Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

frame saws in british immigrant invetories

Posts

frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#1

frame saws in british immigrant invetories

Jerome Bias

>I was recently reading through some late 1700's early 1800's estate inventories of cabinetmakers who have immigrated from England to Petersburg Va. A number of the had frame saws in their inventories.

Would these most likely have been turning saws or continental frame saws (non-panel)? I would expect to find a turning saws, but I wouldn't expect to have them called frame saws. I don't know why not. But I wouldn't.

Also being British trained I didn't expect them to have frame saws.

Thanks,

Jerome

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#2

One possible explanation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jerome,

I am wondering if these saws were veneer saws, which would have had the blade tensioned in the middle and at right angles to the plane of the frame.

The time period you are describing is called the Federal period in America. During this time, furniture makers on both sides of the Atlantic used a lot of veneer. Robt. Mussey's book, "Furniture Masterworks of John & Thomas Seymour", describes the overall commerce around Boston where the Seymours, who were English transplants, did most of their work. High figured veneers were hand sawed from imported logs, like mahogany, ebony, she-oak, and satinwood; as well as domestic species such as birdseye maple and crotch birch.

The question though is whether the cabinetmakers bought logs and sawed their own veneer, or whether there were veneer specialists in those days, who would saw and sell sequenced flitches to cabinetmakers. Either way, the veneer was sawed, but the question was, 'who did the sawing'? Mussey implies it could have been either way--he says (p. 87) "One of the Seymours' favorite veneers was an unusual curly mahogany with a dramatically striped figure. Its natural rarity and the frequency of the Seymours' use from between 1805 and 1810 suggests that they may bought one large log or flitch of these figured mahogany veneer leaves and used it over a long period of time until their supply was exhausted."

If cabinetmakers tended to buy logs and saw their own veneers, then the frame saws you're reading about could have been veneer saws, even if they had plate saws for ripping.

Wiley......speculating

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#3

mystery

paul womack

>The other kind of frame saw is used in a pit (or on a stand) for converting logs into planks - surely this is commoner (and hence more likely)?

BugBear

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#4

Re: mystery

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, especially in the colonel period when people are building new cabins left and right. Petersburg is only a few miles west of Williamsburg, south of Richmond.

Pam

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#5

Re: frame saws in British immigrant inventories

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If the inventories say 'frame saw' then it was probably a frame saw. The webs on veneer saws are much wider and many times had more than one web or blade. And turning saws were also named. These names were common among woodworkers but not necessarily someone preparing a probate inventory, so the names may not be correct. Then some inventories seem to name the tools correctly.

Also coming from England or Europe they did a lot more hand sawing and had to prepare a lot of timbers and boards. In America a lot of the stuff came from sawmills to close dimensions, so there was less sawing in board preparation.

Also in the US the circular saw was used to cut veneers in the early nineteenth century. The Europeans commented on the wasteful practices of the Americans.

Stephen

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#6

Possibilities

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I don't think the fellows making the inventories envisioned us trying to decipher them 200 years later. I can think of many possibilities: pit saw, buck saw, felloe saw, turning saw, veneer saw, compass saw, and the bow saw and more. I think some of these terms are favored by us today just because they are not ambiguous.

Charles Hummel illustrates the Dominy's "frame or veneer saw", but notes that judging from the large volume of documented work the Dominys probably never actually made veneer. So maybe they never called it a veneer saw. Without looking at your inventories, I think this is a good possibility.

Sometimes an ambiguous term can be judged by the other terms in the inventory. Whip saw is an ambiguous term. When you see whip saw, cros cutt saw, pannel saw, whip looks like a pit saw. And when you see pit saw, whipping saw, hand saw, it looks like a cross cut saw.

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#7

What I am really wondering

Jerome Bias

>Hmmmm.

I guess what I am really wondering is would British trained cabinetmakers routinely have continental saws in their tool chest or as an alternative to plate saws?

The clientele of Petersburg liked their furniture neat and plain they only took federal kicking and screaming. And many times without veneer. Some of it looks rather... well you can tell where it is from.

Jerome

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#8

picture of pit/frame saw 

paul womack

>


img

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#9

Re: picture of pit/frame saw

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Paul,

That type of pitsaw is the earlier version. One wouldn't expect to see Englishmen with such a saw in 1800. That's a 17th c style tool that was used until the early 18th. I think the image you reference is from 1720? I always wondered if framed pit saws indicated iron blades. My guess is no, but that's the issue behind the design. When they could make blades stiff enough to push they skipped the frame.

Adam

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#10

Re: Possibilities

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Jerome,

You could easily tell by the value given the tool. And I can add one more possibility- the Morris frame saw which is a sort of coping saw. Otherwise, most inventories I've seen include a frame saw. And Warren is right, this term was used for all of the above.

Adam

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#11

saw age

paul womack

>That type of pitsaw is the earlier version. One wouldn't expect to see Englishmen with such a saw in 1800.

I've seen such saws in local auctions, in fairly good (i.e. usable) condition. Either they're tremendously durable, or they were used a good deal later than 1800.

BugBear

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#12

Holtzapffel, circa 1850

paul womack

>The pit frame-saw, fig. 076, in commonly used for deals, and for such pieces of the foreign hard woods as are small enough to pass between its frame, which is about two feet wide.

The frame-saw blade has two holes above or at the wider end, and one below, and is attached to the wooden frame by two iron buckles or loops, which are split about half way round. The upper buckle fits squarely and firmly to the top head, and receives, above its lower side, two pins passing through the holes in the saw. The lower buckle is similarly cleft, and receives one pin only; this buckle is drawn tight by a pair of equal or folding wedges, beneath the bottom transverse piece.

The blade is usually five or six feet long, and thinner than that of the whip saw, which latter although it may be used for the widest timbers, is more wasteful.

He gives every impression that he is writing of current technology.

BugBear

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#13

Thanks

Jerome Bias

>I suspected that these options might be a more likely candidates.

Thanks for the help.

Jerome

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#14

Re: Holtzapffel, circa 1850

Don McConnell

>Bugbear et al,

I think there is a good deal of reason to believe Holtzapffel, in writing of (pit) frame saws, was writing of current technology at the time of publication (1846 for Volume II). Smith's _Key_, published in 1816, illustrates "Frame Saws" which match Holtzapffel's description, and the Marshes & Shepherd price list (likely dates, 1841-1849), keyed to Smith, lists them in four grades and ranging in length from 4 to 7 feet. Also, they are still listed in the 1871 _Illustrated Sheffield List_, in a wider range of lengths, at the same prices. So they were still being made in Sheffield at least through the third quarter of the 19th century.

So I guess the question may be whether they were still in use in England during this period, or whether they were only being exported to other parts of the world? I can't answer that definitively at the moment, but think there is some decent circumstantial evidence to indicate a likelihood that they were still in use in England. For that, I turn to the reports about the London sawyer's trades which Henry Mayhew published in the _Morning Chronicle_, July 4, 1850. The total number of sawyers (four main trades: hardwood, timber, cooper's stave and shipwright sawyers) in the London metropolitan area, at the time of Mayhew's survey, was 1,595 This was down from about 2,978 at the time of the 1841 census (when there were 23,360 sawyers in all of England).

Further, the sawyers Mayhew surveyed indicated that they were working, on average, far fewer days during any given period. The general impression is that they had been largely relegated to small jobs which wouldn't pay for a saw mill to take on. Included among these jobs were those described as "one cuts" - which I take to mean resawing jobs. Just the kind of work mentioned by Holtzapffel as appropriate for this type of saw. So, this type of saw would have been useful in London at mid-century.

So, I believe the frame saws in the inventories which Jerome asked about could have been of this type, for resawing tasks. Though, as has already been pointed out, the term frame saw may not have been so specifically used by the people taking these inventories. However, as has also been pointed out, it may be possible to get some idea as to what type of saw is represented in these inventories by looking at relative values. Toward that end, I thought I'd include a few comparison prices from the Marshes & Shepherd price list.

Frame Saws, six feet:

Common (possibly iron?) 14 s

German Steel 22 s

Cast Steel 24 s

Cast Steel, Warranted 29 s

Veneering Webs, 55 inches

Cast Steel 14 s

Turning Webs - set & sharped, 24 inches

Cast Steel 2 s

Felloe Saws, set, 5 feet

15 s

Hand/Pannel Saws - 26 inches

German Steel 5 s 4 d

Cast Steel 6 s 2 d

Cast Steel, Warranted London Spring 7 s 6 d

While the values in the inventories will not likely reflect the exact same relationship as found between the above prices, I think it might well be possible to narrow the possibilities down. In other words, if the value of a frame saw in one of these inventories is considerably more than a hand saw, then it likely is a veneer, felloe, or frame (pit) saw. If the cabinetmaker is known not to do veneer work, then it may be possible to eliminate the veneer saw. If it is closer in value to a hand saw, then it may be a turning saw.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: frame saws in british immigrant invetories

#15

Re: Holtzapffel, circa 1850------WebKitFormBoundar

Don McConnell------WebKitFormBoundary+BmdKMcQLIfPe

>Bugbear et al,

I think there is a good deal of reason to believe Holtzapffel, in writing of (pit) frame saws, was writing of current technology at the time of publication (1846 for Volume II). Smith's _Key_, published in 1816, illustrates "Frame Saws" which match Holtzapffel's description, and the Marshes & Shepherd price list (likely dates, 1841-1849), keyed to Smith, lists them in four grades and ranging in length from 4 to 7 feet. Also, they are still listed in the 1871 _Illustrated Sheffield List_, in a wider range of lengths, at the same prices. So they were still being made in Sheffield at least through the third quarter of the 19th century.

So I guess the question may be whether they were still in use in England during this period, or whether they were only being exported to other parts of the world? I can't answer that definitively at the moment, but think there is some decent circumstantial evidence to indicate a likelihood that they were still in use in England. For that, I turn to the reports about the London sawyer's trades which Henry Mayhew published in the _Morning Chronicle_, July 4, 1850. The total number of sawyers (four main trades: hardwood, timber, cooper's stave and shipwright sawyers) in the London metropolitan area, at the time of Mayhew's survey, was 1,595 This was down from about 2,978 at the time of the 1841 census (when there were 23,360 sawyers in all of England).

Further, the sawyers Mayhew surveyed indicated that they were working, on average, far fewer days during any given period. The general impression is that they had been largely relegated to small jobs which wouldn't pay for a saw mill to take on. Included among these jobs were those described as "one cuts" - which I take to mean resawing jobs. Just the kind of work mentioned by Holtzapffel as appropriate for this type of saw. So, this type of saw would have been useful in London at mid-century.

So, I believe the frame saws in the inventories which Jerome asked about could have been of this type, for resawing tasks. Though, as has already been pointed out, the term frame saw may not have been so specifically used by the people taking these inventories. However, as has also been pointed out, it may be possible to get some idea as to what type of saw is represented in these inventories by looking at relative values. Toward that end, I thought I'd include a few comparison prices from the Marshes & Shepherd price list.

Frame Saws, six feet:

Common (possibly iron?) 14 s

German Steel 22 s

Cast Steel 24 s

Cast Steel, Warranted 29 s

Veneering Webs, 55 inches

Cast Steel 14 s

Turning Webs - set & sharped, 24 inches

Cast Steel 2 s

Felloe Saws, set, 5 feet

15 s

Hand/Pannel Saws - 26 inches

German Steel 5 s 4 d

Cast Steel 6 s 2 d

Cast Steel, Warranted London Spring 7 s 6 d

While the values in the inventories will not likely reflect the exact same relationship as found between the above prices, I think it might well be possible to narrow the possibilities down. In other words, if the value of a frame saw in one of these inventories is considerably more than a hand saw, then it likely is a veneer, felloe, or frame (pit) saw. If the cabinetmaker is known not to do veneer work, then it may be possible to eliminate the veneer saw. If it is closer in value to a hand saw, then it may be a turning saw.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

------WebKitFormBoundary+BmdKMcQLIfPesXX