Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Weather resistance

Posts

Weather resistance

#1

Weather resistance

David Miller from Iowa

>Rebuilding a cast iron bench (not too hard, just some slats) that will be in the Iowa weather from here on out. Question - what would you recommend for wood type (commonly available) and finish - product and application?

Thanks, David

Re: Weather resistance

#2

Re: Weather resistance

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>White oak, ipe (but buy a new carbide saw blade and plan to see it used up), mahogany.

Re: Weather resistance

#3

Re: Weather resistance

R.J. Whelan

>David ....

Apatong is used on truck beds (trailers actually). You probably won't find it at a Home Center, but most specialty suppliers should have access to it.

I have used it with success in my area which receives a fair amount of snow in the winter and, typically, bright sun from May through October.

I pressure wash it once a year and then give it a light sanding to knock down the grain.

I have a table and two chairs that are coming up on seven years use and they still look pretty good.

RJ

Re: Weather resistance

#4

Re: Got any locust?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>

Re: Weather resistance

#5

Re: Weather resistance

peter kolb

>I vote for ipe'; which is a hard, dense wood I have a deck that is 14 years old and in excellent shape. Peter in south central NJ

Re: Weather resistance

#6

Re: Weather resistance

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Nothing beats paint for lasting out doors. As far as wood, my bare wood farm gates of oak last for more than 15 years. They are off the ground. For that matter after we built our current house I put some old saw horses out by the wood pile and 14 years later they are still there. They are made from framing softwoods-spruce, pine?

Re: Weather resistance

#7

Red Wood.

Victor P

>I've still got a pile of short pieces left over from the redo or Houston's Rice Stadium. I'm guessing they were in the weather some 20 plus years when I retrieved them from the dumpster. Ran them through the jointer and planer and they cleaned up real nice.

Victor - in hot and humid Houston

Re: Weather resistance

#8

Re: Red Wood.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I'm surprised we aren't buying Redwood by the ounce these days.

Marv

Re: Weather resistance

#9

The troubles with redwood for a bench

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>1. It's a weak wood, so you need correspondingly thicker slats (a couple of years ago, LOML and I were touring a museum - one room - in a county north of us. The docent that day had grown up in the area, moved away, then retired back in the area, and he was telling us that, when he was a kid, they used to fell trees over ravines to serve as bridges, and that they always used Douglas fir, not redwood, because even a big redwood tree would splinter when the top hit the far side of the ravine).

2. When redwood ages, it sends up splinters that, when they get under your skin, fester with great enthusiasm - probably some extractive in the wood.

These things are true, not just a front for the fact that we Northern Californians get kinda protective of the stuff.

Re: Weather resistance

#10

Re: Weather resistance

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>David,

I did the same job a few months back, asked the same question, and got some good advice.

I used 5/4 QS white oak for the slats, since that's what I had. Sprayed the iron black with Rustoleum. The original screws/carriage bolts were brass--I replaced with stainless, but the brass was fine.

To finish the QSWO, I took someone's advice and used marine spar varnish. Doing well so far, and looks good to me.

Wiley

Re: Weather resistance

#11

Re: Weather resistance

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"I replaced with stainless, but the brass was fine."

I suppose with a good coat of paint on the iron (in the holes where the fittings go), the potential for galvanic corrosion between the iron and a more noble metal like brass or stainless wouldn't matter; but, although I'm ready to be told I'm talking through my hat, I think I'd rather have stainless sitting next to iron than brass, in case the paint cracked.

Re: Weather resistance

#12

Re: Weather resistance

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill,

You've brought up an interesting idea. Now in my case, the cast iron still had enough original coating that there was no apparent dissimilar metals corrosion from the brass fasteners. Plus, you have to have an electrolyte (water) present for much to happen, and it's pretty dry here most of time.

In Sebastopuddle (Sir Wm's phrase) or in Iowa, might be different. The amount of iron in a bench casting would make a pretty big sacrificial anode, I will allow that.

I'm not sure what would happen in a wet environment between brass fasteners and iron frame. If you look at a ranking of the metals, the iron should corrode first in the presence of the brass. However, yellow brass has a lot of zinc in it, and zinc is way ignoble, so it could be that each brass nut could have internal battery action, if wet. Big if.

Oh well, I didn't see any corrosion, but the brass had formed a dark ugly patina, so I replaced with the stainless. As I understand it, the stainless (exposed to air) will form an initial dull patina, and then be inert thereafter.

Wiley

Re: Weather resistance

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Weather resistance

Jesper, Denmark

>Black Locust will outlast the cast iron. No finish necessary. It will weather to a nice pale grey. Scrub clean in spring with soap and water or even a high pressure washer.

Re: Weather resistance

#14

No kidding Marv.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It's very pricey around here.