Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Some data on wood for bow saws

Posts

Some data on wood for bow saws

#1

Some data on wood for bow saws

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The log collection yard down the road has reopened on a vastly smaller scale. (The saw mill it had supported, Gilbert Hardwoods, is bankrupt). The hardwood lumber industry is in more dire shape than the autos with log prices less than half what they were and mills awash in unsold inventory. I filled my trailer with cut offs from where they up-grade logs. It is easy firewood as in many cases the cut-offs are already an acceptable length. I usually split the cut-offs in quarters to enhance drying rate. There is no current market for red oak so there wasn't any of this easy to split species in the pile. Instead there was a mix of maple, cherry, ash and hickory. It has been some time since I encountered any hickory.

It was no trouble splitting anything but the hickory. I could not get it to split with my 8 pound splitting maul. In every case wedges were needed to split even short cut-offs.

This experience suggests that the cross grain strength of hickory is superior to most domestic hardwoods. I am making the assumption that cross grain strength is correlated with ease of splitting. Beech is similarly had to split but I don't have any recent experience to precisely compare to this hickory encounter as beech is only rarely harvested for lumber in these parts.

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#2

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>Hmm. That doesn't sound like any hickory I have ever run into. We don't see a lot of it up here, but the logs I have had experience with have all split very nicely.

greg

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#3

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

ThomD

>Condition and grain (stuff Bill would know) is a big factor. I remember as a child when our huge elm died from DED, it was all I could do to split a piece a day. Elm is the diamond of comon woods, with rowed grain. Though without rowed grain Sitka Spruce has outstanding resistence to splitting in the structural softwood segment. Elm is a little in look like Hickory.

I was using a sledge and a metal wedge. I have since learned that is a poor choice, though a constant in the mater at hand.

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#4

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>My experience splitting beech is that when you crack it, instead of splitting cleanly on a ray or ring, the split will "jump" rings. I think that indicates it's strength cross grain (flatwise tension) that we see in the wood hand book.

There's a lot of american beech in the pocono mountains in PA. I split up a bunch of it in hopes of making planes out of it someday. But it was pretty badly twisted (which I hear is common).

I turned hickory not long ago. I forget why. But it smelled like food and made me hungry. So much of my favorite food is hickory smoked or has artificial hickory smoke flavor added, like those smoke house almonds - they are like bacon in a can. mmmmmm.

Adam

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#5

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Indeed, beech and hickory split (not very well) the same way. When I need to split it I drive a dogwood wedge in the crack made by the steel wedges, remove steel wedges and then saw it apart with the chain saw.

If you are in the neighborhood I will give you some straight grained beech. I doubt I will ever get around to making planes from it.

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#6

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>

Adam,

You wrote:

"I turned hickory not long ago. I forget why. But it smelled like food and made me hungry. So much of my favorite food is hickory smoked or has artificial hickory smoke flavor added, like those smoke house almonds - they are like bacon in a can. mmmmmm. "

Oh yeah, can't agree with you more on that! Back when I was wood turning more I was given a huge chink of mesquite. Just as I was finishing up hollowing a bowl my wife walked into the shop to see what I wanted to do for dinner. She started sniffing and said, "Wow, what are you working on in here! It smells GREAT!". I told her it was mesquite and then asked if she would mind if I cooked on the grill that night. I tell you, my BBQ chicken never tasted better!

Now I have a special bucket in the shop for "BBQ wood cut offs". I just filled it up with some hikory shavings and found some scrap mesquite that was cracked beyond use. I'll shave them up and soak em' in water when it comes time for BBQ'ing. Nothing like a charcoal fire with some mesquite and hickory added. And maybe some apple for "sweetness"!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#7

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Bill ... I don't know a lot about the mechanical characteristics of hickory, but I will pass on the limited experience I've had.

I built a large entertainment cabinet for a client a few years ago and by the time I was done processing a few hundred board feet I had to have two carbide blades sharpened (they started sharp) and I went through two sets of knives on the planer (HSS) and one set on the jointer (also HSS).

It's nice looking material but I have changed my policy: if a client wants me to use it I add the cost of sharpening to the estimate and I tell them I am doing so.

Best regards ... RJ

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

#8

Re: Some data on wood for bow saws

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>When we moved here, 21 years ago, there was a very dead elm, probably 4' on the butt in between my driveway, and my neighbor's- but in the state road right-of-way. I expected the State to take care of it. Nope. It was threatening telephone and power lines, but those two businesses said they'd wait for a line to drop, and fix it ad hoc. But when it dropped a limb, I realized that my kids were in jeopardy, so I paid the $1500 to have it removed. I gave the wood to my neighbor, and I helped him split it with my 15 lb "Monster Maul". I wish I had saved some of that. It made terrible fire wood.

Welsh stick chairs. Mallets. All sorts of good things... Augh.