Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

Posts

Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#1

Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

David Brown

>I'm in the middle of building the magazine stand from the link below.

The plans say to use a router and template to shape the D-shaped cutouts. But if I wanted to use hand tools, what is the best method?

I assumed the answer was files and sandpaper, but I'm having a terrible time. It may be that I don't have good files. The only half round one I have I picked up at a flea market and it may not be that sharp. If it is files/rasps, what type should I buy for this type of shaping. It's all end grain and causing problems and is very hard to cut.

My only rasp is a four-in-hand and that's not working at all. It just gives horrible chip out on far side when I take a stroke with the rasp.

Thanks for any suggestions.

--Dave


Magazine Stand

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#2

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Dean J in MN

>I'd cut as close to the layout lines as possible with a turning saw and clean up with rasp/file. Nicholson 49/50 and a smooth cut half round should be all you need. If you really feel the need some sandpaper wrapped on a dowel for the final touch.

-Dean

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#3

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Bob Lang

>I'm working on a similar piece at the moment and my first choice for smoothing the open areas is a hand-cut rasp. Typically I will use a sequence of three, coarse to get the curves even and the saw marks out, then medium and fine to refine the edges. Make a small chamfer on the back side before you start and that will eliminate the tear out problem. If you are raspless at the moment, the ones from Joel at Tools for Working Wood are pretty good. Not quite as refined as the Auriou but pretty close. We also just got some Japanese floats in for testing from The Best Things which look promising as well as a good value. You should be able to get pretty close to a finished surface with the rasps.

hope this helps,

Bob Lang

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#4

Chip out *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Bob Lang comments, "Make a small chamfer on the back side before you start and that will eliminate the tear out problem."

I have, at times, tilted the rasp so that I'm making a large but relatively flat (explanation in a minute) chamfer on one side until I was rasping past the middle of the stock, repeated on the opposite side, rasping in both cases to the layout lines, then smoothed out the resulting hump in the middle. By "relatively flat," I mean a low angle, measured from the face of the work, as opposed to a 45 degree chamfer.

A proper spoke shave might be handy, too, but they're maybe less flexible in their uses than a rasp, and round shaves (what you need) have a definite learning curve - so I'd get the rasps first. Of course, if you're looking for an opportunity to buy tools...possibilities include a wooden shave, the Lee Valley aluminum riff on the wooden shave, or (my fave) a cigar shave. There are so many possible wooden shaves out there, I can't begin to think how to list them; the Lee Valley shave is linked below. I can't recall right now who's still offering the clones of the Millers-Falls cigar shave; maybe someone else knows.

Doing this with hand tools gives you a couple of opportunities that the screamin' whirly tools don't permit (at least not easily): 1) you can make the corners of the "D" cutout square rather than rounded, and 2) you can ease the edges with a tiny chamfer at your choice of angles, making it larger or smaller as it goes around the curve, if that will contribute to the design (don't know: this is something I can never sense from the pictures and would have to experiment with on a piece of scrap pine or something).


Lee Valley shave

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#5

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Marv

>David,

If you want to prevent chip-out on the backside as you rasp, clamp a scrap piece of wood on the back and saw it to the same rough curve shape. Rasp both pieces as if they are one piece. Do all the rasping from the side without the scrape piece.

Marv

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#6

If you are make an accurate reproduction

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I don't think you would use hand tools as the original was surely made with machines. Maybe some hand sanding.

Stephen

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#7

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Alex Grigoriev

>I wish Microplane was making their rasps with "pull" teeth orientation (across the file). Such rasp would work as a coarse spokeshave. You could pull it along the edge not fearing a tearout. "diagonal" oriented teeth would allow to use it as either drawfile or in usual manner.

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#8

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

dave brown

>Bob,

Thanks for the response. I looked at the Japanese floats and they look intriguing for someone like me (meaning cheap!). I can't easily afford the French rasps, but I'd love some.

I could afford some of the Japanese floats. You say you are testing them. Can you provide any feedback yet? Are they realistic alternatives to expensive hand cut rasps or do I need to just save up for the real thing?

Thanks.

--Dave

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#9

Re: If you are make an accurate reproduction

Dean J in MN

>That is a good point. A&C was all about machines. (Well, and a few other things...)

-Dean

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#10

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

George Moore

>A very good quality rasp that is reasonable in price is these from LV. I have been using them for over a year and they do a great job.

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=20133&cat=1,42524

Have a Blessed day.

George

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#11

Re: Big chips to small chips

ThomD

>Better both for getting the correct shape, and ease of working, to start with big chips that set up the outline, and work to small chips.

If this were a dowel like handle, paddle etc... one would start by going for an octagon, and then reducing it with further flutes, then doing the final smoothing. That is the way this should go here. Start from the inside curve and cut 45 deg with a Sloyd knife, knife, small draw knife, spokeshave to the corners, working with the grain. Keep removing corners until you can get in there with sandpaper or scrapers. One might think spokeshaves are hopeless, but often if the corners are taken out by hand a lot of shaping can be done with a shave of some kind. The endgrain part is a candidate for coming in from the side with a block plane, etc...

If the idea is I want to use hand tools because I don't own anything else, one could spit shine the holes with a strip of heavy sandpaper. That will tend to leave horrid marks that are hard to get out, unless you use a scraper. Back the strips with tape to make them last longer.

OK, you didn't ask, but whoever clodded up those handles should not be working as a designer:

1) exactly under what circumstances would one use them they look to be too high off the ground? If I am moving it I would grab under a shelf, more comfortable, and more efficient.

2) They do not reflect the shape on the feet. The feet are open to the floor, and create the impression of roots, they do something useful, somewhat, in taking up for wobbly floors, thought in the average house with skirting on the walls they never fit nicely. Whereas the handles are a dead end and lead the eye to an ugly, weak, short grain situation, that looks like it would have been thought up and executed by the router brotherhood. They make an ugly impractical feature, and then draw your eyes to it as a major focal point. It is like a Gerbil wheel: It doesn't move the eye on to contemplate the piece in it's entirety, ones eye will just get trapped circling that carbuncle.

3) I mentioned it above it is weak structurally.

So in summary, bad design, bad execution, bad structure, and bad practicality. Normally even in great designs like Frid's stool I really have to think long and hard to add any little hand holds to a piece. There are beautiful examples, like the Krenov drawer pulls, but they really would have to earn their keep, or I would leave them off. If I felt I needed something up there I would:

Add a dovetail top shelf; taper the top piece from thick on the inside to thin at the top inside. Possibly curve the top, though that has to be approached very carefully. I would under no circumstances put in that childish smiley face. Not your fault of course.

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#12

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Alexander Grigoriev

>Still you can't draw it along the edge.

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#13

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Peter Evans

>Pick up some old files and rasps from the flea and sharpen them in citric acid (or any acid, but citric is kinder to you). You will be amazed how sharp they get.

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Moses Yoder

>It is hard to say what the radius of the curve is but a spoke shave made for curved work might work for you as well. The trick is to learn to cut a nice cut real close to the line to start with then the cleanup is not nearly as difficult. If you already have tearout around the edges a beveled edge would cover it up. If you send it up here I will clamp it to the cnc router and clean it up for you ;)

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#15

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Darrin

>Turn the blade around, and you can then pull it.

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools *LINK*

#16

Re: Best method for Shaping curves with Hand tools

Alex Grigoriev

>I want to "draw" it along the edge (see: "draw-filing"), not "pull" across.