Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Couple of odds and ends

Posts

Couple of odds and ends

#1

Couple of odds and ends

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

1. A stain remover. Couple of days ago, a purple iris blossom fell overnight from its vase down onto the curly maple chest top that the vase was sitting on. I think it took some water with it. Anyway, the iris sat there overnight, and by morning I had a nice purple stain on the chest top. I got out a card scraper, and scraped away what was left of the iris bloom, to reveal the stain underneath. Scraped away the shellac, and there was still stain down through into the wood. Took a couple of plane shavings, and discovered the stain was pretty deep into the wood. 3% household peroxide didn't do anything to the stain except raise the grain.

It happens that I've been working with a metallurgist on preparing steel samples for microscopic examination. One of the items you use in the preparation sequence is Nital, specifically 2% nitric acid in alcohol (methanol). The dilute acid is used to etch the metal to reveal its structure. Anyway, after a test on scrap, I dabbed Nital onto the purple iris stain. It began taking it out. I've made 4 applications so far, and the stain is about gone, leaving the light maple surface just as original. Well, we'll see if there is any rebound discoloration from the nital, but I plan to make another application or two, rescrape the surface, and replace the shellac and call it good. If there are no rebound effects from the Nital, this stuff is a first rate stain reducer.

Chemical note: Nital is typically mixed with methanol, because nital + ethanol evolves gas and becomes explosive at higher concentrations (like 10% nitric). Bill Tindall, who is a professional chemist among other talents, may have additional remarks.

2. Ultimate hone. One other item which is useful in metallurgical sample preparation is diamond paste. Foror a final polish, the paste is sometimes applied to paper--like Xerox bond--and wet with a solvent. When you look through a microscope (say 100X) at steel which has been polished with 1 micron diamond paste on soft paper (I wet with denatured alcohol, my shellac solvent), it doesn't have the brash scratches on it that diamond paste on iron will leave. So I've taken to using this diamond paste on paper wet with alcohol, as a final sharpening step for paring chisels or gouges--just make little circles on the paper. The paper starts out white of course, and begins turning black as the diamond removes steel from the blade. Talk about sharp--my goodness. Harrelson Stanley always talked about finishing up on stones with a soft touch for the best edge--and Harrelson can really sharpen. I suppose that is what the paper is doing--ensuring a soft touch.

Wiley

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#2

Thanks, Wiley

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Great suggestions. I'd never have thought about paper as a base stock.

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#3

Sorry to report

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>that my Nital fix of the purple stain in maple did not come out perfect. The 'fix' is still a little darker than the surround. Maybe I'll come back another day and try oxalic acid, which I believe is the standard remedy for bleach.

Any other ideas would be appreciated!

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#4

Re: Sorry to report

RJ Whelan

>Wiley

When you apply the oxalic acid you might also fold an absorbent paper towel to the approximate shape of the unfinished area (about 4 layers), soak it with filtered water, and cover the treated area for about 10 minutes. This will slow the evaporation of the oxalic solution and let it work a little longer.

Good luck .... RJ

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#5

Followup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks, RJ, I will do that. I'll have to plane the whole top next time, in order not to have a low place where the accident occurred. So the additional planing may help too.

I was disappointed that the vegetable dye from the flower penetrated through the shellac finish. There were several coats on there. Question: If I had used varnish, like Behlen's or some similar real hardshell finish, would I have been OK?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#6

Feedback on the hone.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wiley

I tried out the paper+diamond paste as a hone on a couple of chisels.

In my case I had a couple of blunt-but-usable Blue Spruce chisels. I usually strop them on Veritas green rouge on leather to bring up the edge. I tried them as is on pine end grain - they struggled to cut. I gave them a quick hone on the green rouge and leather. They could then cut the pine acceptably and leave a smooth surface.

Then I tried the diamond paste. I added a little baby oil to a strip of plain white copier paper resting on a sheet of glass, and then added a tiny amount of oil-based .5 micron diamond paste. The reason for baby oil (= mineral spirits) is that I have oil-based diamond paste. I assume that yours in water-based.

The result was an easier-to-push chisel that took a longer shaving than before. Hence I must conclude it now had a sharper edge.

Interesting. Thanks for that tip.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#7

Room for experimentation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I wonder if this would work on cardboard - the monolithic (monocellusosic?) kind, such as the backing for a legal pad, rather than corrugated? It would seem that would generate a longer-lasting substrate and less waste of diamond paste.

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#8

Re: Followup

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Wiley, I am having trouble imagining how this stain penetrated the shellac. The iris in our area are not close to blooming, or I would try to reproduce your results. How was your shallac applied?

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#10

Re: Followup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Warren,

This is blonde dewaxed shellac padded onto soft curly maple. I was doing this in the summer, so the shellac dries quickly. This work was done about 5 years ago, but I would have applied numerous 1lb coats, padded on, then denibbed with a very thin flexible scraper. Then wax rubbed in with 0000 steel wool. I'm not sure, but I may have wet-sanded BLO into the wood before applying the shellac.

The blossom fell onto the wood in a little pool of water, and sat there for a day and a half before I got it up. There was still a little water remaining, is how I know it got wet.

Any comments you may have on how you apply shellac, or cuts you use, etc, would be much appreciated.

Wiley

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#11

By the way

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Derek, you refer to "...baby oil (= mineral spirits)..."

Don't you mean "mineral OIL," or are babies tougher down there in Oz?

Lord knows, there were times when my older son's nether parts could have used a good cleaning with industrial solvents (steam cleaning perhaps too), but I think he might have had some dermatitis after mineral spirits.

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#13

Re: Followup

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>My feeling is, Wiley, that one way or another, there isn't a good film of shellac on your chest. Too thin, or not continuous over the pores, or rubbed through- I just don't know.

I just put shellac in alcohol without measuring and french polish without oil. I have never used a scraper on shellac. I sometimes use steel wool, but before waxing. That way you can see what the steel wool is doing to the shellac. If you use the steel wool with wax you cannot see as well (or maybe at all) what is going on. I don't see any purpose to using them together.

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#14

Re: Followup

RJ Whelan

>Wiley ... I'm surprised the shellac allowed the stain to pentrate so deeply - I've been working with wood for over 50 years and still see new things frequently.

For table tops I have pretty much settled on Behlen's "Rock Hard Table Top Varnish". It applies pretty easily (not below about 55 degress though) and you can adjust the sheen with steel (or bronze) wool. I like the look of an oil rubbed finish and you definitely have to knock back the shine with this product.

Good luck, again .... RJ

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#15

Re: Followup stain

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>On the issue of the stain, most vegetable based dyes don't do well under UV. Also most bleaches work better when placed in direct sunshine. I am beginning to see a trend here. You can probably subject the stain to intense UV radiation and it will just go away. Also most organic bleaches work better with the same radiation.

Stephen

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#16

That was probably a substantial mistake

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been off on a canoe trip so I was unavailable to warn you against trying your hand at experimental chemistry on a finished piece of furniture. Recall we ALWAYS try a new finish on a test piece before finishing the project. The same thinking extends to chemistry experiments on finished furniture.

I don't know what the result of mixing nitric acid with methanol is. It might be methyl nitrate (dragster fuel) or it might be a mixture of nitric acid and methanol. If the latter, as it evaporates it will make concentrated nitric acid which will oxidize the wood nicely. In fact maybe that is the reason it is mixed with fast evaporating methanol, I don't know. I would expect nitric acid might make a good stain resulting in some sort of color, perhaps even a desirable color, depending on the wood.

I don't know how Nital is safely made but I witnessed the result of mixing more than a few percent nitric acid with methanol and it was a result that would leave you wary of doing it a second time.

I am skeptical that iris dye penetrated very deeply into the wood. Could it be that conditions were ideal for growing fungus? I know that maple will stain (from fungal growth) clean through a 1" board in two days under ideal conditions (fresh cut board and hot).

I have no idea how to remove the stain. Basic peroxide ( something basic plus peroxide) is pretty potent, especially on plant stains. If the nitric acid oxidized the wood you are screwed.

Had you sprayed the piece with conversion varnish or urethane varnish the iris and water would have had no effect. I say this not to harass you but to point out that modern finishes can out perform traditional finishes in some situations. Personally I would not finish any sort of table top with shellac and I doubt that anyone could tell the difference.

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#17

Tempered hardboard?

Dan Moening in heating Sacramento

>Seems tempered hardboard might provide the stiffness of glass with the porosity of paper?

I don't have diamond paste to try, but would be interested in hearing the results.

~Dan.

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#18

To be fair to my older son

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the younger one could produce some pretty impressive waste products too, but by then, we were experienced parents...

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#19

Re: Followup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Warren,

Thanks for the suggestions on wool and waxing.

On your main point, that my original coating failed, I think you have to be right. Just can't see why I would have had breakthrough otherwise. There appeared to be thick enough coating, based on what I scraped off as I went down to bare wood.

I did not mix a fresh batch of shellac for that top. What I used had probably been mixed a week before. So I am wondering whether the original shellac was not fresh enough, and perhaps had absorbed water vapor from the air, and this kept it from developing a true water-shedding shell. Just a theory--I'm trying to learn something from this experience.

Thanks a lot for the benefit of your experience,

Wiley

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#20

Re: That was probably a substantial mistake

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Bill, I will interline with your post, as there are many points in there:

"I have been off on a canoe trip so I was unavailable to warn you against trying your hand at experimental chemistry on a finished piece of furniture. Recall we ALWAYS try a new finish on a test piece before finishing the project. The same thinking extends to chemistry experiments on finished furniture."

ANSWER: I tested the Nital on curly maple scrap beforehand, to make sure it wouldn't cause immediate disaster. However, you're right that it would have been more sensible to try to replicate the entire problem and fix before attacking the chest top. That would have taken plenty of time, as one would want to see what the Nital did over time. At the time, I was kinda shocked, and more interested in trying to intervene before the dye set in any harder. Might not have been the best judgment in principle, but as it has turned out, it's not a perfect fix, but not bad. To improve on this, I'll have to plane the whole chest top down to bare wood and start over. Big chest, though, 57" high, 44" wide, and chock full.

____________

"I don't know what the result of mixing nitric acid with methanol is. It might be methyl nitrate (dragster fuel) or it might be a mixture of nitric acid and methanol. If the latter, as it evaporates it will make concentrated nitric acid which will oxidize the wood nicely. In fact maybe that is the reason it is mixed with fast evaporating methanol, I don't know. I would expect nitric acid might make a good stain resulting in some sort of color, perhaps even a desirable color, depending on the wood."

ANSWER: There may be some oxidation from the 2% acid. The fix area is a slightly darker tone than the surround. But then I started with a very dark dye in the wood, so that might account for the tone difference, too.

________

"I don't know how Nital is safely made but I witnessed the result of mixing more than a few percent nitric acid with methanol and it was a result that would leave you wary of doing it a second time."

ANSWER: Like you, I would discourage experimentation with these chemicals. The 2% Nital I used was purchased and mixed by the vendor to Mil-Spec. It is the standard etch used every day in metallurgical labs. From reading, mixtures approaching 10% or higher are dangerous (explosive), particular if ethanol is used (not methanol).

__________

"I am skeptical that iris dye penetrated very deeply into the wood. Could it be that conditions were ideal for growing fungus? I know that maple will stain (from fungal growth) clean through a 1" board in two days under ideal conditions (fresh cut board and hot)."

ANSWER: I didn't go down more than maybe 4 thou, based on counting shavings. Our climate is drier than fungus like, especially now that it's May. I am wondering if the curl pattern itself, in soft maple, is porous. I also know from working with this wood in veneer form, that it will wet quickly. The dye was dissolved in shallow water on the wood.

_______________________

"I have no idea how to remove the stain. Basic peroxide ( something basic plus peroxide) is pretty potent, especially on plant stains. If the nitric acid oxidized the wood you are screwed."

ANSWER: The stain is gone, but the tone is slightly darker. I can fix it fairly easily by adjusting the shellac color, but that would be after planing down the whole top, which ain't gonna happen quickly.

___________

"Had you sprayed the piece with conversion varnish or urethane varnish the iris and water would have had no effect. I say this not to harass you but to point out that modern finishes can out perform traditional finishes in some situations. Personally I would not finish any sort of table top with shellac and I doubt that anyone could tell the difference."

ANSWER: That's an interesting point. This is a chest top, 57" high, which when I made it, I never figured it would have anything other than dry gewgaws on it. But then 5 years later, we decide a vase of iris would look nice up there. Why didn't I put something under the vase???? But you're right, varnish in the first place would have headed off all future issues. To be fair to the shellac though, as Warren said, I think there was some flaw in the original application, because the shellac should have held up against the room temp water.

Thanks! Wiley

Re: Couple of odds and ends

#21

Re: Tempered hardboard?

Craig D

>>Seems tempered hardboard might provide the stiffness of glass with the porosity of paper?

I use a shop made hardboard platter on my Veritas� Mk.II Power Sharpening System with their green honing compound and am really happy with the results. It might be even better with diamond but it is good enough for me.

Craig