Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

Posts

Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#1

Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I was to meet a realitor at her house last night. I spied a set of chairs with exquisite carving. The lady said a relative had made them who had been a cabinet maker in NYC in the 1800's. She also said she was "keeper of his tool chest" which she proceeded to show me. It was typical sized. The center was open to the bottom. Each side had trays which slid to the center revealing the tray beneath. The trays extended part way to the bottom; the bottom was all open. In the bottom-back was a row of about 20 profiled planes, with few hollows or rounds. I saw three planes- a short one, a medium one and a long one. The short one had been fitted with a steel sole. The others had mouth inserts of some dark dense looking wood. There were numerous scraper profiles, and screw clamps of various sizes disassembled so that they fit in the trunk. There was a handle with a polished agate piece affixed to its end which I believe was used to "hammer" veneer. I saw one dovetail saw and didn't get to explore saws buried under stuff toward the front of the trunk. There were numerous carving tools. I did not see chisels, but I didn't get to explore everything as she was getting antsy to make a commision (she didn't). I have never seen a farm with poorer dirt. The woodland which "hadn't been logged since 1970" had 5" trees and lots of rotting stumps. But that is another story.

Which leads to questions: I didn't see that any care had been taken to preserve these tools, such as "oiling" the steel or loosening the plane wedges. What should be done to preserve these tools? Would there be an academic interest in an inventory of these tools?

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#2

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

wilbur

>Academic interest? Maybe.

Internet forum woodworking hand tool geek interest? Definitely. :@)

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#3

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I would guess that the level of academic interest would depend on the noteworthiness of the original owner of the chest. Certainly the contents of the chest of Duncan Pfyfe is of extreme academic interest as have been the tool chests of other notable woodworkers/carpenters.

A less known owner may not have as much academic interest but might carry interest for the current family. It might also be of interest if there is a local historical society or the like.

Tom

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#4

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

The chairs which you saw were fine enough that you asked about them. That shows high skill. So this was a high-skill cabinetmaker. Therefore. I think there would be state or local historical interest if the chest is (a) complete, as-found, not-picked-through-and-high-graded; (b) has some age--Civil War era or previous would be more interesting than 1890, I would think; and (c) there is enough known about the man--life dates, where he worked, detailed photos of what he made--sufficient to get the attention of a NY historical society.

You're gonna maintain two farms?? Buying when the price is right is good.

Wiley

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#5

P.S.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>How do you judge 'poor dirt' versus 'good dirt'?

Wiley... who grew up in red clay and thought it was normal.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#6

red clay.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>red clay is vastly better dirt than the rock pile I was looking at. If an un-mowed pasture has sparse grass this time of year, its poor dirt. Actually it was thin dirt.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#7

Poor dirt

Hank Knight

>I would think pine trees would grow larger than 5" over almost 40 years in good dirt.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#8

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

Adam Cherubini

>Bill,

My sense is there is no such thing as an "academic interest" in period furniture. The only possible exception is us, as Wilbur has pointed out.

In my experience, the 'hallowed halls' of various institutions are chiefly interested in how tools shape styles and most importantly, how they might be able to make attributions based on tool marks or techniques. Pretty sure the "Garvan carver" is identified by three "signature" vee gouge cuts on the ends of acanthus leaves. As long as a dealer or museum (I'm finding less and less difference between the two) can make a compelling case for an attribution, the perception becomes reality at Sotheby's.

So in terms of what they really want, a link between the tools in the chest and the craftsman's products IS helpful. What they would like to know is whether the tools in the chest influenced the design or if they were essentially irrelevant. Was style/form a function of the tools one had on hand, the joinery one was capable of, materials availability, or was it (as I think they largely believe) some ephmeral, possibly market driven, compulsion?

At the heart of this issue is my pondering; What is a regional style? When viewed as a jumbled pile, period furniture could probably be better (i.e. more accurately) segregated. My sense is that like local sports teams, producing regional categories appeals to our tribalism. This explains how there could be no such thing as "Southern Furniture"* and why some desperately need there to be.

Adam

* I don't know enough about Southern furniture to say for sure that a Southern regional style doesn't exist. I can say I've not been convinced by what I have seen.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#9

A Southern Style of Furniture

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I was watching Antiques Roadshow the other day and they had a lady with a chair she said had been in her family from the beginning and was made in Virginia. The appraiser said that it resembled a New York style of crafting with the use of southern yellow pine as secondary wood being the main indicator that it was Southern-made. This of course made it worth considerably more. I have also wondered about Southern-style furniture, being a Southerner myself. My first inclination is to dismiss the notion of a Southern style in favor of many, many Southern styles. Just as Hollywood tends to make all Southerners speak the same wierd accent which one NPR commentator named "Foghorn Leghorn Speak" (after the Mel Blanc cartoon character), I wonder if pundits try to do the same with furniture. I have seen many regional (Southern) pieces that seemed unique enough to be singled out. But they were representative of a much smaller region than the entire American South.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#10

Re: A Southern Style of Furniture

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Oh yeah, I don't see how the use of SYP as a secondary wood makes much of a difference in classifying something as being Southern. I would say the chair in the above post, according to what the appraiser said, was a New York-style chair that was possibly built in Virginia.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#11

Re: A Southern Style of Furniture

Hank Knight

>Patrick,

I have long been put off by those who characterize "The South" as a monolithic region. It's not. The South is comprised of many regions, each with its own individual flavor and distinctive culture. I think this regionalism is plainly evident in "Southern" furniture. One would be hard pressed to deny that both Kentucky and Low Country South Carolina (Charleston) are properly categorized as "Southern." But their furniture styles are individually distinct and a far cry from each other. Charleston and Kentucky are easy examples, but stylistic differences abound throughout the South. The differences between Moravian pieces from North Carolina and "classic colonial" pieces from Tidewater Virginia are evident, even to the untrained eye. And on and on. I agree with you. While furniture may classified as "Southern" if it was made in the South, the classification obscures the many, many regional differences in style, design and construction that exist across "The South."

Hank

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#12

Some OT, some not, all rambly

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There is a book on Texas furniture (it may be "Texas Furniture: The Cabinetmakers and Their Work, 1840-1880," by Lonn Taylor, out of print and apparently a collector's item at $200 or so; the book I had was on loan from another library system years ago, and I have forgotten the title) that vividly illustrates that a lot of the furniture in Texas was heavily influenced by the large German population that migrated to Texas prior to and after the Mexican-American war: quite of a few of the pieces are kasts (armoire-like cabinets) that could be slipped into a Pennsylvania Dutch house and never raise a ripple. Then there are pieces that show a blending of kast construction and "Spanish colonial" construction. In the book I had, there is also a sofa with a back composed of two fish that Judy Kensley McKie would have been proud to call her own, but that's such an outlier that it hardly counts.

Little of the furniture illustrated in the book looks like "Southern furniture" as Antiques Roadshow understands it.

Off-topic #1: if you listen to some Macedonian music, you'd swear you were hearing Tejano, very heavy on the tuba for the rhythm/bass line. It turns out that both areas were strongly influenced by German military brass band traditions. This has NOTHING to do with the subject; I just find it delightful.

Off-topic #2a: when my dad (born in Seattle, raised there, Portland, OR, and Oakland, CA) was in Corpus Christi during World War II, two of his fellow officers were from different parts of the South. They couldn't understand each other, and he was always being called on to translate, since he could understand each of them. I suspect it had to do with his lack of preconceptions about what he should be hearing.

Off-topic #2b: a friend of mine who was doing peace education and draft counseling in the South during the Viet Nam war - not the most congenial part of the country for his message - found that, if he spoke the regional dialect, he got a more respectful listen; and that the regional dialect changed about every fifty miles (fortunately, Martin was a natural linguist). I have no idea to what degree that's still true with all the geographic ferment in the South over the last 30 years.

In my opinion, no part of the country is a monolith culturally; it's one of the simplifications the urban (especially Noo Yawk) media have foisted on us all. I notice cultural differences between my part of my county and the part of Oakland I grew up in, 65 miles from here; and the contrast between my town and the farm culture of the Central Valley is intense.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#13

Get a county soil survey!

Martin, from Granbury

>My soils prof, Dr. Watterston, once said "if you learn nothing else from this class, never buy a piece of property without first consulting a county soil survey".

The soil survey, which is available and can be interpreted by what used to be called the Soil Conservation Service (now called something else, but I don't know what, ask your county agricultural extension agent) contains everything you want to know about the soil of your property, before you buy it.

Including, but not limited to: flood plain boundaries, soil type, what kind of plants and trees the soil can grow, and how many bushels of corn or the Site Index of specific species of trees and if you can build a house or not and if you can put in a septic system or not. And much, much, more that I cannot recall.

So, find one at your local library or extension agent, and find someone who can interpret it, and you will save yourself a trip to look at poor soil, the book will tell you without spending the gas money.

Martin, who was teaching forestry merit badge last week at Scout camp.

BSF, MSF, SFASU

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#14

Re: Some OT, some not, all rambly

Hank Knight

>Bill said:

"Off-topic #2b: a friend of mine who was doing peace education and draft counseling in the South during the Viet Nam war - not the most congenial part of the country for his message - found that, if he spoke the regional dialect, he got a more respectful listen; and that the regional dialect changed about every fifty miles (fortunately, Martin was a natural linguist). I have no idea to what degree that's still true with all the geographic ferment in the South over the last 30 years."

The Southern regional dialects are still very pronounced. And the part about the dialect commanding a respectful ear is still very true. If you want to lose a lawsuit in the South, hire a yankee lawyer to try it for you. In rural counties in South Carolina, big city lawyers from Atlanta (known as "blue suits" locally) don't fare well.

I have a different recollection about the Southern attitude toward the Viet Nam war. I remember it as hawkish - at least in the beginning. I enlisted in 1966.

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#15

Re: Some OT, some not, all rambly

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I have a different recollection about the Southern attitude toward the Viet Nam war. I remember it as hawkish

That's what Bill said. "Peace education and draft counseling" were things done by those against the war.

Pam

Re: Exploring a 19th century tool chest, questions

#16

Thanks, Pam

Hank Knight

>Pam, you're right. I missed the "peace" in "peace education." Thanks.