Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Woodfiller vs....

Posts

Woodfiller vs....

#1

Woodfiller vs....

John L. Blue

>sawdust and glue. Your favorite!

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#2

None of my timber has knots or defects.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Oh sure!

In the real world ..

1. Leave the hole/defect as a feature.

2. Fill with 5-minute epoxy - either tinted black (I prefer a contrast) with a cement oxide (or the colour of your choice), or leave clear.

I never use sawdust and glue - it always goes black. Anyway sawdust never looks real once it is finished.

3. If the defect is small (small nail hole), and it needs to be disguised, I will wait until after the finish is on and fill with wax or epoxy (depends on the finish and wood).

I am sure others have favourites ..

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#3

Re: Woodfiller vs....

Joel

>BONDO!!!

dries fast, you can sand it, carve it, it takes details, hit it with finish it turns black. Wonderfull stuff and the fill is totally unobvious when done. (on walnut anyway)

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#4

Epoxy....

John in NM

>I've got some white two part that transtint will go into. Takes all day to cure though. 5 minute epoxy is nice but some brands are annoyingly soft and rubbery. I like the Pacer Technologies stuff that HD carries. The best results I ever got though, as far as invisible goes, was using window putty and paint. Paint must have been some type of water base (came in little bottles from HD or somewhere). Mixed the paint in with the putty for a base color to fill the flaw (a dent in this case), then made another putty the color of the lighter grain and pushed a little rope of it in line with a streak of lighter grain. Only trouble is that it will show up when the wood darkens or lightens, but on the short term its pretty invisible.

I never liked the sawdust/glue thing. PVA glues resist finish of course, which is why it looks awful when you put the finish on. I've had it work better with hide glue, but if its a large flaw the hide glue can shrink too much. Adding a lot of sawdust can cure either of these, but then it doesn't adhere as well.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#5

shellac sticks..

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Some years ago Mohawk offered an affordable kit of shellac sticks. It must contain at least 50 colors. I often alter the shape of the defect to blend the shape with some grain feature and then fill with the stick. So, for example, a round hole will be made elliptical. Sometimes I even fill with more than one shade to "camo" the filled part.

One problem is that some woods change color with age, for example ash gets much browner. So a color match with the newly finished wood may not match well after some aging.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#6

another alternative

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When possible I use a piece of the wood to patch. There are the obvious approaches of shaping a piece of wood to fill a hole but another approach can work for some repairs, especially shallow ones. I carve a piece of wood to approximate shape and then glue it into/onto the defect using extreme clamp pressure which forces the patch into the defect. This repair must be thoroughly dried so that it doesn't continue to shrink or expand after finish is applied.

I steam dents out- soldering iron and a wet rag.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#7

Ellis Walentine

Woodfiller and touch-up kit

Ellis Walentine

>For an invisible repair, I use water-based wood filler. When it has dried hard, sand it flush and get out your trusty touch-up kit -- a variety of powdered pigments, a tiny red sable brush, and a bottle cap with some lacquer or shellac in it. Start with the lightest color in the surrounding grain. Dip your brush in the finish and then in whichever combination of pigments gives you a good match, and paint over the filled area with it. Then paint in any darker grain features necessary to complete the picture convincingly. Top it all off with a light spray of touch-up lacquer or dilute shellac, or whatever finish you need to match the surrounding film thickness and sheen. The whole process is very quick, once you get your techniques down.

Note: Some fillers shrink when they dry, so you may have to apply a second coating to fill the cracks in the first.

Another note: This advice is for high-end woodwork and furniture. For less demanding jobs like filling nail holes in door casings and moldings, I usually use tinted plumbers putty after the wood has been finished.

Ellis

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#8

Beaumontage stopping

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#9

Re: Woodfiller and touch-up kit

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Shellac and pumice work well. On one project I had a natural crack for about two inches. As I finished the piece with shellac the crack finally disappeared. Three years later it's still invisible. Pumice will fill pores and small holes.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#10

Re: Woodfiller vs....

ThomD

>I tend to use epoxy for clear finish over hardwood, usually dyed with graphite powder. most comonly it is a pitch pocket in cherry. I tend to use unblemished hardwoods for other stuff, but cherry can be blended in.

I use CA glue on detailed small blemishes, like guitar finish stuff. either add a tiny drop and sand to fill, or sand to fill and add a small drop of glue, it depends on the situation.

I use creamy wood filler on painted softwood.

I use epoxy and microballoons on structural repairs.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#11

Krenov suggested something very similar

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>In one of James Krenov's books, he describes how an instructor at his woodworking school in Sweden saved his final term project. There was a blemish of some sort in the final surface. The instructor took a sharp gouge and dug out the blemish and found a matching piece of wood and gouged out a 'replacement' divot, and glued in the replacement divot just as Bill described. Apparently it blended perfectly.

I have found that in wood which carves easily--cherry in my case--this approach works very well. The key to the method is the geometry of the gouge producing an identical shaving, plus you want a dead match for grain and color. You have to make a clean cut on the project surface, which means the gouge has to be dead sharp. If you can make a clean cut on the project, then you can make as many attempts as is needed on the donor scrap to make the match. Glue with hide glue so that the finish is not affected.

Practice on scrap of course........

Wiley

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#12

Re: Krenov suggested something very similar

ThomD

>I have a hard time imagining it would be invisible.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#13

Invisible vs. unobtrusive

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Probably not, but if something is unobtrusive enough, it might as well be invisible.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#14

Re: Invisible vs. unobtrusive

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I'm not as good as Krenov's mentor (to say the least!!), and would not be able to pull this off in the middle of a light colored table top.

I did it on cherry legs, where the favorable circumstances were a medium colored wood, and enough color variation to mask a small anomaly, and the fact that no one is studying this leg in a raking light.

You can get a near-perfect color and grain match. The test is to make the patch outline not noticeable. You have a fighting chance because the gouge leaves a subtle curve, which does not attract the eye. The key is to make the replacement divot a little larger than the hole you're filling. The curvature will be a match because of gouge geometry, but you make the replacement piece a little larger, then plunge it into hide glue, to soften it and to ensure it doesn't curl, then clamp it down hard (after making sure it's a fit).

The combination of glue-softening and clamping will mold the patch to the divot you've dug in the work. I'm talking about a patch that is on the order of 1/16" to 1/8" to 3/16" (max.) wide and, say, 3/8" to 1/2" (max.) long. Use a veiner (No. 11). In other words, it's small so that you can match grain and color and blend it into the overall busyness of the wood. And kinda steep-sided (why a veiner does well) so it will finish up neatly.

If it's hot hide, you can work it pretty quickly--after 10 minutes of clamping, say. What I did was pare off the main excess with a chisel, using a skewing cut. Then used a flexible scraper to level it--the scraper is good because it does not tend to rag the edges of the patch, tends to keep pressing the patch into the work, rather than tearing it out. Then shellac over. Later, come back and worry it down to true level with 300g sanding paper on a flat block. More shellac.

It works better than one would imagine.

Wiley

It blends well if you don't overwork it. If you overwork it, you begin to reveal the border, because the patch is getting worked down slightly below grade.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#15

Re: Krenov suggested something very similar

Alexander Grigoriev

>It was veneer sanded through. The instructor cut what they called "a louse" with a gauge. Because it was veneer, it was very easy to make a flat-bottomed hole for the plug.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#16

to emphasize the points leading to success....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Without getting lost in the details of execution, there are several points to emphasize that lead to success.

1. Nothing patches better than a piece of wood from the same tree. With some care in selection one can find a perfect match in the scrap pile from a project.

2. If the "plug" (loosely defined) shape approximately matches the hole, gouged or otherwise excavated, extreme clamping pressure will force the malleable plug into the hole and the edges will seal up.

3. When this assembly gets planned/scraped level the color and grain will match and the glue line at the edges will be indistinct.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#17

a report

roninkokomo

>Have done this kind of repair twice.

Once it was terrific.

Once, not so good.

I strongly suspect operator error in the unsuccessful attempt.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#18

I thought about this for a bit.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Knots=epooy

Gaps in DT's at the end grain plugs or shims.

Gaps in DT's at the long grain good old Elmers white glue and a healthy dose of sawdust, this fix does NOT work with Cherry. Don't ask why...

A sloppy mix of BLO and sawdust works in a lot of cases.

Famowood (sp) or others work well for repairing finished pieces or items that are going to painted.

I try steam out anything before messing with it for the most part.

Cheers!

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#19

North Bennet does, too.

James Watriss

>We were told by several of our instructors not to throw scraps away until everything was over and done and delivered. I've seen straight grained wood done this way, and even seen someone inlay a bird's eye to cover up a really obnoxious bit of tearout on some really wild blister maple. (Didn't care too much for that particular student, but he did do very nice work.)

The repair is typically findable if you know that it's there, and you're looking for it. subtle discontinuities in grain and whatnot. But it's rare that it'll really stand out on its own. Like many other properly done details... it fades into the background, and it's possible that, once the finish is on, no one will ever know. Most of the surface area of most pieces of furniture is just blank space, and doesn't attract much attention.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#20

Re: North Bennet does, too.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Whether noticeable or not, I think a tidy repair is at the bottom of the list of things a craftsman should worry about. Design, stock selection, proportion, ornamentation, finish, and many many other things are more important and very often come up short.

I know someone who has a 17th century violin. Made in Cremona. On the fancy back are two wiggly worm tunnels, neatly repaired. The owner thinks the worm went in after the violin was made and that the repairs are later. But actually the tunnels are wider than the back is thick; no worm can make a hole like that. So the repair, quite noticeable, was done by the maker. It did not prevent the violin from being enjoyed for more than three centuries.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#21

Re: North Bennet does, too.

James Watriss

>Well, there was an ongoing debate about that. There was an instructor at NBSS names Will Neptune. He was very highly regarded at the time, (still is, really) but then he was asked to give a demonstration on something. I think it was a ball and claw foot, something like that.

He proceeded with his demonstration, and something went wrong. So he started again. And something went wrong. And so forth, and he got horribly panned in print as unable to work effectively, since every goof meant a new piece of lumber got cut.

The truth is, things happen. Gaps in dovetails, dings, dents, cracks, chips, tearout, clamps get dropped, chisels can slip, and sometimes pieces can even get knocked of the bench.

On a really well done piece, you don't really see a well planed surface, or cleanly installed molding, or proper symmetry. But if there's a plane track, or something is off, there's tearout, or something else that's glarlingly obvious, then it's noticeable almost right away. Good supporting elements are like proper harmony. They come in, and they add to the piece, but they're unobtrusive... unless one of them is out of tune, off beat, or out of step with the others.

So, to that end, I think that good repairs are actually close to the top of the list. No project ever goes perfectly, there's almost always something that goes awry, or doesn't go as planned. Sometimes it's a "design opportunity," and you have to work around it. A guy I know who repairs antiques actually found an old table with reeded legs, where the back legs had an odd number of reeds, different from the ones in front. After consulting with Winterthur, it turned out that the legs were actually original. But by matching the mistake in the mirroring leg, it make the mistake less obvious or obtrusive.

But sometimes, particularly if the goof is in an obvious spot, or if you're using exotic, expensive, or personally important wood, (I have a job coming up using reclaimed lumber from a family homestead that was in the client's family) there's no real way to work around it... the repair has to be made, and it has to be cleanly, almost seamlessly done. One element out of place, or one error if it's big enough, can become a focal point, and really detract from the piece, to the detriment of all of the other work you put into it. A repair on the back side, or underneath, these are easily hidden, and not normally out in plain sight... but the repaired wood was used on the back of the violin for a reason.

It's true that design and proportion and decorative elements are all important, and very critical things. But if all the client/recipient sees is a big dent on the leg, the rest of it is a wash.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#22

This is well written and thought out editorial

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This is the kind of commentary that would be nice to see inside the cover of fine woodworking magazines.

Knowing that Will can screw up will make me feel some better about my next mistake.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#23

Re: This is well written and thought out editorial

James Watriss

>Hey, man, that's the point. :)

Everyone can screw up. It happens, Murphy guarantees it.

That's why repairs are pretty high up on the list for me.

Re: Woodfiller vs....

#24

Total effect vs. total symmetry

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>(Not by any means as experienced as James Watriss, but adding a thought)

One of the chairs in my family, which sat in my grandmother's living room all the years we were growing up, and then in my parents' house after she moved in with them, was clearly not factory turned, as the finials at the top of the back legs are significantly different sizes and subtly different shapes. However, the overall effect of the shape is sufficiently similar that I had to point this out to my sister (one of whose children received the chair when we closed out our parents' house a couple of years ago).

And we've got another chair from the same grandmother in our house with similarly mismatched finials (the shape is a vase with a ball on top, and the ball on one side is half the size of the ball on the other), a difference I didn't notice for probably three years after we received the chair. Interestingly, this one does look to be factory made, or at least not craftsman made, but clearly not with a duplicating lathe as part of the tooling.