative pegs.

Victor

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#14

Nice Stephen, that should do me.

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

#15

Re: Survey :Bench Slave or Board Jack?

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Hi All,

Thanks for all the ideas and suggestions.Between projects and while cleaning I was able to recycle some door parts into a sliding deadman.

From Recent work

I haven't had much usage from it as of yet but it seems like it will do exactly what I was looking for.

From Recent work


There is no finish on it as of yet
From Recent work

The plan follows the article linked above from PWW with the exception being the height/length to fit my particular bench.It will slide clear of the drawers so I can access those without too much pain.

Thanks again to all who offered suggestions and ideas.

Andy