Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Hand Tools vs Machines

Posts

Hand Tools vs Machines

#1

Hand Tools vs Machines

DaveK

>I am a long time lurker and hand tool lover recently left the corporate world with time to pursue woodworking. My question is how many on this forum are strictly hand tool users or do you use a combination of machines and hand tools specifically for milling and use a bandsaw or tablesaw as part of the process. I have a bandsaw and jointer/planer but dont really enjoy the dust and or noise from either and will likely need to break down and buy some form of dust collection if I keep them.

My objectives are not driven by time or desire to make and sell furniture but want to develop my skills and enjoy woodworking as a hobby.

Thanks

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#2

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

wilbur

>Hi Dave,

Although I like doing woodworking with hand tools whenever possible, I do have some machines. My machinery collection is a lot like yours: bandaw, jointer/planer, drill press, and lathe.

There are varied reasons for these machines. Although I know how to mill boards by hand, I do find the jointer/planer to be much faster if I have stuff to do in batches. I'll get close to final thickness with the planer, and then finish up with hand tools.

Likewise, for big cuts, the bandsaw is a faster way to go, although I know I'll be tuning up the cut with hand tools.

I have a lathe because there isn't a hand tool way of turning a bowl (and yes, I already know about spring pole lathes).

I have a drill press because I am bad at drilling. :@)

You absolutely need to get some sort of dust management going, especially if using a bandsaw. Even if you are sawing by hand, an air cleaner is a nice thing to have to get the dust out of the air.

If you enjoy milling boards by hand, however, more power to you, and don't feel bad about dumping your jointer/planer. Likewise, don't feel compelled to do everything by hand. As long as you enjoy what you are doing, that's the most important thing.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#3

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>And then there's that project that just won't go with strict hand tool only use.

I'm building a couple of Windsor high chairs from John Kassay's book. The seats are supposed to be white pine, but what I could find in the right size, air dried, and available here in California, turned out to be, reportedly, Italian Stone Pine. The stuff chips out badly when cut with your tongue in the wrong position. Takes nasty divots with a travisher or sweep. And you can't rasp every shape in the seat.

Turners use a Milwaukee close quarters electric drill. Mount a soft velcro sandpaper pad, and clip on some 80 grit, and the divots all go away. The shop cleanup takes a lot longer, though.

But it is a hand tool. Of sorts.

Purity counts for a lot in some parts of my life. Not in woodwork.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#4

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Paul M.

>There's a reason that the bandsaw is sometimes called the neanderbuddy. Using hand tools on anything that requires accuracy or finish is a true joy. Using hand tools for large sawing jobs is not.

I'm not into speed at all, as I'm do this for a hobby and not a living. But I resawed a couple of wide hardwood boards with a quality Japanese rip saw before I realised that my spare time can be used doing something much funner than that. It just plain sucked.

Any cuts I do for joinery purposes are done by hand and cleaned up with a shooting board if necessary. Any cuts for milling or lumber resizing purposes are done by the bandsaw.

I have to admit that owning a shopsmith has been quite instrumental in developing my love for using hand tools. That awful tool now works primarily as my assembly table. I haven't found a single thing it does well. I'm waiting for the economy to pick up a bit before trying to sell it. It would be pointless to try now.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Dave,I'm a carpenter by trade so I use power tools all the time.My woodworking shop is mostly equipped with hand tools though,but I use power tools where I find it more efficient.I will hand work a board to get it flat if it's too wide for the power tool.For most jointery I use hand tools but will do some tasks with power if it makes more sense to me.I don't enjoy operating the table saw and am actually a little fearful of a router(which I seldom use).The jointer and planer are noisy,messy and require constant adjustment and maintenance.I love paring a joint to perfection with a chisel,jointing two boards with my #7,chopping mortises,getting perfect dovetails with hand tools,etc.. Hand tools are enjoyable.Power tools are necessary evils.

Don't worry about what's right. Do what works for you and enjoy the craft.---Jack

P.S. I used a chainsaw this afternoon to create a scarf joint in a 6x6 beam. It was the best tool on hand for the job.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#6

A lot of good advice here

Roy Anderson

>I have to say that I agree with most of the points of view here. I do the fun stuff with hand tools and the dog work with power tools. Bulk ripping by hand is grunt work. I use a table saw, but I'm seriously considering dumping my table saw and going with the "neanderbuddy".

I have a jig saw, a hand drill, a router and a table saw. That's it. My table saw doubles as an assembly table with a sheet of MDF on top. I've only used my router a couple of times and don't really know how to use it yet. Besides, I hate the noise and the dust.

Also, I think it's worth pointing out that you will always get a certain amount of "honey do" projects that mostly call for efficiency and not pleasure. Power tools come in handy there.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#7

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

James Watriss

>I've been where you are, setting up home shop and whatnot.

This is a discussion I've seen in various forms, in various forums, too. The guys on the Festool boards are constantly debating whether or not to ditch their tablesaws, and there's a discussion up right now about whether to go with a Laguna band saw or a Sawstop table saw.

I'm not a purist, by any stretch, despite my North Bennet upbringing. There are times when it's great to be able to work on your skills, but eventually you'll find skills that you really find tedious. It can be fun to learn to mill stock by hand. But I think you'll find that it's long, boring, tedious work, that is greatly enhanced by an ability to sharpen, but in the long run, you'll start to find that while efficiency may not be an end goal, it is nice to finish projects and move on. Every project will have its good points and a few mistakes throw in, and it's refreshing to be able to start from scratch... but the prospect of going back and planing everything again can get to be a real drag.

That said, dust collection for a jointer or planer is a must, and a GOOD set of hearing protection earmuffs is key. I suggest you look up an industrial supply place like mcmaster.com for good ones... woodcraft and lee valley are great boutique tool dealers, but they don't really cater to the industrial workaday crowd. Earplugs work ok. Muffs are a lot easier to use and work better, I think. And I think you'll be a lot happier using the machines that will make you happier doing woodworking i your ears aren't ringing when you're through. Cutting dovetails with a headache is no fun.

Band saw over table saw any day for a home shop. Table saws are great for some things, but the band saw can do just about all of those things, with the exception of cutting dadoes, and handling plywood. Routers can handle dadoes really well, and hand held circular saws are a lot easier to move over a sheet of ply than a sheet is to move over a table saw. Finally... band saws have a much smaller footprint by far, and they can be tucked away a lot more easily when they're not in use. I had a contractor's saw in my basement for a while, but it became a real drag, because there wasn't a lot of room to do much else very comfortably. But I do recommend a 16 or 18" band saw. The table is a bit lower, which makes rough breakdown a lot easier to do. It's just a better working height. Whatever you have will be fine, I'm sure, but if you ever find yourself in the market again, bigger is better, to a point. 18 seems to be a great all around size.

If you're now out of 'the world,' and you have time to spend in your shop, I would suggest that you also take the time to make sure to arrange it in a way that makes it easy to work in. My home shop was such that I could handle working in it for 2 or 3 hours. Since then I've set up twice more, and I can say that layout makes a huge difference, as does lighting, and good storage. The ability to get in there and get things done is really conducive to both learning and working. And you'll get a lot more out of your time in there if you're not being frustrated.

My .02

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#8

Mostly hand tools, but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I have a TS, rarely used except for an assembly table. A bandsaw, my favorite power tool, and a drill press used when accuracy matters. I do not own a jointer or planer. I have a few routers and mic. hand held power tools that are hardly used now.

If I was ever to buy another power tool it would probably be a planer.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#9

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

ThomD

>I have something like 25-30 stationary power tools, though not all are accessible. I think a lot of the power VS. hand discusion would go away if one had separate rooms for them. It isn't much fun combining them, and things really went to heck around here when I moved my yacht into the workshop.

I think it pays to decide whether you are interested in producing stuff, or playing. If I was purely interested in playing (and in a lot of ways that is preferable), then I think it is possible to limit the work one does to hand tools and and enjoy the variety there is there. When it comes to production, one thing inevitably leads to the next and power tools spring up like daisies.

Challenge wise a lot of the most interesting work I do is probably with power tools. Both power and hand tools can be set up to make cuts relatively automaticaly. A table saw and a hand plane both fence the cut, but if anything it is a little more dicey with a table saw than a plane. Hand grinding and power grinding are pretty freehand but again the power grinding is probably more challenging. So power tools can be very interesting to use if somewhat harsh at times.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#10

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Dave,

For me, it varies a lot according to type of project and how large it is. I am strictly a hobbyist. By type of project, I mean furniture vs. carpentry. About a year ago, I had a section of picket fence to replace, and I ripped those pickets as fast as I could on the bandsaw (don't have a tablesaw), and ran them through the lunchbox planer since this was mostly recycled wood of different thickness, and some with paint still on it. I just wanted to get her done.

Right now, I have a smallish project (Krenov wall cabinet) that will be done almost entirely with handtools, including ripping and some resaw. It's a small job. For a larger furniture job, like a big chiffonier or other piece of case goods, where you have a big stack of roughsawn lumber to prep and size for joinery, I would and have used bandsaw and planer to get through the surface preparation and into joinery.

It helps to have a kind of 'world view' of what you're doing. From 30,000 feet, there is a spectrum of hand/machine usage that one could break down like this:

Level 1-Hand Tools Only

Level 2-Machines for stock preparation; hand tools for shaping, joinery, and ornament.

Level 3-Machines for every operation which can be done by machine; hand tools for ornaments (finials or pulls, say), or curved parts (Queen Anne legs, say) which do not lend themselves to machining.

-I doubt there is a 'machine only' level, unless you are going to make only rectilinear things--maybe some Stickley pieces can be machine only.

There are sublevels to the above. For example, a group of Level 2 woodworkers would be seen doing things a little different from each other. Some would start from roughsawn, some from S4S lumber. Some would do all the dimensional sawing and thicknessing by machine, and others would flatten one side of a board by hand, and run the other side through a thickness planer. A Level 1 (Hand Tools only) worker would leave many boards unthicknessed, thicknessing only those where it was essential, and leaving rough planing on the interior sides of case pieces or the bottoms of drawer bottoms, for example.

Some Level 3 (max. machine) workers would do final edge jointing by machine; others would run a hand plane over the machine-jointed edge to get the final surface for gluing.

At a practical level, if I were you, I would keep those two paid-for machines, the band saw and jointer/planer. The only reason I would get rid of them would be if you were short of space, and needed their footprint for your handtools bench. Their noise can be dealt with by ear muffs--gun shops have good ones. Do some hand ripping and resawing, and that will inform you whether it is worth hanging onto your bandsaw. Six square a couple of boards by hand, and that experience will tell you whether you want to use your jointer/planer on a regular basis.

By the way, going Hand Tools only is not a good way to save money, if that is in the back of your mind. You will need a lot of stuff, unless you already have your tools in hand. That is another reason why it would be a good idea to hang onto what you have until it becomes clearer to you what the choices and tradeoffs really are.

Wiley

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#11

Machine only level

wilbur

>"I doubt there is a 'machine only' level, unless you are going to make only rectilinear things--maybe some Stickley pieces can be machine only."

Just wait for the day that home CNC machines become available. :@)

Actually, one of the professional woodworkers in our woodworking club thinks this is quite feasible, given how quickly the prices of industrial CNC machines have come down over the past decade.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#12

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"I doubt there is a 'machine only' level, unless you are going to make only rectilinear things..."

I've observed in the magazines people doing curved work by machine - bandsaw, spindle sander, etc. My observation, though, is that there's a tendency to amend the work to fit the requirements of the machine - that is, the final product is more rectilinear than something produced by hand.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#13

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Wonder if Norm Abrams of This Old House does anything using hand tools? Maybe a hammer? A paint brush?

Marv

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#14

Not on TOH but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I saw him pull out a handplane once on NYW. He also reaches for a chisel now and again.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#15

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Victor Parisian

>You must have missed the episode where they were high up in some wilderness area rebuilding a cabin with all hand tools. No power tools allowed on site. He did a fair bit of work with hand tools on that segment.

Victor - enjoying a rare cool evening in Houston

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#16

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

DaveK

>Hi Everyone,

I would like to thank you all for your varied and interesting responses to my question I believe the conclusion I can draw is focus on making furniture and let the end result speak and not the debate with respect to process. The machines are paid for and I intend to keep them and use when needed while continuing to develop my hand tool skills.

Now my next question wooden vs metal planes!....LOL I enjoy both.

Dave

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#17

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

Dan Donaldson

>Metal or wood, pins or tails first ....

Might be better to stick to non-controversial subjects like politics or religion ;-)

Actually, I like both wood and metal bodied planes, depending on the application and my mood at the time.

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#18

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines------WebKitFormBoundary

Mark Grable------WebKitFormBoundaryAADVAA+gAAStAA7

>The best advice anyone has given me was to be good friends with your

tools. When using hand tools, they don't have to be very dull before

you are using more energy forcing them to work than it would take to

sharpen them. Using an edged tool on sandpapered or dirty wood with

hand power will instruct you on how quickly the edge disappears. When

you then go to power tools, you won't be so tempted to keep going when

you should stop an sharpen the blade, or tune up the machine.

At some point, a tool will use a human being. So choose your work and your tools wisely. If you love the material and the tools, you don't need a lot of skill; the mutual respect develops real trust and care.

Returning to the work with enthusiasm and frequency is what develops skill.

------WebKitFormBoundaryAADVAA+gAAStAA7u

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

#19

Re: Hand Tools vs Machines

ThomD

>I have done a lot of boat work, it tends to be curved, and it tends to be a province of power tools, if you have them. Every tool limits the outcome in the work, an extreme example being carving tools where a myriad of individual chisels are relied on for their individual flavour.