Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

repair and glue used

Posts

repair and glue used

#1

repair and glue used

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>One of the virtues of hide glue advocated by its proponents is that joints can be repaired. As I understand it, the joint is steamed and the combination of heat and moisture softens the hide glue. One procedure someone sent me involved drilling an access hole into a M&T joint and injecting steam to loosen a joint.

I am so frugal that I recover glue brushes, even when I have forgotten them for days. If they have yellow glue hardened in them a brief soak in hot water softens and then washes the glue away. This must be so as I habitually wipe excess glue on my pants and it goes away in the wash.

So my question is, is there any significant difference in taking a joint apart that was glued with hide vs yellow glue, given that each adhesive is readily softened by moist heat?

I am needing some considerable motivation to leave the instant gratification offered by a bottle of yellow glue with a practical expiration date of years into the future.

Re: repair and glue used

#2

Yellow Glue & Repairing Joints

Steve Elliott

>Bill,

My guess based on some recent experiments using yellow glue is that steaming a joint apart and regluing probably won't work. Certainly not with the crosslinking types (Titebond II and III) and I would want to make a test joint and steam it apart if I was going to count on doing it in the future.

One of the glue failures I've seen is yellow glue not sticking to itself after a surface has been coated with it and the glue has skinned over. The joint in question had both surfaces coated and both had become tacky on the surface, then they were clamped together. The desk seemed OK when it left the shop but within a couple of months the joints had worked loose. A close look at the surfaces revealed lines from the glue brush that had applied the glue. The tacky surfaces had stuck together but not bonded with full strength. (I saw this 25 years ago and ever since then I've made sure the glue was wet when it came in contact with either a wood surface or another wet coat of glue.)

Regular yellow glue can dry completely and be reactivated by a combination of heat and moisture, as in the "dry glue" technique used in veneering. I've tried to release veneer that has been glued on using this technique and heat alone wasn't enough to get the veneer off in one piece. I'd be concerned that the amount of heat and moisture needed to get the glue to release would damage the wood, and even if that part worked the re-glued joint might not have good strength unless the reassembled joint was subjected to heating to get the glue layers to link together.

I'm with you on being frugal, but this might cost you more trouble in the long run than what you would save.

Steve

Re: repair and glue used

#3

Re: repair and glue used

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have worked on more furniture that was previously repaired with yellow glue than I would like to admit. The presence of yellow glue can easily double the cost of repair. Old hide glue gets brittle and can often be shattered apart. Warm water will easily remove the old glue or soften it to the point where it can be recoated and reglued. Yellow glue is much harder to take apart without damaging wood, much harder to remove without damaging wood, and does not stick to itself as well. When someone brings a piece with yellow glue, it is nice to say you are too busy. It makes me ill just thinking about it.

Re: repair and glue used

#4

Here, here, I charge three times

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: repair and glue used

#5

hide glue

roninkokomo

>I used to be over on "the porch" all the time. There were some guys over there who restored furniture for a living. They were unanimous. If you want to build an heirloom use hide glue. There is no question that it will need work some time. The only question is how many decades from now. Yellow glue does not allow for repair without out a whole lot of trouble. I have gotten to the place where I really prefer working with hide glue. No question, yellow is more convenient. But, there are some applications where hide glue has a real advantage, For example irregular pieces that are very hard to clamp can be held together for a couple of minutes and set aside to cure without clamping.

I still have yellow glue in my shop... But if I am making something that I think someone may want to keep and pass on... hide glue.

Re: repair and glue used

#6

Re: repair and glue used

Alexander Grigoriev

>Vinegar softens the yellow glue. LV is selling thickened vinegar concoction for that purpose.

Re: repair and glue used

#7

Re: repair and glue used

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I keep vinegar in my shop and I have used it many times for this purpose. It makes the yellow glue kind of rubbery, but is only a marginal help. It does not allow you to wash away the glue like water will with hide glue.

Re: repair and glue used

#8

Agree I have tried

roninkokomo

>

Re: repair and glue used

#9

Re: repair and glue used

ThomD

>I agree with the others that the issue isn't getting joints apart as much as it is what happens next. With HG you can immediately recoat, you do not need to do anything to the surfaces other than reactivate them with more HG, assuming the wood is all there and not in need of repair. The extreme version of this being regluing veneer by simply pressing it back down with an iron.

Guitar necks get steamed apart whatever the glue used. So I don't think the separation of a joint is a big issue.

What bugs me about hide glue, is that by and large stuff I glue stays glued, and the real issue is even assuming the stuff survives our throw away society, will the person down the road who needs to repair it even have the slightest idea what glue was used or be equipped to handle it. I would have said no, a few years back. These days HG is another fetish like hand planing, and the number of people using it is growing all the time. So I can see the point. HG is HG while other glues vary widely so there is an increasing chance that HG will get properly handled where something else might not. That said whether it is worth the bother on the average piece of craft furniture destined for the dumpster is another mater entirely.

I generally prefer white glue to yellow though I like Titebond 1, and it is a yellow glue in colour. Colour is there fore whatever reason, but many of the yellow glues are basically fast grabbing which I don't prefer. Even for something I want to grab fast like a rubbed joint I prefer a more liquid glue that will thin out easier.

Re: repair and glue used

#10

fetish??

roninkokomo

>I really would not call either hide glue or hand planing fetishes. More like learning some lessons that the past can teach us and taking advantage of those learnings.

I would agree that one has to decide whether stuff is "worth it" or not.

We have had many discussions on this board about whether one really saves money by building a few pieces of furniture considering what some have invested in tools new buildings for a shop, Suburban to haul wood in, hundreds of bucks a year in books and magazines, trips to the ER, etc. Not to mention the value of tools we had to have but don't use>....... WE do it because we like to and we want to do it according to what we believe is the way that it should be done.

My dad used to say 97 percent of the population can't tell the difference between good furniture and pretty looking crap and less that half of what is left is willing to pay for the difference. I think he was right.

I will guarantee you that a huge percentage of the population can't tell and doesn't care if a piece was hand planed. But I can and do.

MY .02 OH BTW they found my right coronary artery was blocked 99% on Friday. Angiogram.. Stents. Told me Saturday I could play golf

I waited till last night to keep SWMBO from strangling me. Played nine holes last night..... not well.... but that has nothing to do with my heart. Good to be alive!!

Re: repair and glue used

#11

You have night golf in Kokomo? :) Be well.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: repair and glue used

#12

Glad to hear they found the problem

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>and took action, Ron. Modern medicine is a wonder, when it works well (and kind of scary at times).

And, yes, good to wait a little - our mates can express their love and concern for us in creative ways.

Re: repair and glue used

#13

which leads me to wonder

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>if it wouldn't be a good idea on furniture intended to outlast us to have a "construction notes" piece glued to the underside of the work somewhere not visible in normal configuration, but immediately obvious to the repair person.

Although, in reading furniture repair tomes, I've certainly seen enough on how to determine what kind of glue is present.

Re: repair and glue used

#14

Re: fetish??

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Congrats on the stents! I had 3 installed a year ago, and the difference was substantial and immediate. Damn genes.

Good luck on the golf game.

Bruce

Re: repair and glue used

#15

Re: fetish??

ThomD

>Well call it what you want, but when there are planes that cost 5K, or whatever it's gone beyond the lessons of the past. Nothing wrong with any of that, I've been at this stuff for 30 years so I know the differences too. My point is just that some people are into this stuff for the stuff not only what it can do. The technique or product is the end itself.

Speaking of fetishes and heart disease: Lattest miracle cure is massive doses of vitamin C. I don't know if it is helping my heart but it definetly has reversed some other vascular problems I had that are nearer the surface and observable. Where getting worse for 30 years (also), and inside a week rolled it back 28 years. So I hope it is helping the stuff on the inside I can't see.

Re: repair and glue used

#16

HG construction notes

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I leave detailed construction notes indicating my use of hide glue only I call them glue drips. :)

Adam

Re: repair and glue used

#17

a problem that may be easy to fix

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have gained insight. It is not the taking apart that makes hide glue better than yellow(or white, or PVA) but the joint cleaning necessary for reassembly.

How yellow/white/PVA glue works and how its shortcoming could be overcome(I think):

These glues are an emulsion(latex) of glue balls suspended in water. The glue balls are swollen with some solvent that makes them mushy. When the water evaporates in the joint the loss of water enables the mushy balls of glue to coalesce into a film. When the solvent evaporates the film hardens and becomes strong. New glue will not coalesce with the hardened glue so the bond between new glue and old glue is not strong.

A possible fix for the problem: Maybe one could pre-soften the old glue with some solvent, perhaps the coalescing solvent used in the new glue. Anybody have a contact at Titebond to bounce this idea off of?

Re: repair and glue used

#18

damn!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>that suddenly makes a glue discussion unimportant. I hope all goes well for you. I have been reading that stents are not the best fix in all cases. Get a second opinion.

Re: repair and glue used

#19

second opinion? too late for that

roninkokomo

>I understand there is disagreement about this. I know that some physicians want to treat with medicines and herbals. Kinda risky with 99% blockage in a major coronary artery.

My situation allowed for very little fact-finding and debate.

Yes... some things are more important than glue :)

Re: repair and glue used

#20

light till 9:30.

roninkokomo

>

Re: repair and glue used

#21

Re: fetish??

roninkokomo

>Spending 5k on a plane does not make hand planing a bad thing. It does call into question one's judgement when wonderfool tools can be had for 1% of that amount.

Re: repair and glue used

#22

Re: a problem that may be easy to fix

Alex Grigoriev

>The problem is that the mating surfaces will be sealed (or "sized"?), preventing water evaporation from the new glue. Cured yellow glue just doesn't pass water fast enough.

You have to use solvent-based glue. Or apply more yellow glue, let it cure completely, then apply some solvent (which?) to make it sticky, and assemble.

Re: repair and glue used

#23

Re: fetish??

ThomD

>Are fetishes bad in general or disproportional? Off to drain my 6 grams of vitamin C.

Re: repair and glue used

#24

Re: repair and glue used

Chris Friesen

>Not sure what kind of yellow glue you're using, but TBIII and the Lee Valley yellow glue are both waterproof. I've still got hardened glue in some of my shirts dozens of washes later.