Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Finish recommendations

Posts

Finish recommendations

#1

Finish recommendations

David Miller from Iowa

>Building a built-in entertainment center 15' wide by 9' tall - 12 doors. Exposed wood is cherry and the inside is birch plywood. Time to finish the built-in part and need something that is fast, easy and dries reasonably quick. No stain, but I want it to darken the wood like a penetrating oil. Prefer brush on, but would consider wipe on. Already built in so I don't want to spray.

Suggestions including brand names would be welcomed.

Thanks, David

Re: Finish recommendations

#2

Re: Finish recommendations

Dave Mount

>Reminds me of that old saying, "Good, fast, cheap -- choose any two."

You don't say much about what kind of finish you're looking for, but I'm guessing you're thinking film finish. If so, I really like General Finishes "Arm-R-Seal" which is a wipe on urethane. It's basically just a thinner cut of urethane varnish. Like any wipe-on finish, the build is slow, but I use it where I don't really want much build. It actually builds fairly fast on horizontal surfaces if you foam pad it on, but you need to wipe it on any surface other than horizontal, because it's thin and it will run otherwise.

If you're the frugal sort, you can make your own wipe-on varnish from any ordinary (solvent-based) varnish by thinning it some. However, I find it's just simpler to buy it pre-thinned. Arm-R-Seal is available lots of places, Rockler among them.

Arm-R-Seal is fast, good, and easy, but it does not meet your requirement of drying quickly, and being solvent based could be an issue if your going to have to live in the fumes while it cures. It's no more noxious than other varnishes, but it's an issue for a large application in a living space.

I think you may run into problems finding a finish that combines brush or wipe on application with fast curing. Basically, most fast-drying finishes are tough to apply by hand in a way that doesn't risk brush marks when you're dealing with a large complicated surface, like an EC, and you can't "finish the finish" by sanding to remove marks.

Best,

Dave

Re: Finish recommendations

#3

Re: Finish recommendations

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>David,

I like thin coats of shellac for what you're describing. Use 'dark' for a more neutral tone, or garnet for a redder tone. The thing about the shellac is that it has a very pleasing smell which seems to last for years. It is fast drying. Thin coats means you can wipe or brush easily, and without having brush strokes or fat edges. I would wipe it myself with an old washed-many-times cotton t-shirt. Stop whenever you want, based on how much build you want. If it develops more gloss than you want, degloss with a gray pad or whatever. Main thing--you're left with a very pleasing smell, and no chemical fumes.

Wiley

Re: Finish recommendations

#4

Wiley!!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"you're left with a very pleasing smell, and no chemical fumes"

I can't let this pass. Let me rephrase correctly.....You are left with the vapors of ethanol and its denaturing agent(s) as well as what ever chemical vapors are volatilized from shellac, either from the bugs or the processing steps, instead of hydrocarbon vapors from paint thinner. I won't argue personal taste in choice of chemicals but if the nose detects it, what is detected is some volatile chemical(s).

And for others, it is a flawed assumption to presume that chemicals whose smell you prefer are harmless chemicals, while those you don't are "toxic chemicals", to borrow a popular phrase from the media. As far as I know there is no agreed upon LD50 that triggers the modifier "toxic" in a chemical's name in spite of what the media would have one to believe.

For the application at hand I would use naptha thinned varnish applied with a high dollar brush. After application crank the heat to 80 and it will be dry to touch in 3-4 hours.

Re: Finish recommendations

#5

They coat apples and candy with it, Bill

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Finish recommendations

#6

Now why doesn't that make me feel better? :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Finish recommendations

#7

Re: Wiley!!

Hank Knight

>Bill,

I'm with Wiley on this one. I consider ethanol a "consumable." In fact, I'm consuming some right now. The "denaturing elements" are a minor annoyance - at least when it comes to inhaling the stuff.

Hank

Re: Finish recommendations

#8

What fun is that...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Finishing with out the Buzz effect. Man O Man.

Beats BLO....

Re: Finish recommendations

#9

Re: Wiley!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Uh-oh. Hit a nerve. Didn't mean to, and will try to explain below.

Krenov suggests thinned shellac also. He describes it in one of his books, calling it 'polish'. My recall is a little hazy on this point, but i believe he describes a method of dewaxing. Of course, we can buy dewaxed just as easily.

I was not discussing anything to do with relative toxicities, and do regret the use of the term 'chemical fumes' because it certainly does suggest notions of toxicity. Bill Tindall is absolutely correct in his reaction and his explanation.

So let me start over. I suggested shellac, and still do, because it meets David's requirement that it is simple to apply, if thinned to less than 1-lb cut, and is fast drying. It requires no equipment; it can be obtained in different color strengths from superblond to dark; and can be built to whatever thickness is desired; and deglossed as desired.

But more than this, Krenov's 'polish' leaves a very pleasant woody sort of smell, which I can tell you endures at least 5 years undiminished, and surely much longer. Puts a smile on your face every time you open the cabinet. This could be a significant matter for a project the size David is discussing.

And I do regret using words like 'chemicals' and 'fumes', which diverted the message from what I was trying to say.

Wiley

Re: Finish recommendations

#10

Not to mention shiny prescription pills & skittles

Raney

>

Re: Finish recommendations

#11

NapHtha

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>It seems kind of odd to warn of the dangers of breathing denatured alcohol and then recommend naphtha for the same application. I hope you haven't been breathing too many fumes.

Re: Finish recommendations

#12

Re: NapHtha

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Warren,

I have to agree with you but didn't want to bring it up, but since you did, there is nothing wrong with alcohol fumes.

If people are real worried they can use Everclear (190 proof straight grain alcohol) which is 'safe' to drink!

The denaturing agents are put in there to discourage drinking.

As for a light colored finish I would recommend a spirit varnish, Dammar and Mastic are a bit soft (add Burgundy Pitch), Gum Benjamin is a harder and smells great when it is applied, Copal is best unless you can afford Amber varnish.

Stephen

Re: Finish recommendations

#13

reread what I actually said

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Apparently some of you presumed I said more than I did. The point, in case it was not sufficiently clear, is that anything you can smell is a chemical vapor, including ethanol.

The second point is to not presume that your personal preference in smell will enable you to judge hazard. Cyanide has quite a plesant odor of almonds and phosgene smells like freshly mowed grass and in lethal doses hydrogen sulfide (rotten eggs) has no detectable odor.

Personally, I don't believe there is any hazard in finishing something indoors with either varnish or shellac.

I have better success with brushing varnish than shellac and no one in the family is deluded into thinking one is more a hazard than the other. Hence, my preference for varnish.

Re: Finish recommendations

#14

Random thoughts....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

According to my Polmolologist (sp) (my lung doctor) I shouldn't be breathing anything unless I am wearing a 3M full-face resperator. I'm being facitious of course. The point is, we really don't know the extent that the various fumes we breath will have on our lungs in a general sense or in an individual sense.

We all know of people who live into their nineties who were chain smokers. Then there are those who die very young with lungs plugged with tar.

We can die from just breathing in certain spores from fungus that's in rotting leaves that are composting beneath trees that are most everywhere.

When I was a young man working in the electronics industry, we thought nothing of working over an open tub filled with all kinds of solvents and working with vats of hot epoxies of all kinds. Talk about fumes! This was before OSHA of course. But even after OSHA came on the scene, they didn't inspect for protection against breathing fumes, they were too busy looking for a missing outlet cover or counting the number of urinals in our restrooms.

Then the lawyers got their greedy minds working and now we see them on TV hawking their services for those who got a whiff of asbestos or whatever.

Yes, I have a mild case of asthma, but my guess is, I got it from sitting in traffic for hours on end breathing in the exhaust from a million cars around me.

Actually, I have little concern as I wipe on some BLO or Lacquer or Shellac on a saw handle.

Just a thought,

Marv

Re: Finish recommendations

#15

Re: Random thoughts....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Marv, always amazes me how those most protected by OSHA are those most politically opposed to their very existence. Now, I could understand my father's venting when they made him replace a toilet seat; but I also wondered why he didn't simply replace it to begin with (He said one of the mechanics broke it. I said Well, who else? Only mechanics use it. It was such a lovely car ride. :)

Pam

Re: Finish recommendations

#16

Re: Random thoughts....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I'll try to relate this to woodworking....car rides with my Dad that I mostly remember was when we drove to and from his little jippo saw mill when I rode in the back seat. He chewed snuff and opened his window to spit. Taught me to may attention and how to quickly duck. Didn't always work though. When I got older I got to sit in the front.

Marv

Re: Finish recommendations

#17

George Burns...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Smokes cigars for a very long time. Yes, he stopped but he was GOD too.

Died at 90 somethin.

Don't joke about Asbestos it's right up there with Mercury and alike. It took my wife's father at a very young age 56. He was in in the navy in the bowels of the ship. He died before the Lawyers quote "got their greedy minds working". Not true!

My dead FIL was fighting (along with many others) with/against the military for years.

Personally I love the amount of support they (our government)give the ones that have served once released. NOT!

They were and still are guinea pigs.