We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm about to be making my first infill plane from a kit that Andy Lincoln made. The dovetail sockets on the sole piece are only notches at the moment and need to be filed to a dovetail shape. I had a few questions for you infill enthusiasts about this process:
What size, type and brand of file would you suggest I use for this and where is the best place to buy these files? (The sole of this plane is #304 stainless steel, not mild steel or ductile iron. I don't know if that demands a harder file or some other "cut.")
>I spoke to Andy but he didn't have specifics of make, model, size, cut, etc. Your idea sounds like it would work, if I can conscience a 60� angle dovetail. I guess with metal you don't have any short-grain considerations like you do with wood. (Duh.) I don't know if the aesthetics should be a determining factor.
Here's a detail shot of one of Konrad Sauer's planes that underscores my dilemma. I really admire his work and would like to emulate his successes. This shot, though, shows a more organic dovetail schedule -- varied angles and crispness of detail in the tiniest corners -- which I believe is part of the cachet of a handmade tool. That's totally in keeping with my style of working, so I'm tempted not to fret too much over exact angles or perfect symmetry, but rather to allow the peening process to fill in the spaces.
Which brings up the next question, which is how does stainless steel peen? I've always found it to be not exactly malleable. The sides on my particular plane are brass, which will peen nicely, but what about a body that is all stainless?
>> Which brings up the next question, which is how does stainless steel peen? I've always found it to be not exactly malleable. The sides on my particular plane are brass, which will peen nicely, but what about a body that is all stainless?
I several planes out of stainless, don't know the alloy, and it was quite malleable but a totally pain to machine ("sticky", toasted several endmills). Some types of brass are malleable (eg annealed 360), brass does work harden and some brasses are not very malleable.
An all stainless plane or a plane with same materials on the sole and sides � you shouldn't see the dovetails unless you look very very closely. So dovetail shape isn't an issue, you can even use finger joints or weld. Here is an example of two identical brass planes, one dovetailed and peined (top) the other finger jointed and soldered (bottom).
Re: Stainless? Have you asked Andy how he does it?
Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI
>Pam,
I have only put together one metal sided infill plane in my planemaking history.I used stainless steel because we were cutting alot of it at work and it was easy to place small plane parts in the waste/void areas of our cuts.My one and only infill scrub plane I cut most of the dovetailing with an air powered dyna-file until the pieces slid together and then I beat the c@#@p out of the pins with a ball-peen hammer.After that crude treatment I sanded the sides/bottom
on a horizontal belt sander to clean everything up.You could say I don't have alot of patience for fine,precise filing and fitting of metal parts : ).With all that being said would a toolmaker/planemaker prefer different materials?brass,ductile iron,good old mild steel?I have access to mild steel and stainless steel,occasionally brass but mostly steel and stainless steel are the common materials and it can range fron 1/8" to 1" material.Below is a picture of my scrub infill to attempt to show the dovetail results.
>I haven't received my kit from Andy yet (drive by, thanks Andy), but to create the little recess, in the side tail corners, to pein the pins into, I'll probably use a triangular saw needle file (I have lots of saw files), wishing for a safe edge. To shape the pins (on the sole), I'll use a flat file with a safe edge.
If I am not mistaken, Andy got the original design off the web from Jim Yehle. Jim has made several dovetailed infills, and I know he has some improvements to the design you have.
He is a good friend of mine, and if you want, I will have him email you with some info/advice/tips about how to proceed.
>For currently available new files, I stick to Grobet for the most part. Nicholson is hit or miss, and more miss lately. However, the best source I have is Slav the old tool clearing house. He has spectacular NOS files in huge ranges - feel free to email me if you need his contact info
For the stainless, Grobet has a line called, IIRC, Villartin or something that is made for stainless - they don't load as quickly as others, which counts a LOT with 304. I get mine from one of the jeweler's supply houses on ebay. They're pretty expensive, but you won't need more than two or three I would think.
For dovetails, I actually don't find using a triangular file to work well for the corners at all. Even the small ones still have more of a radius at the corner than I like. I use a barette needle file for that work.
A good barette needle files (I don't personally like the 6 or 8 inch ones as well), and a few smallish pillar files will do 90% of the work you need. If there are curved profile sections to be smoothed and finished with files, then a range of half-rounds is also really handy.
Also, if there's brass or bronze for sidewalls, magicut files are spectacular for those metals. I don't like them as well for O1 and they're poor for stainless.
>I use anywhere from 10-14 degrees. It's not particularly critical because the peening process locks everything up so well. Just for fun, I once peened a few 0-degree dovetails (i.e. box joints), and while it may not have been as strong as double dovetails, it was plenty strong enough for most plane work IMO. The metal deformed before the joint slipped...
>Raney spoke of Grobet, and specifically of the Valtitan line. See link below. I have ordered from Contenti before, and they are reliable. The Valtitans are ultra-high RC and clear easily, as Raney said. Also expensive.
Thanks for the clarification on the brand... I've used contenti as well - very reliable, and a huge selection of stuff.
Most of the time now, I use "Tools for Jewels" ebay store. Their prices are a little bit better, but they're also much closer to me (NJ) so I get orders within two days most of the time. Shipping is also quite a bit more reasonable in general.