Re: Big chips to small chips
ThomD
>Better both for getting the correct shape, and ease of working, to start with big chips that set up the outline, and work to small chips.
If this were a dowel like handle, paddle etc... one would start by going for an octagon, and then reducing it with further flutes, then doing the final smoothing. That is the way this should go here. Start from the inside curve and cut 45 deg with a Sloyd knife, knife, small draw knife, spokeshave to the corners, working with the grain. Keep removing corners until you can get in there with sandpaper or scrapers. One might think spokeshaves are hopeless, but often if the corners are taken out by hand a lot of shaping can be done with a shave of some kind. The endgrain part is a candidate for coming in from the side with a block plane, etc...
If the idea is I want to use hand tools because I don't own anything else, one could spit shine the holes with a strip of heavy sandpaper. That will tend to leave horrid marks that are hard to get out, unless you use a scraper. Back the strips with tape to make them last longer.
OK, you didn't ask, but whoever clodded up those handles should not be working as a designer:
1) exactly under what circumstances would one use them they look to be too high off the ground? If I am moving it I would grab under a shelf, more comfortable, and more efficient.
2) They do not reflect the shape on the feet. The feet are open to the floor, and create the impression of roots, they do something useful, somewhat, in taking up for wobbly floors, thought in the average house with skirting on the walls they never fit nicely. Whereas the handles are a dead end and lead the eye to an ugly, weak, short grain situation, that looks like it would have been thought up and executed by the router brotherhood. They make an ugly impractical feature, and then draw your eyes to it as a major focal point. It is like a Gerbil wheel: It doesn't move the eye on to contemplate the piece in it's entirety, ones eye will just get trapped circling that carbuncle.
3) I mentioned it above it is weak structurally.
So in summary, bad design, bad execution, bad structure, and bad practicality. Normally even in great designs like Frid's stool I really have to think long and hard to add any little hand holds to a piece. There are beautiful examples, like the Krenov drawer pulls, but they really would have to earn their keep, or I would leave them off. If I felt I needed something up there I would:
Add a dovetail top shelf; taper the top piece from thick on the inside to thin at the top inside. Possibly curve the top, though that has to be approached very carefully. I would under no circumstances put in that childish smiley face. Not your fault of course.