Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

Posts

New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#1

New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

wilbur

>Jay van Arsdale, who teaches courses on Japanese woodworking out in the Bay Area, just released a new 2 DVD set on Japanese hand planes. I just watched this DVD over the weekend. I think it's a real good overview of Japanese planes. I've seen Harrelson Stanley's Japanese plane DVD as well.

Jay's DVD has a very practical orientation, a bit more so than Harrelson's, I think. Jay's approach to setting up the sole of a Japanese plane seems to be less fussy than Harrelson's. Jay's explanation of seating the blade in the bed when you have a new dai is also a bit more straightforward, but this is an area that I thought might have been skimmed through a bit quickly.

If I had any criticisms of Jay's DVD, it would be that it seems like it was shot in the "set up two cameras and let's do this in one take" school of filmmaking, and there are parts that could have used a bit more polish. There are times that Jay seems to be rambling a bit, especially with the more theoretical/less hands-on material. On the other hand there are some really nice explanations of aspects of the set up of Japanese planes, especially when Jay is actually physically working on the set up. There are also times that close up pictures are used to illustrate a point, and I think that Jay's DVD could have used more of these. On the Daiku Dojo website photos I've seen the way that Jay uses diagrams in his classes, and it's clear that he uses these diagrams quite effectively.

Jay's DVD provided an important tip to me that made one of my troublesome Japanese planes work much better than it used to. It's when he shows the importance of making sure that the corners of the blade are set so that they are narrower than the throat. My plane had the corners just a bit wider than the throat, and although it was useable, it always gave me problems here and there. I ground down the corners a bit more, and it's incredible how much nicer the plane is to use now. It's also incredible how much of a moron I am for not noticing or figuring this out before.

All in all, I'm quite pleased with the DVD. There's more info on the DVD at the link.


Jay van Arsdale Japanese plane DVD

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#2

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Thanks for the timely review Wilbur. I ordered Jay's DVD over the weekend and should have it early next week.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#3

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't understand how the blade could be wider than the throat. Part of fitting the dai is to accommodate the blade. Care to elucidate?

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#4

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

It's all because I wasn't appreciating the difference between "mouth" and "throat". Here's a closeup of the plane in question.

kanna mouth

What this picture is supposed to illustrate is where the sides of the mouth of the plane and the throat of the plane are. Because of the side grooves that hold the plane blade in place, the throat is narrower than the mouth. The little red arrows show about where the corners of the plane blade used to be before I ground them down more. That's how the blade was wider than the throat, but was otherwise fit to the plane. Hopefully you can see that I have since ground down the corners of the blade so that they fit within the boundaries of the throat.

Because the corners were wider than the mouth, they would try to take a shaving, which then had nowhere to go, leading to clogging. I also think that something was going on with the sidewalls bending the blade because the corners were too wide, since the other problem I had with this plane was a very difficult time getting a full width shaving. Now it's really easy to get this plane to behave.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#5

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Tom Colligan

>Well thank you, Wilbur, for your heads-up about the DVD and esp. your clarification. I don't know how you ever post a picture like this.

Would the DVD be useful for just Japanese planes or for Knight and HNT Gordon planes as well? Thanks again, Tom.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#6

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I see, thanks. The process for laying out the dai that Inomoto-san taught me avoids this problem; but it's good to know if I ever buy another plane ready-made by someone else.

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#7

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

wilbur

>I'm not sure if this DVD is directly applicable to the Knight or HNT Gordon planes, unless you are pulling them. The mechanics of how a Japanese plane works is quite different from a plane being pushed, wooden or otherwise.

Pictures are actually pretty easy -- at least I think so.

What I tend to do is:

1. Use the macro mode on my digital camera if shooting a closeup.

2. Import the photo to my computer and then put it into Powerpoint, which is an easy way of adding arrows and text.

3. My Mac has a utility that allows me to take a screen shot, or a cropped screen shot, which then makes my final picture.

4. Then I upload the photo to Flickr or Picasa, and link to the photo.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#8

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

I'm guessing that the layout for the sides of the throat are taken from the corners of the plane blade that you have?

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#9

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I push and pull all planes, wood and metal, eastern and western. So far they've all done their jobs quite nicely regardless. When I push a Japanese plane, I admit I add a little extra pressure pushing it up as well as forward, but not enough to make it think I'm actually pulling.

However, there's probably no point paying $50 or $60 for advice on making western planes. The HNT, of course, are somewhere inbetween; but the primary thing vis a vis this topic is that their soles are flat, dead flat. Any jamming I've experienced in HNT's was resolved by sharpening the blade.

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#10

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, not at all, the throat width is based on the subblade; so the arrangement is highly dependent on the subblade to blade relationship. This got me wondering, so I checked a couple of planes from Mosaku and Tsunesaburo that I haven't used yet and that, therefore, need to have their dai fitted. Lo and behold, the cutting edges extend slightly beyond the throat sides.

Now if you use a subblade, the only option is to grind the blade corners; but if you don't, you could also open the throat a bit instead. What does Jay say about this?

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#11

Dave Burnard, we need you?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Which also raises questions about how the smiths make the subblades. And it also may answer some questions about why it's so important that the subblade be made to fit the blade by the blade smith. Dave?

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#12

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

wilbur

>On his DVD, Jay puts the blade in the plane, and uses a pencil to draw reference lines to define where the throat is. Then he takes the blade to a dry wheel grinder and knocks the corners down a little, using the lines as a guide. That's pretty much what I did, except I used a Tormek, as I don't have a dry wheel grinder.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#13

Re: New Japanese plane DVD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>On his DVD, Jay puts the blade in the plane, and uses a pencil to draw reference lines to define where the throat is. Then he takes the blade to a dry wheel grinder and knocks the corners down a little, using the lines as a guide.

I suppose that's the only thing to do; but I still wonder about the subblade-blade relationship. Shouldn't the blade corners reflect the subblade width?

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#14

Pam has it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Pam said, "I still wonder about the subblade-blade relationship. Shouldn't the blade corners reflect the subblade width?"

Precisely. Maintain this relationship as part of the regular sharpening routine.

Wilbur knows this; just reinforcing Pam's point for those learning about Japanese planes.

Wiley

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#15

Re: Pam has it

wilbur

>One other way to look at it is that if the throat is based off of the width of the subblade, and the throat is used as a reference for grinding down the corners of the blade, then the corners of the blade should be the same as the width of the subblade.

I forgot to mention that on Jay's DVD, he does go through the setup of the subblade, but he goes on to say that it's better to start learning to use and set up Japanese planes without the subblade first. Personally, I tend to use my Japanese planes without subblades first, then put them in if I run into tearout issues.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#16

Re: Just one more thing.

ThomD

>They should but they often didn't come that way. I think that most of the sets I have had over the years the main blade is not correctly set for the sublade width, or the real world cutting width. It is obviously something they expect the user to set up as they do the over all blade fit, the flatness of the back, etc...

It seems as thought he better blades and sub blages are not made as sets but turned out separately, and matched up. So they just grab a pair where the main blade is wider, and pair them up. That would tend to call for main blades that are too wide, with corners that need cliping.

The idea that the blade should fit within the confines of the mouth sounds pretty basic and one hopes that there is good reason for a 2 DVD set.

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#17

Re: Pam has it

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>For the moment, the main purpose of the subblade for me is as the throat width "measure." They then live in little labelled bags in the cabinet drawer. However, much is made by sellers of having a subblade made by the blade's smith.

However, it's comforting to be able to use a subblade when the situation calls.

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#18

Re: Just one more thing.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but I was surprised that planes from very good vendors, smiths, and dai makers hadn't accommodated the disparity.

Everybody makes 2-dvd sets these days, they can charge more for them; but based on my experience of falling asleep from lack of stimulation (haven't seen Jay's yet), I think I won't be buying more of them. If you can't tell your story in one dvd, I'll just pass. (:

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#19

Re: Dave Burnard, we need you?

dburnard

>It depends on who does the sharpening, the "ears" are often ground off after the blade leaves the smith's hands and goes to the sharpener. There are standard widths for both blade and subblade. Ultimately though when you buy a japanese plane (or any tool), you are expected to do the final setup work yourself. We're still getting used to the concept of not ready to go fresh out of the box.

Adjusting the blade ears to match the subblade (and then maintaining them as they shrink over sharpenings) and adjusting the slowly shrinking dai to fit the subblade are just part of the game. If your work/wood lets you get away without using a subblade then there are several fewer things to worry about. No one gets away without using a subblade once in a while, so you run into cutting edge width issues sooner or later.

Anyone remember the photos of that Korehide blade with the unusual grooved sides? Notice that the cutting edge would stay a constant width over sharpening - no need to adjust the ears! A clever attempt to reconcile the blade width issue against the simplicity of wedged blade design, but it didn't catch on.

------WebKitFormBoundaryuN0wFaWLu8Di+i+p

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#20

Re: Dave Burnard, we need you? Yes.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks for stopping by.

It depends on who does the sharpening, the "ears" are often ground off after the blade leaves the smith's hands and goes to the sharpener. There are standard widths for both blade and subblade. Ultimately though when you buy a japanese plane (or any tool), you are expected to do the final setup work yourself. We're still getting used to the concept of not ready to go fresh out of the box.

I really have no problems with this, particularly no problems with making dai. I think what's a little disconcerting is that I finally find out exactly why a subblade tailored for a blade is so important; but as it turns out, it apparently doesn't matter all that much to the smiths. That's OK, probably just a sales pitch.

Adjusting the blade ears to match the subblade (and then maintaining them as they shrink over sharpenings) and adjusting the slowly shrinking dai to fit the subblade are just part of the game. If your work/wood lets you get away without using a subblade then there are several fewer things to worry about. No one gets away without using a subblade once in a while, so you run into cutting edge width issues sooner or later.

Agreed on all counts.

Anyone remember the photos of that Korehide blade with the unusual grooved sides? Notice that the cutting edge would stay a constant width over sharpening - no need to adjust the ears! A clever attempt to reconcile the blade width issue against the simplicity of wedged blade design, but it didn't catch on.

I'd forgotten all about that; but yes, that would resolve some of these issues, assuming a wooden tongued abutment would last more than 10 minutes. :)

Pam

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#21

Re: Dave Burnard, we need you? Yes.

dburnard

>Sorry my description led you astray, I should have said the sides of the blade were rabbeted along it's length on the ura face. So blade still held in tapered wooden slot. So the only change to the dai is that the slot isn't quite a thick as the full blade (since the rabbet has removed some material).

Re: New Japanese plane DVD *LINK*

#22

Re: Dave Burnard, we need you? Yes.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>IIRC, the blade wasn't tapered either, which was why, as it was sharpened, it stayed the same width (side to side). Is that correct?

Pam