Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Recommendation for mallet size

Posts

Recommendation for mallet size

#1

Recommendation for mallet size

David Brown

>Aside from the expected puns, do you guys have any recommendations for the best size for a hammer or mallet to use with a chisel for chopping out joinery. I'm thinking about dovetails and mortises mostly. I took a class once and they recommended a tiny 8 oz metal hammer, but it seems small and many mallets are much heavier. I feel the 8 oz is very small for chopping dovetails.

So what do you use and why? Is there a traditional size?

Thanks for any help. I googled this topic and had trouble finding much info, so I assume it's obvious and I'm just a tad dense. So I appreciate your help.

--Dave

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

Jack Guzman from Maine

>As to your last remark,it's not obvious unless you've done it.I like a light carvers style mallet for dovetails and most mortising.For larger mortises or those in tougher woods,I use a heavier mallet of the same design.

You need a mallet that is comfortable for you.I'd suggest trying a few different styles till you find one you're comfortable with.

I've found in woodworking that there are few hard and fast rules. It's whatever works for you.---Jack

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

Moses Yoder

>A light mallet made out of very dense wood like lignum vitae works very well; more of the energy is directed into the chisel. A heavier mallet made out of less dense wood is more work.

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#4

Make a few...

John in NM

>Fairly easy project, then you have some basis for comparison without having to purchase several. The one I use the most is made of a scrap of 12/4 mesquite with an oak handle. Mesquite isn't actually a good choice as its very brittle. Maple would be a lot better and a similar weight. Mine is just a squared up block with the faces cut at a slight angle and a square mortise for the handle. I didn't have a lathe at the time I made it, so I just used a spoke shave to shape the handle out of a 1" square by 12" long (more or less) scrap.

I have another, smaller mallet, that I turned out of a local oak branch when I lived in Tucson. The oak out here is very small, but very dense and tough. I broke the handle on that one about a year ago and I've never gotten around to making another (teak makes a bad handle btw). I've got some hickory on hand for a job, I'll probably use a scrap of that once the project is done.

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#5

Make one or two

roninkokomo

>There are several options. I made mine out of three pieces of birdseye laminated. I drilled holes in the center piece of the laminate and put lead shot in them.

Handle is walnut and put leather on the faces. Works terrific. Had it for 15 years.

I use is also for knocking joints together, thus the leather. Be careful with the handle. I kept shapimg it till I got mine just a tad small.

Ron

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#6

Great, if poignant, line

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"I kept shaping it till I got mine just a tad small."

How many times have I done similar things? Let me count the times...um, no, can't remember but I'd have to take my shoes off even to count recent ones.

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#7

yeah

roninkokomo

>A variant of the old " I cut it twice and it was still too short"

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#8

Re: Great, if poignant, line

Al Goldstein

>Yeah, as my father-in-law used to say - I tightened it up too loose.

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#9

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Dave ... I agree with what others have said.

I have three mallets (round, carver style) that I turned: 8 oz out of maple that I use mainly for DTs; a 12 oz out of walnut that I use for DT's in harder material; a 20 oz out of osage orange that I use for deep mortices. I've been using these three mallets for about 10-15 years and they serve me well.

Best of luck ... rj

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#10

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

ThomD

>I use either a 8 or 14 oz japanese hammer, or I use a 20 ounce rubber carver's style mallet. I have tried just about everything over the last 30 years, and since I am mostly Japanese tool centered, I really would have prefered that I prefered the Japanese hammers. By far the best for me has been the rubber carver's mallet. They sell a 30 oz model also, which might be nice for over 1" material but I haven't ever found one in a store. I prefer the quietness of the rubber, compared to what a hammer sounds like, as well as the dead blow.

Mallets have shorter handles, relative to the center of gravity,, and therefore the swing weight and head speed are lower. So I think that a heavier mallet is required relative to a hammer.

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#11

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dave,

I saw and pare through dovetail waste. For half=blind dovetail waste, I like a dense round carver's mallet. The one I use is made of heavy vera wood, probably about a pound, head is about 3" diam. by 3-1/2" long.

For mortises, what I have found is that I like a heavy, short-handled steel hammer. My favorite is a pound-and-a-half dog's head shape hammer that was used by a Japanese smith. It's short and fat. You get a heavy blow and a dead blow from the weight, but without a lot of head speed, so there is lots of control to keep the mortise plumb.

Funny thing......for heavy work like mortises, I find that the steel hammer is actually easier on the chisel butt than a comparable-weight round mallet.

Wiley

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#12

Horses for courses

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>These are a few rules I keep:

The first one is that the hammer must not damage the chisel. I'd rather replace the hammer (easy enough) than a set of chisel handles. I read of LV-headed mallets with horror!

Marry wooden mallets to unhooped chisel handles, and steel hammers to hooped chisel handles.

The weight of the mallet/hammer head should increase as the blow to the chisel increases. Therefore a "heavy" mallet for a mortice chisel, a "moderate" weight for a dovetail chisel, and a light weight for the very occasional love taps one might give a paring chisel.

"Weight" is relative, and the style of mallet/hammer is also personal.

I have three round mallets, two genno, and a couple of plane-setting hammers. This does not include all the others fopr nails, etc.

Three mallets (a softish Jarrah, some unknown gum, and an unused LV carver)..


Gennos are 300 gm (peeking out of the picture above) and 450 gms

Plane-setting hammers, one from Dave Anderson (8oz)and one of my own (7 oz) ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#13

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

James Watriss

>I learned with an 18oz urethane faced thing... basically, a weighted version of the 12oz. I have one made of maple laminated to a walnut handle, a huge cherry one that I turned out of wood that was still pretty wet, so it's now deformed a little bit, and I generally use it to be brutal, so it's definitely the worse for wear, and should be retired.

Somewhere along the line I picked up one of those little Lee Valley brass headed carver's mallets, and put a longer handle on it. Handle split, because of how they mount the head, so I soaked a linen rag in glue and wrapped it around the split part and voila... it worked like a charm. Poor man's composite makes a good band-aid, and the mallet has worked fine now for years. One of my favorites for a long time. There's something about brass... you don't have to swing it quite as hard to impart a reasonable amount of force to the work. I like it.

Somewhere I picked up a brass calvo mallet that I turned a very long handle for... I almost never use it, but it does look menacing. I also have a knockoff of the Glen Drake mallet... but I mostly use it for the same things mechanics use a brass hammer for... namely anything where you don't want to damage cast iron or deform steel... the hammer is sacrificial. I also used some letter punches to add a personal note on the side of the hammer. You know, to make it mine. Don't ask what the note says, though... I was in a mood that day.

And lately I've switched over to Japanese chisels, so I've been using a Japanese hammer.

In the end, I find wood to be bouncy. Sometimes that's nice, but it means that any mallet you make will end up being fairly large to account for the force lost in rebound. Or, you'll use wooden mallets for more delicate work, since (my opinion and experience, so feel free to flame away) wooden mallets just don't impart as much force, and are therefore much better suited to the delicate stuff.

In general, I'm something a bruiser with swelled up forearms that have left me with meat hooks for hands. I try to carve with hand force only if I can, or use a wooden mallet. But I think that, overall, I prefer the brass mallets for most joinery work, and even for some carving. Very light slow taps can be very delicate, almost pushing rather than driving, and (with the added length on the Veritas) a quick snap can drive a chisel into the work with authority.

One half measure I've seen that I think looks cool, I've seen people epoxy brass faces on hammer-shaped mallets that have denser, exotic wood heads. Keeps the wood from splitting (I hope!) and gives them a lighter mallet to work with. I'm not sure if I'd bother with it myself, but I do think it looks cool.

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#14

Depends, what kind of chisels are you using?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Knowing that I can give a somewhat real response. Also it wood be nice to know what woods you work...

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#15

Re: Depends, what kind of chisels are you using?

David Brown

>Thanks everyone for your responses.

Scott, I use L-N chisels in domestic hardwoods only. For personal ethical considerations, I avoid any exotics. Thanks.

--Dave

Re: Recommendation for mallet size

#16

Well then...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Mallets all the way! Somewhere is a plan for a usable mallet with the secret DT.

I'd be looking for a small(ish) face and the weight of 325g or so. Once you have one, you'll want more...