Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

Posts

How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

#1

How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Sunday, we hit an estate sale and came away with a few things, of which the best is pictured below.

From both the texture of the stone and the quality of the box (I have other Craftsman stones in cardboard boxes), I suspect this is a natural stone. It distinctly appears to have two different textures, with the line between the two sides being pretty darned straight.

This leads to a question, one that the Norton site doesn't address: how are combination natural oilstones bonded? Manufactured stones seem easy enough: you get the different grits lined up before the stone is cooked. But how do you bond natural stones in a way that won't come apart when they get oil or water soaked?


img

Re: How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

#2

Close up of the two textures/grits

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think the division between the two grits appears in this picture moderately well.


img

Re: How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

#3

Looks like Carborundum

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Bill, that looks like run of the mill Si-C (manmade stone) to me.

I've never seen bonded natural stones. I would think you chould glue broken stones, natural or otherwise, using epoxy. I think my friend Paul did. I wonder if teh epoxy will stick okay to an oilly oil stone.

Adam

Re: How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

#4

Bonded Natural Stones *LINK*

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>Belgian blue stones are one example- to quote Wikipedia:

"One of the most revered natural whetstones is the yellow-gray Belgian coticule, which has been quarried for centuries from the Ardennes. The slightly coarser and more plentiful "Belgian blue" whetstone is found naturally with the yellow coticule in adjacent strata; hence two-sided whetstones are available, with a naturally occurring seam between the yellow and blue layers. These are highly-prized for their natural elegance and beauty, as well as for providing both a fast-cutting surface for establishing a bevel and a higher-grit surface for refining it."


Wikipedia entry on Sharpening Stones

Re: How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

#5

Re: Bonded Natural Stones

Joel

>I have one of these natural combo stones. no advantage to it over two stones cemented together. But they are an interesting curiosity.

All stones can be cemented to one another as long as it is done before oiling them.

Re: How are natural combination oilstones bonded?

#6

"Bonded" was not the right word

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I should have said "cemented." There are plenty of modern examples of two different natural stones glued together.