Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

Posts

It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#1

It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Hartville Tool lists them (see link). More wondering about how good they'll be until El Schwarz or Derek Cohen, duke of comparos, get ahold of them.


http://www.hartvilletool.com/category/519

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#2

Irony

David Miller from Iowa

>Can't help but be struck with the irony associated with the fact that all competitors used to copy Stanley models and innovation, and now Stanley is seeking to catch up to Lee Valley and Lie Nielsen.

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#3

Pet Peeve...

Rob Lee

>If I read one more time that they've got an "integrated body/frog" I'm gonna puke...it's a blade bed!

A frog is the separate piece between the blade, and the plane body.

Do all wooden planes have integrated frogs??? How about their LA block - is that an integrated frog as well???

I guess all our B-UP planes have integrated frogs too - and we just never knew it...

That claim detracts from the body of woodworking knowledge...might as well claim a laminated blade too - with only one lamination! Sheesh!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#4

Re: Pet Peeve...

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Rob, I would think that the one-piece construction would actually lend itself to more problems of alignment than less because of warping, etc in the casting and finishing processes. Am I right?

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#5

Why

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Do Stanley 78/289s have a history of warping problems? With sophisticated casting, it should be possible to make a pretty stable blade bed.

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#6

And, by extension

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>a block plane has an "integrated body/tote" or "...body/handle."

Language does change, of course, but it's always a shame to see people wandering away from definitions that make useful distinctions.

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#7

"Gender".

steve mackay

>

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#8

Re: Pet Peeve...

Rob Lee

>Hi Patrick -

A complicated question... to which the answer is - maybe... :)

Certainly, machining on a low angle blade bed is tougher, and tolerances have to be held higher, to avoid bed skew. From the standpoint of the casting - the extra mass of the bed may give porosity problem in the casting back of the mouth.

The again, mating a frog to a body can present a whole other set of tolerance/control problems - as now you're wourking with 3 machined surfaces... but also have the advantage of being able to adjust the geometry somewhat.

Then too, it depends on the production equipment you have, and the quality of your fixtures...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#9

Re: Pet Peeve...

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>You sound like a process engineer, LOL.. yes porosity is the bain of all castings in any material.. harmonic resonance can be used to evaluate castings for density as well

Take care,

Jim

Wondering if Rob knows how find equilibrium with all his X, Y's and Z's ... and knowing the answer is yes, maybe...LOL

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#10

"a nut with integrated threaded hole"

Alex Grigoriev

>

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#11

Re: Pet Peeve...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Rob,

Only those who have spent hours on a milling machine holding tight tolerances can fully appreciate what you are saying. Even the temperature of the room can effect accuracy and consistancy.

A Jig Boring machine, the Mother of all milling machines, must be operated in a temperature controlled room in order to prevent even the machine itself from expanding and contracting too much.

Marv

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#12

All ya have to do is...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Season the cast iron. And yes, pretty much like a frying pan, just different.

Maybe...

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#13

Hmmmm... Comming soon!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The 92 avatar looks like laundry detergent packaging. Funny they put Hock blades on the same page.

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#14

Can you be a little more specific please?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#15

Re: Why

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>You're right Bill. I was thinking about cheap planes from Asia I've seen where nothing is flat, square or straight. I forgot about my LN BU planes.

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#16

Should have said aged not seasoned...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Like a good piece of beef, cast iron needs to be aged. Just let it sit in a somewhat controlled environment and let it relax after forging casting whatever. After a few months then it's ready for finishing. No warp twist or other nasty things happen like you'll see on old stanley planes. Working un(non)-aged it's kinda like squating and flattening a green piece of wood... It's not gonna stay that way for very long.

Cheers!

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#17

Re: Should have said aged not seasoned...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

My post was intended to relate to holding tight tolerances, even on a well "aged" casting.

Marv

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#18

Re: Should have said aged not seasoned...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

So, the aging is to allow the casting to do it's warping and twisting before it is machined? Sometimes, depending on the design of the casting, it can move when metal is removed.

Marv

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#19

Yes before machining... And

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Depending on the piece being finished it couls, duh WOULD be restrained in the -A-, -B-, and -C- datums. Also it might be shimmed up or pressed down before the process to hold nice tight tolerances.

Oh yes, Let's not forget the 2 pass machining process as well.

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#20

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out

Todd Hughes

>I would never buy anything like that when it is so easy to pick up old high quality vintage planes but they are sort of interesting.

I would imagine for a modern made factory plane they are probably made as well as any and I bet alot of people will buy them. If I was LN or LV [esp. LV whose market they seemed more aimed at] these might would cause me some sleep less nights.

I could be wrong but I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for some fair and impartial testing of them.

I would love to see a blind test where work planed with these planes, LN and LV ones and maybe even antique Stanleys are shown to "experts" and have them match up the work with the plane that did it...Now wouldn't that be an interesting and novel way to test something by the actual work it produces?

I think they need to get a better person writting the add copy, description pretty weak and flat. Photos could be better to esp. if they included some action shots with shavings on an old bench etc.....Todd

Re: It seems the new Stanley planes are almost out *LINK*

#21

bow design

paul womack

>I would love to see a blind test where work planed with these planes, LN and LV ones and maybe even antique Stanleys are shown to "experts" and have them match up the work with the plane that did it...Now wouldn't that be an interesting and novel way to test something by the actual work it produces?

Todd - surely ease (even joy) of use should also be a factor?

BugBear