A different perspective *LINK*
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>For a very different perspective on the Auriou debacle, you may want to take a look at this article.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
A different perspective *LINK*
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>For a very different perspective on the Auriou debacle, you may want to take a look at this article.
Re: A different perspective
Norman
>With this much acrimony between management and workers, you can't be surprised if many of these French companies decide to offshore their services and manufacturing.
A little too much sense of "entitlement" on the part of workers?
Norman
Re: A different perspective
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>OTOH, how could the French workers be blamed for wanting a good life and fighting for it? I suspect that off shoring would be just what they need as a catalyst to start worker owned businesses.
Pam
Re: A different perspective
ThomD
>I'm not sure entitlement is the issue, it may be power. Ultimately grown-ups take what they can get. If you can get the benefits, or whatever that the French workers have taditionally taken, at least until the current president was elected, why not. Managements in the US took huge amounts of Shareholder value over the last ten years, reportedly 10 percent listed value, not too many people blinked. The only real issue is whether the French workers can keep it up, and if not to what level they will have to peel it back.
The author should have pitched the wankerish HBR, and rented a copy of Office Space. Apparently US workers aren't that far away from their French counterparts.
At the end of the day the rasp business is hardly likely to be the key point. And if they offshore it, they are just teaching other competitors all their trade secrets, and what the business is worth. Looking forwad to buying the rasps at our dollar store.
Re: A different perspective
Norman
>Actually, I'm not in support of off-shoring at all, I'm wholeheartedly opposed to it. The problem is with these kinds of demands workers place on the employers and the price margins and competitive environment the employers need to work with, sometimes they have no choice but to offshore.
There needs to be give and take, having the acrimonious management employee relationship results in a negative, hostile workplace and I can't see quality work or products resulting from this.
Maybe the solution is for the workers to have a financial stake in these companies, then they have more of an understanding and interest in the success of the company.
Norman
Re: A different perspective
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Once you get a hardened set of distrustful relationships like that - especially if they're endemic to the culture - it's REALLY hard to change them. For whatever reason, at least some Americans get to work under multiple different management styles in their careers, so can respond to differences.
When I first started in human resources, one of the popular buzz concepts was "Theory X vs. Theory Y" management. The Theory X manager sees workers as lazy, untrustworthy, out to get what they can with as little work as possible, no pride in their work. The Theory Y manager sees workers as wanting to do work of which they can be proud, and hardworking if they're given the opportunity to do good work. I found myself more a Theory Z manager - some workers are Theory X workers, most are Theory Y; the trick is to hire Theory Y workers and then give them the support they need to work well. I certainly observed plenty of Theory X managers - they tend to be great incubators (well - the incubator heat source, anyhow) of human resource problems.
IF that article is correct, it sounds like French culture is calcified around Theory X thinking. Personally, I find it hard to believe that any country is monocultural in its management/worker attitudes and relationships.
Recent experience with Auriou *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi All,
Must've been about a year ago, I placed an order with the re-launched Auriou. They had just started over--there was Michel, one stitcher named Denis, a blacksmith Bernard, and a grinder whose name I forget.
I liked the Auriou rasps I had, and I liked their gumption starting over from scratch like that. Folks I knew in No. America who had met Michel when he came over to stitch some rasps at woodworking venues were impressed with his grasp of all aspects of his business--I'm thinking of Konrad and Mike Wenzloff. I ordered a large grain 15 rasp. It was a custom order, and the website was advertising 5 weeks til delivery.
My rasp came in 4-1/2 weeks. Opened it up, and it kinda reminded me of Lie Nielsen, in that it was well-packed and secure, but the packaging materials were not fancy--kinda what they had on hand. The rasp itself was wrapped in butcher paper, and on the butcher paper Michel had written a note saying that this was the first large grain 15 rasp made by the new team, and the stitcher Denis signed right below MIchel. I went and tested that rasp's cutting speed and smoothness against the old Aurious, and it was right with them. Same quality as before.
I have a warm fuzzy feeling about that experience. Small shop. Committed people in a sink or swim situation. First class product. Custom (left handed). And a note expressing thanks for the business, from the boss and the stitcher.
Re: A different perspective
Alexander Grigoriev
>It's no surprise unemployment in France runs at 20%. If you can't layoff people (or even fire an underperformer), you'd not want to hire anybody.
Re: Recent experience with Auriou
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Wiley,
What is the major difference between a left handed rasp and a right hand?
Seems like asking for a left handed spoon.....
Marv
Re: Recent experience with Auriou *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Marv,
Maybe you've noticed that a rasp will cut smoothly in one direction, and coarsely in the opposite direction? Like with these Auriou rasps, if I push straight down, it will cut the smoothest if I let it slide sideways a bit. The left-handed rasp, held in my left hand, makes its smoothest cut when it slides right, toward my belt buckle. The right-handed rasp makes its smoothest cut when it slides left--so if I'm holding it left handed, it wants to work away from me. Whereas a right handed person holding a right handed rasp, the rasp will want to work into their body, not away.
Don't want to make too big a fuss of this, because you can get results either way.
I looked at the rasp teeth under 10x magnification to figure out what's going on. The rasp teeth appear to point straight down along the long axis of the rasp. But in fact the teeth are angled just a few degrees off vertical. You can tell by the way the little lines of sawdust lay, where they're caught under the teeth.
Auriou marks the left handed rasps with a 'G' (gauche). The new rasps are marked 'Auriou', same as the old ones.
I have attached the website page which introduces the Auriou work force (of 4). No room for anyone not working. Each person has a specific job they do.
"Gauche" is French for "left."
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Re: A different perspective
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I don't think people are all that different from one country to another. I suspect that the French have the labor laws to act out what many Americans would like to. So I also suspect the rabid differences relate to CEO's taking money away from the workers to pay themselves huge, obscene wages. Just like they do here. A race to the bottom steered by the top.
Pam
Re: A different perspective
steve mackay
>WHEW ! Would it have made more sense translated ?
Re: A different perspective
Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia
>I am and have been a "production" worker for most of my adult life. I get paid based on the quantity of labor I perform. I will get replaced if the quality suffers.
That said, I have no sympathy for the French. They all seem spoiled to me.
JR
Freedom fries, anyone? :)
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Commentry
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>It strikes me (as a observer without knowledge or experience in this field) that each country sets its work and social philosophy from links to a notable historical experience. These events become symbols that set the standards and approach for workers. This seems to transcend generations.
In France it was the Bastille and Revolution (and we continue to see the fierce suspicion towards the bourgeoisie).
In England it may have been inventions during their Industrial Revolution (the growth of manufacturing meant that the first industrial proletariat also came into being).
In Australia it was the First Fleet of convicts transported from Britain (subsequent undercurrent of anti-authority and anti-achievement).
In South Africa it was the Boer War (Afrikaners and God verses the English and the World)
In the USA would you say it was the Boston Tea Party (as a prelude to the War of Independence)?
Naive regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Commentry
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Certainly, there are country to country cultural differences, just as there are generation to generation and region to region (within a country) and trade to trade/profession to profession cultural differences.
I worry that pursuit of this topic too far will start to get political, though...
Re: A different perspective
ThomD
>They could call it S for sinister, which also means left handed.
Thanks Wiley....
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>I would never have guessed by just looking at a rasp that it could be left or right handed. Learn something everyday in here.
Is it common practise by rasp makers in general to make left and right?
Thanks,
Marv
Re: Thanks Wiley....
wilbur
>I was able to see Michel Auriou demonstrate the method used to make rasps by hand at the WIA conference in Berea. You set the rasp blank in front of you, and use a light hammer and a sharp tool to "dig up" a piece of metal from the face of the rasp which becomes a tooth on the rasp. The tooth making is done one diagonal row at a time.
Because of the angle the rasp maker is tapping at in relation to the rasp, the teeth will be angled very slightly in relation to the long axis of the rasp. I can't see how one could make a non-handed rasp by hand, unless you had machine-like precision. It seems that you can't help but make either a right handed or left handed rasp.
Except for me, that is. I was able to try my hand at rasp making there at the demo, and I'm sure that of the teeth that I made, some were left handed, and some were right handed. :@) After I was done, one of my friends there asked Michel if he would give me a job, and he politely declined comment.
So you made ambidextrous rasps, Wilbur
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Accentuate the positive!
How can one really fault a country that gave us
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>the Roubo bench, the Statue of Liberty, Edith Piaf, Bridgitte Bardot, Jules Verne, Jean Cocteau, the Impressionist movement and Opinel knives? I could think of some negative things but the Roubo bench makes up for all of it. Each nation's genius contains the good and the bad.
Re: How can one really fault a country that gave u
Edward in Vancouver
>The Metric system?
Ducking and running..............
Re: How can one really fault a country that gave u
Jeff Weaver
>And a really fun way to kiss....
vive la difference
Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX
>