Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

Posts

Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

#1

Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The recent Woodcraft flier features the new line of Stanley planes they call "Sweet Heart" (which appear to be replicas of planes from another manufacturer). In the text there is some nostalgia about the original "Sweet Heart" planes and it is stated that the original Sweet Heart was the "best of the best". I guess one is to believe that adding a heart to the new plane will make it better.

Anyway on to my question, were the original "Sweet Heart " planes any different in design or quality of materials than those that preceded or followed them?

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

#2

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

David Miller from Iowa

>I don't think the Sweet Heart planes were of any different quality than those immediately preceding of following it, although one could argue that during this general period the quality was at its zenith. I've always thought the various Sweet Heart logos (actually a play on "Hart" the chairman of Stanley in the 1920s) were just a nice logo that dated the planes to the 1920s and people found them desirable for aesthetics reasons

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

#3

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

Todd Hughes

>The Stanley Sweet Heart logo was a sereis of three slightly different logos with a heart in them used by Stamley on it's planes [and other tools and items they made...Ive seen many Sweet heart marked hinges] from 1920 to 1935. Has absolutly significance of extra quality etc....was just the logo they used like the "V" Stanley New Brtian Conn USA logo that was used befor it.

Planes from this time period are probably some of the best that Stanley made though no better then ones made in say 1919 or 1936

Used to be that Sweet Heart planes would sell for a premium, maybe they still do but it seems if so not that much anymore over the same condition one that is a bit older or newer. The mark does make it easy for people to date the tool at a glance and is kind of neat.

Sargent marked some of thier planes and tools VBM for Very Best Made and it is just a logo they used too during a time period and doesn't mean they were of extra quality either....Todd

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

#4

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

James Watriss

>It does seem to be the period during which they were at their prime.

-Frogs were machined well enough that they slide back and forth (when unscrewed) like they're on a rail... very precisely fit, and while I've seen a few bedrocks where the frog wasn't quite square to the sole, I haven't seen that with the SW planes. And at the time, the frogs still had a full, smooth surface to mate with the iron. (This changed around WWII.)

-The general fit and finish was great. My favorite SW plane has a stamp of "imperfect" on the side... factory seconds are a pretty good indication to me that quality was definitely one of their priorities. But I still have no idea why it was stamped that way. The rosewood was in great shape, and the plane is pretty much my go-to plane for almost everything. It's a joy to use.

-Bear in mind, this period was just prior to the introduction of hand held power tools, so these tools were being made for customers that actually USED them. I think that makes a difference. I can't quote a source, but I remember reading that they also cost roughly two weeks' wages for a journeyman, rather than the one weeks' lunch money that they go for now.

-One last thing, and I don't know when this stopped, but I can say for sure that the irons were top notch. They were laminated steel, meaning the blank was softer steel, and the edge was good tool steel. Since then they've gone to making the whole blade out of a lesser, but still sharpenable steel, with a much coarser grain. I've taken SW blades to the point where they can easily plane curly maple without tearout. (or at least, without much, as the iron wears)

In my second semester at North Bennet, I took a SW #4 through all of the step in the charlesworth article in his first book, and stuck an aftermarket A2 blade into the thing. Steel being equal, I found no difference in performance from a comparably sized Lie-Nielsen plane that had been properly sharpened.

Starting around WWII, things seemed to start going downhill.

Re: Old Stanley Sweet Heart question

#5

Thanks Todd

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>we can always count on you for reliable tool information