Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Stopped Grooves

Posts

Stopped Grooves

#1

Stopped Grooves

David Brown

>I was wondering if the collected wisdom of this august group could help me as I prepare to make some dovetail boxes. They will be used for 2 things: As storage for kids toys and to allow me to practice cutting dovetails!

I have a Record 044 plough plane but not the LV large router plane I want.

I want to cut grooves for the bottom of the box and I have a couple of choices:

1) Cut through grooves all around and live with the gap that will be present.

2) Cut through grooves all around and plug the gap (I got this idea from a search on "stopped groove" on WC. Thanks to Bob Demmers)

3) Cut through grooves on 2 sides and cut stopped grooves on the other 2 sides and lay out the dovetails to hide the through grooves.

I'd like to do option 3, but I'm not sure of the best technique to cut 1/4 inch grooves with the grain in a 12" long board and have it be consistently 1/4" in from the edge and be exactly 1/4" wide and 1/4" deep. Something tells me this technique might involve a chisel. I do have a 1/4" one. I've seen techniques described for cutting dados with a saw and chisel, but I don't own a saw that would allow me to cut a 12" wide groove prior to clearing the waste with the chisel.

I thought I saw something by Christopher Schwarz on cutting stopped grooves with a plow /plough plane, but I can't find it by searching his blog. I could be making this up. I can't see using that tool for a stopped groove.

So how does one do this with limited tools? If the answer is basically, buy the router plane, I'd like to know that as well. I'm new at this, so please be kind in your responses.

Have a good night.

--Dave

Re: Stopped Grooves

#2

First off, let's go through the questions.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>1. No way no how. Just walk away.

2. Completely acceptable as long as you do it proper!

3. The fun way. It starts with drilling a hole the size of the grooves at the quadrant where the grooves will end. Work backwards toward (away from the hole) the edge of the board carefully. Complete the groove by squaring the hole

Now cut your DT's

Yippy Kai Yeay

Re: Stopped Grooves

#3

Re: Stopped Grooves--one way to avoid

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>David,

You could avoid stopped grooves for this project by using half-blind dovetails at each end. For example, let the two longer sides carry the tails, and the two shorter sides carry the pins. Plough through grooves in the middle of the bottom tail on each side. Then plough through grooves to match between the two lower pins on each end.

The half blind ends will cover the through grooves made in the sides.

Wiley......who got schooled recently by Warren on avoiding stopped grooves

Re: Stopped Grooves

#5

Re: Stopped Grooves--one way to avoid

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes, it would be somewhat shocking to see a stopped groove on an 18th century box. The craftsmen of that era were much more concerned with efficient use of time than today. Even with a router plane, making a stopped groove is no slick operation. Period boxes generally had the bottom nailed on. Sometimes the bottom was slightly larger than the box and then molded on the edges. Sometimes the bottom was made flush with the sides and often had a base molding applied.

There are a few other options. If the lowest half inch of the sides are mitered instead of dovetailed, one can groove or rabbet the bottom without it showing on the outside. Not the easiest for someone who has not made a lot dovetails. I think for you, David, I would recommend either plugging the grooves or applying a small strip (like 3/8X1) around the base. I think a chest looks better with a slightly broader base.

Re: Stopped Grooves

#6

another way

Dan Donaldson

>Use slips rather than cutting the grooves.

Re: Stopped Grooves

#7

Re: Stopped Grooves - with a plough

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have a Record 044 plough plane but not the LV large router plane I want.

Hi again Dave

I would not recommend making a stopped groove with a plough, but it can be done (heck, you can do anything with any tool - you just have to be creative).

I don't have any pics of this process, but I have something similar, perhaps better since they are like a cut away of a groove.

Here is the process of what occurs when yiou use a plough to make a stopped rebate.

In the first image you see a marked out rebate with the stopped end sawn. This will be chiselled out to prevent breaking out the end. The arrows mark the grain direction.



The nect image shows the rebate cut with a plough. What you will see is that the cut curves owing to the limitation of the length of the plane's skate.



I used a router plane to clean up the waste here. In the absence of a router plane, just use a chisel (held bevel up).



The completed stopped rebate ..



... which is part of this cabinet back ..



The process should be the same for a stopped groove.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stopped Grooves

#9

Re: Stopped Grooves

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Everyone's posts seemed to cover the traditional methods of concealing the ends of the grooves. Half blind dovetails, miter the last dovetail, an outside molding, nailing the bottom into or onto the bottom of the box. When nailed inside the bottom, they float on the nails, not much attempt to worry about cross grain problems.

I have examined several nineteenth century chest and two of them had stopped grooves to secured a feather edge bottom board. The stops were on the longer boards and the shorter boards groove was shot through. I think they did this to allow a plow plane to be used for most of the waste removal on the longer boards. Both showed hand work to finish off the ends and one had remnants of small center bit drill marks in the stop end.

Stephen

Re: Stopped Grooves

#10

Re: Stopped Grooves

David Brown

>Okay, taking a moment from my busy day to post a quick response. Thanks to all the response.

Scott -- I got as far as drilling the whole, but can you clarify your technique for "work backwards toward teh edge of the board carefully? Is that with a chisel?

Warren -- Thanks for the idea of adding a strip around the bottom. I too think that might look nice. I also like the idea of mitering where the groove comes through. In the most recent PW, Roy Underhill does something like this on a chest and he uses a saw kerf to clean up the two miters after he put the dovetails together. Don't know about that for me. I'm not Roy Underhill, that's for sure.

Derek -- Again, thanks for the link. I need to spend more time perusing your excellent site. I don't have that nifty LV router plane though.

Dan (or anyone else) -- If I use slips (I read that post by Chris Schwarz), won't the inside bottom have a sort of step? I can't get clear in my mind what the inside looks like with slips.

Stephan and Warren -- When you say 18th C. boxes had the bottom nailed on, do you mean just nailed to the sides from the bottom (is there any other way)? Won't my kids (undoubtedly extra heavy) toys eventually cause the bottom to come off?

Anyway, Thanks for all the thoughts. I've certainly got some ideas. Now I just need time away from my job, kids, etc. so I can finish the projects that are in line before this and get to this.

Have a good weekend.

--Dave

Re: Stopped Grooves

#11

It's easy Dave.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>My personal favorite plane for this is a 46 the skewed blade excels here as long as your careful. BTW any plow plane can do this...

1. Use a batten as fence

Provided ifin your plane don't have knickers... Score! your gonna get lucky tonight! Then again it might be a really bad Lindsay moment...

Anyway, score the mark with a marking knife.

Most all are use to pushing the plane into the wood (from the back closest to you) to the front (farthest from you) just so we all know where I'm coming from.

Start at the hole (the front of the board) and work to the back with the plane. Shallow cuts at the start until the wall side of the groove forms. Then you can start to go back to the way some of us plane, back to front. In the end all you have to do is square up the hole.

Hope this makes scene.

Re: Stopped Grooves

#12

Re: Stopped Grooves

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Many old dovetailed chests had the bottom (usually pine or poplar even on hardwood chests) nailed on. The nails go up from the bottom into the sides. If there are no feet, the bottom sits on the floor and there is no place for the bottom to go. If there are feet, the bottom sits on the feet and cannot fall out. The dovetails are the real structure of the chest. If there is a base strip or molding, it hides the bottom.

Re: Stopped Grooves

#13

Re: Stopped Grooves

Bill Drylie

>David:

If you put a shallow (1/8" or so) rabbit on the ends of the side to have the stopped grooves you can set your plow and through plow the other sides and plow to 1/8" depth on the stopped sides with the same setting. I then increase the depth as required with chisel and router plane. In this case no fence is required on the router as it is guided by the groove the plow established. I've had good luck doing boxes like this, alyhough I must admit it has always been in cooperative woods. The idea for the rabbits I think I got from the Popular Woodworking site and is used for ease of layout for the dovetails. Sorry for joining in so late. Just got back from a trip.

Bill