Re: Hand Tools vs Machines
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Dave,
For me, it varies a lot according to type of project and how large it is. I am strictly a hobbyist. By type of project, I mean furniture vs. carpentry. About a year ago, I had a section of picket fence to replace, and I ripped those pickets as fast as I could on the bandsaw (don't have a tablesaw), and ran them through the lunchbox planer since this was mostly recycled wood of different thickness, and some with paint still on it. I just wanted to get her done.
Right now, I have a smallish project (Krenov wall cabinet) that will be done almost entirely with handtools, including ripping and some resaw. It's a small job. For a larger furniture job, like a big chiffonier or other piece of case goods, where you have a big stack of roughsawn lumber to prep and size for joinery, I would and have used bandsaw and planer to get through the surface preparation and into joinery.
It helps to have a kind of 'world view' of what you're doing. From 30,000 feet, there is a spectrum of hand/machine usage that one could break down like this:
Level 1-Hand Tools Only
Level 2-Machines for stock preparation; hand tools for shaping, joinery, and ornament.
Level 3-Machines for every operation which can be done by machine; hand tools for ornaments (finials or pulls, say), or curved parts (Queen Anne legs, say) which do not lend themselves to machining.
-I doubt there is a 'machine only' level, unless you are going to make only rectilinear things--maybe some Stickley pieces can be machine only.
There are sublevels to the above. For example, a group of Level 2 woodworkers would be seen doing things a little different from each other. Some would start from roughsawn, some from S4S lumber. Some would do all the dimensional sawing and thicknessing by machine, and others would flatten one side of a board by hand, and run the other side through a thickness planer. A Level 1 (Hand Tools only) worker would leave many boards unthicknessed, thicknessing only those where it was essential, and leaving rough planing on the interior sides of case pieces or the bottoms of drawer bottoms, for example.
Some Level 3 (max. machine) workers would do final edge jointing by machine; others would run a hand plane over the machine-jointed edge to get the final surface for gluing.
At a practical level, if I were you, I would keep those two paid-for machines, the band saw and jointer/planer. The only reason I would get rid of them would be if you were short of space, and needed their footprint for your handtools bench. Their noise can be dealt with by ear muffs--gun shops have good ones. Do some hand ripping and resawing, and that will inform you whether it is worth hanging onto your bandsaw. Six square a couple of boards by hand, and that experience will tell you whether you want to use your jointer/planer on a regular basis.
By the way, going Hand Tools only is not a good way to save money, if that is in the back of your mind. You will need a lot of stuff, unless you already have your tools in hand. That is another reason why it would be a good idea to hang onto what you have until it becomes clearer to you what the choices and tradeoffs really are.
Wiley