Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Dominy Bench Questions-long

Posts

Dominy Bench Questions-long

#1

Dominy Bench Questions-long

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I decided this year was the year I built a new bench and a tool chest. I have always wanted to build a bench with a slab top and had planned on buying a SYP beam from a local supplier here in Houston. But the supplier sells timbers and so the drying process is not as careful as what I need. Cracks develop and I believe I would experience more problems than I would be able to deal with easily. I wish I had a better understanding of just how wet bench tops were in Roubo's time.

I've gone back to looking at Dunbar's Federalist bench which he detailed in Fine WW (it's really the same as Holtzapffel's bench, I think), the Roubo-style bench that Roy Underhill built, and the Dominy benches mainly. There are others of course but the main issue is building a two piece benchtop. The main portion of the top is a thick, wide slab that is rabbeted at the back and a thinner plank is connected to it to make up the necessary width for the top.

Dunbar screwed a piece of birch plywood to his plank. The Dominy benches were red oak slabs with a hardwood plank. I wonder if anyone knows how they were connected? There are end caps on Dunbar's but none on the Dominy benches. Underhill used endcaps, a tongue and groove and a tool well on his. The Shakers used endcaps and bracing underneath.

The next question concerns the back legs. Underhill attached the back legs to the main slab, Dunbar attached longer back legs to the secondary wood. The Dominy benches have splayed back legs as does Underhill. How are the back legs of the Dominy benches attached? I hope someone can shed some light on these two questions for me; 1)How were the secondary pieces on the Dominy tops attached to the primary slab? and 2)How were the splayed back legs connected?

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#2

Underhill Bench

David Cockey

>Roy Underhill's French/Roubo" bench has a single piece top with a tool tray behind. The tool tray is suspended by a piece at either end which is mortised to the single piece top. However, unlike benches with multi-piece tops and end caps, the end pieces on Roy's bench don't do anything to help support the top, only the tool tray.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#3

Dominy bench

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have a pretty good picture of the large Dominy bench. I am rather certain the back legs are attached (probably mortised) to the main slab and are not splayed. The legs are still not very far apart at the floor. The legs look like 3x5 with only about 12 inches of space between. The back board 2x11 might have been added later; I don't think it is really part of the bench structure. You would not need to do heavy work on that portion. The bench was against the wall both in the original East Hampton shop and at Winterthur and the extra board may have been attached to the wall or studs as well.

I think I would make such a bench from green timbers and let it dry in place. Usually made pith side up.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#4

David and Warren

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>David, your point about Underhill's bench is my point exactly. The end caps are for the secondary part of the top's benefit. Warren, according to Landis, he saw no evidence that the benches were ever attached to the walls. He also states the back legs were splayed and the pictures in his book appear to show that to me.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#5

Splay

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I was looking at a picture in Hummel's book (1968) which is apparently the same picture Landis used 30 years later. Same shavings on the floor. Hummel has another picture which is more of an end view, and Gaynor (1993) has a very clear picture. Not sure it is worth arguing about. It certainly isn't anything close to the amount of splay Underhill used. A small amount of splay would be introduced if the plank was green and has shrunk. Landis says "slightly splayed".

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#6

Re: Splay

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I also notice Landis says only two of the three have splayed legs. The splay is present in many other examples of benches to add stability and that's why I think it was done on purpose. Does your book have any info on how the secondary piece connects with the primary? Thanks also about the back legs connecting to the slab. That makes sense. Because there are no endcaps I wonder how they connect.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#7

Re: Splay *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I thought St. Roy splayed the front legs. At any rate, you can watch his build online (I don't have time right now).

Pam


Woodwright's Shop Season 27

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#8

Re: Splay

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Patrick, I think the ideal thing is to have a single plank as wide as you want the bench. That way you can put the legs at the very back and have your stability. In the case of this Dominy bench, I think the plank, the legs, and the stretchers are the guts of the bench and this board on the back is just an add on. Just to provide more surface for tools and parts, not really a design feature. If I were to add such a piece today, I would just glue it on, though you might hold off if the plank is green. Hope this is helpful.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#9

Re: Underhill Bench

ThomD

>Wouldn't they help restrict warping? Though when a piece has to move there is often little one can do to stop it.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#10

Warren, I have a new problem

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I just committed today to buy a SYP slab from a one-man-operation. I'm getting a 4" thick slab that is 25" wide and about 15' to 16' long. 25" is the widest his mill will cut so I'm leaving about 3" or so behind, ha, ha. I hope the extra length solves the problem with cracks from drying. I guess I'll cut off what has already cracked and then seal the endgrain, build the base, attach the top and then hold on for dear life. How do I get myself into these messes? He tells me it's slash pine but that doesn't grow here in Texas. I would assume it's loblolly, I can hope it's longleaf and who knows? It may be slash pine that somebody planted, I just doubt it. It came off a farm and nobody with a farm in the Texas Gulf Coast needs to bring in "foreign" pines when they're already there naturally in spades.

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#11

Pretty exciting

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>It sounds like you will not have to worry about attaching an auxiliary board or putting splay in the back legs. I think this is a lot more like 18th century practice than the "laminated" tops and will probably look more handsome as well. The various yellow pines are a lot easier to identify when they still have needles on them- not sure you would see a great difference in the wood. Good luck!

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#12

ya but...

V ictor Parisian

>How you going to get that beast home? How are you going to move it once it is home? Do you have a Rugby Club near you to help out? or possibly a couple of those strong lads at the feed store? Better stock up on some beer for their reward.

I want to come see it in person when done.

Good luck,

Victor - enjoying a day off in Pearland TX

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#13

Hey Victor! You like beer?...

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#14

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long------WebKitFormBou

Michael Bush------WebKitFormBoundarymtOL1CimRbAZ5+

>I don't know the answers to your questions, but I just thought I'd post a word of encouragement. Building a bench is a big job, but very special.

Years ago I built one according to Frank Klausz's plan in a FW (an issue that was pretty new when I built it). It's maple, purpleheart, and Goncalo Alves (the vice screws are GA, because of its natural waxiness, and because I had more of it than I could say grace over and never dreamed it would become as expensive as it has).

In his article, Klausz said something like the main difference between European woodworks' relationships to their benches was that some abused their benches and others treated them like pieces of furniture. That has stayed with me.

Because I used a completely different plan I don't know that I can help you do yours, but I do want to encourage you in it. It's one of the most rewarding projects you can do, I think.

------WebKitFormBoundarymtOL1CimRbAZ5+NB

Re: Dominy Bench Questions-long

#15

Ya but...

Victor P

>You can't aford the insurance on this sorry old back.

Besides, there is a Spec's Liquor store just openned on Pearland Parkway not five minutes from my house that carries about 500+/- lables.

Happy thought there.

Victor