Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

Posts

The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#1

The Brese Small Smoother Kit  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have included below a link to a v-e-r-y l-o-n-g article on building this smoother kit. It documents the steps I followed, the modifications required, and the construction. It covers three sessions in my workshop. You will either find it riveting .. or fall asleep! :)

Ron Brese makes wonderful planes, and his kits are just as great. This plane is based on Karl Holtey's S11 ...


That's the Holtey by the way ... do you think I would show you mine and spoil the surprise? :)

One of the nice things about a kit is that you can modify them to reflect your own idea of what it should look like. So ....

All comments and questions welcomed.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Brese Small Smoother Kit

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#2

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit

James Watriss

>Gorgeous job Derek.

I really dig the rounded top... looks very comfortable.

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#3

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit

Stuart Hough

>Derek, Thanx for the all the info on your beautiful little smoother! You really have a way of making everything understandable, and ultimately doable. I always enjoy your posts!

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#4

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit

Tom Colligan

>Nice write up, Derek, and thanks.

Do you think there is something unique in the way an infill holds a plane iron that give it an advantage over a wooden plane or modern LV of LN planes? TIA, Tom.

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#5

Infills verses LNs and LVs?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Do you think there is something unique in the way an infill holds a plane iron that give it an advantage over a wooden plane or modern LV of LN planes?

Hi Tom

There is a disadvantage from the side of an infill because it has two different materials, steel and wood. In a new infill it is expected that the bed infill lines up with the steel mouth support. However over time the infill may shrink, or expand in a humid workshop. Of course, this is why it is important to choose your infill wood carefully.

Holtey has for some time been reinforcing the beds of his infills with brass rods that run through them to the sole. The blade actually rests on the rods, although it appears to rest on the wood of the infill.


Holtey states frankly that he considers infills less reliable than metal-bedded planes. Hence the reason for building his #98 and #982.

The new #982 ...


In my opinion the differences between well-made planes - be they infill, LV or LN - is not readily apparent under "average" conditions. Two factors are noted among the better planes - and again I do not see this due to the type of bedding (that is just one of several factors that determines the stability of the blade): the first is that more difficult woods (e.g. reversing grain, hardness) sorts the men from the boys; and secondly, the better planes cut better when the blades are blunt (as Joel at TFWW notes, "they just feel harder to push").

The latter factor is one why BU planes and selected BD planes do so well - the higher the cutting angle (e.g. around 60 degrees - hence my decision to go for this in the Brese Small Smoother), the better they perform on gnarly woods. Again this is not the only factor that determines performance, but it is easiest to demonstrate.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#6

Re: Infills verses LNs and LVs?

ThomD

>"secondly, the better planes cut better when the blades are blunt"

In my case the award there would go to Japanese planes. I once took my general shop plane to my boatshop for about 6-7 months of work in which it was used to cut plywood, fiberglass, mahogany, and spruce. I didn't take any stones, and just kept tapping the blade out as it dulled so that the rounded edge would keep hooking in with postive geometry. I couldn't believe how long the plane kept cutting. Mostly this was due to the pull geometry, if not the bedding geometry.

It is reasuring to see some comon sense talk about infil planes which have always struck me as somewhat dubious, as do many tools from the transitional period in which the effects of industrialization were starting to be felt, and older solutions were being cast off.

The great thing about infils is that they appeal to people enough that they will pay to have huge amounts of effort put into them, which is critical to much of what governs performance.

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#7

Re: Infills verses LNs and LVs?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The great thing about infils is that they appeal to people enough that they will pay to have huge amounts of effort put into them, which is critical to much of what governs performance.

Hi Thom

I agree. For many of us, I suspect, the infill with its mix of wood and steel, when done well, offers up the ultimate combination of tool and art. We are drawn to them for this. Others, with a more pragmatic than spiritual outlook, may remain suspicious of their mystique.

The topic came up on WoodNet not so long ago, and rather than create a new reply, this is what I said:

Not all infills work better than non-infills ... only those that have been sprinkled with fairy dust.

I also have non-infills that have been sprinkled with fairy dust. This makes them imagine that they are as good as infills. And so they are.

Of course, any plane that is not sprinkled with fairy dust - regardless of whether it is an infill or not - does not perform any better than a 2008 Stanley.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#8

Re: Infills verses LNs and LVs?

James Watriss

>Very well put. :)

Re: The Brese Small Smoother Kit *LINK*

#9

Re: Infills verses LNs and LVs?

ThomD

>I think another part of the mystery is that there has been a time/development issue here. Go back to the 70s when people were more likely to buy into the idea that wood planes were better than metal planes (still arguable, but not my current point). I bought a record block plane with adjustable infeed from LV that when adjusted across it's range experiences @ 1mm of rocker, a gross machining error. Every metal plane I bought in those days required a lot of work to get to work properly, except my Record Jointer. The first block plane I made with an improperly fitted blade took shavings of 5 tens, massively better, so a rank amateur without videos, internet, or much in print could easily produce better than the pros. Over time different planes got the upgrade treatment and various planes moved to the forefront. Today, we lack any real world tests to discriminate between plane types, they are all so close. The information dump has also progressed to the point where in a recent tool competition a relative beginner won top honours.