Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

Posts

Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

#1

Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

Philip Duffy

>Like some others on this Board, I love to use my spoke shaves. So, having splurged to buy a Hock blade and discovering it would not fit in my English made Stanley 151, I consulted the guru himself by email. Ron was most helpful and made some suggestions. I then added a touch or two with a fine cut file to the mouth of my 151 and tried again. Better, but not marvelous results. Second file work, sanding paper to buff as hard as cloth would allow, and a refit. Wonder of wonders! What a great combination of blade and frame. - -just thought this might help someone else. Philip

Re: Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

#2

People diss the Stanley shaves

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I like mine a lot.

Re: Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

#3

Re: Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

Tony - Memphis

>Same here. I remember he told me how lucky I was to have a tight fit to start. My first Hock iron was a dud though. The cutting edge flaked. He replaced it and wanted the defective one back as I recall. New one is nice. Hard to sharpen compare to the original due to the material. I've been wearing it out on some curly maple cabriole legs. I'm getting a lot of chatter for some reason and I recall when I did my last set of legs (walnut), I got chatter. Not sure what's up. I sharpened it and I wax the sole as I go. That helped, as did skewing the shave. Better, but still some chatter. I was able to get through all four legs, but I need to figure out the issue. I may have a clearance issue and need to file a little more? Dunno. Nice tool and iron anyhow. Easy to get carried away when working a cabriole leg and all is going well! You'll end up with a mighty thin ankle if you don't pay attention! I've got one of the old Stanley's with the adjustable part, but I haven't ever fooled with it.

Tony

Re: Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

#4

Re: People diss the Stanley shaves

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>I never could figure out why Stanley spoke shaves are dissed either. I too think they're great tools.

Stanleys are not dissed as much as the Kuntz Stanley knock-offs, though. The Kuntz #55 knock-off I bought needed to have the angle of the bevel in it's iron changed, and poof, it worked just fine. It's still very obviously not a Stanley, but it's just the tool to use on chair spindles to knock off the octagonal facets left by the draw knife.

greg

Re: Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

#5

Re: I bought the fancy LV ones

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>before I started building chairs.

Then I built a couple using Ron's blades.

Rob's are nice, but the homemade ones are easily as useful. Simple tool, the shave. I wish I'd learned its use earlier.

Re: Stanley spoke shave vs. Hock blade

#6

Re: People diss the Stanley shaves

Charles

>I've got a couple of 'crappy Kunz' shaves (basically same as new Stanleys)and they work fine to me.

I suppose I pine for the time and money everybody else seems to have with which to comparison shop, revisit purchases already made, etc. My time is limited enough as it is so I end up using stock cutters in supposedly inferior tools.

Guess I don't know any better.