Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The Unplaned plane

Posts

The Unplaned plane

#1

The Unplaned plane

David Brown

>This is a woodworker's proof for the existence of God (but it's not really religious!). And my apologies go to Aristotle.

So I got this book on how to make a plane and it says under tools required, a plane. What? So to make a plane I need a plane. And to make that one, I need one. And to make that I need one. Well, who made the first plane?

In other words, where is the unplaned plane?

I believe this is akin to Aristotle's unmoved mover, i.e. God. So because planes exist and because you always require a plane to make a plane, we can know that there must be a god who made the first plane. He is, in essence, the unplaned plane.

I find this idea amusing and it was meant in good fun. I'm sure Aristotle's name doesn't get mentioned very often.

Cheers.

--Dave

Re: The Unplaned plane

#2

Re: The Unplaned plane

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, all very logical; but in fact you don't need a plane to make a plane. Or, more to the point, the plane you need can take many forms, such as a yarikana (blade that looks like a leaf with long handle), a hatchet (or chono), knife, scrapers, etc.

Pam

Re: The Unplaned plane

#3

I love those . . .

steve mackay

>un-planed cosmic mysteries. Chicken / egg, plane / plane, . . .

Re: The Unplaned plane

#4

Re: The Unplaned plane

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY

>Today I was making a box for a whet stone I got on eBay out of some (what I think is) rosewood from some crating that protected some furniture my sailor son bought in Pakistan. (Or was it India? They ran the ship on the shore so that it could be scrapped. Sad state of affairs for American merchant marine, but I degress...) I needed to make a groove for the lid to slide in and out of, but I had already cut the pieces (ie, they were too small to use the #50 because I couldn't figure out how to hold them, which I was planning on doing all the time.) Instead, I sawed two parallel cuts, & pared the stuff in between down with a chisel. Woa, that worked quite well! It made me think of the planeing I was doing with a (very sharp) "side" axe the day before on some green stock. It was clean, and smooth. And I've worked other stock to *very* flat with a draw knife in the path.

Bottom line, I don't believe you don't need no stinkn' plane to make a plane.

greg

Re: The Unplaned plane

#5

Re: The Unplaned plane

James Watriss

>I think I had a similar experience when I stopped to appreciate a micrometer I found in my late Uncle's apartment.

It's an old Brown and Sharpe, I think. (don't remember off the top of my head, too lazy right now to go find it.) Anyway, it was really something to think that over years, people had taken an arbitrary measurement, standardized it, and managed to develop methods to subdivide it sufficiently to then develop a way to cut threads on a rod that were precise enough to then be able to measure things to an even finer degree, still using that arbitrary measurement as a starting point.

Reminded me of a story I heard in college, about an ambitious young outdoorsy/ geeky engineering type who went out into the woods. He cut himself a stick and used that as his unit of measurement, to then build himself a small house out there. He now, according to the story, keeps that original measuring unit on his mantelpiece.

Re: The Unplaned plane

#6

It takes Two, or The Unplanned - Unplaned plane

stewart spiers

>I've found it usually takes more than one plane to make a plane. For that reason, it seems like a good idea to keep your planes separated at night or make sure they always have some form of protection readily available.

Or next thing you know you have an extended family and your wife will be asking you, "Where did all these planes come from?"

Re: The Unplaned plane

#7

"...some form of protection readily available..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You mean like plane socks?

Re: The Unplaned plane

#8

Re: It takes Two, or The Unplanned - Unplaned plan

David Brown

>Now that's useful advice. I laughed when I read it, but I'll remember it.

--Dave

Re: The Unplaned plane

#9

I have had them for a long time usually works

Wayne

>

Re: The Unplaned plane

#10

Same goes for workbenches, go figure...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Now if I leave 2 benches alone for the night...