Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

Posts

Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#1

Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>The Veritas small plow plane has two shortcomings, as much as I can tell. The length of the rods limits a cut to within 1 1/2" from the edge of the piece being worked on and the widest cutter is 3/8". I assume I can make longer rods and wider cutters myself. Will the plane allow the use of wider cutters and will longer rods throw off the balance? Also are my two perceived shortcomings that important? The Record 044 could be used out to about 4 1/2" or 5" and had eight cutters up to 9/16".

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#2

Maybe that's why it's called small plow plane?

Alexander Grigoriev

>

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#3

The Record 044 _IS_ a small plough plane

Andy in Vermont

>

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#4

Plow plane blades

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Are you saying you've used a 044 with the blade extended 4.5"?

Pam

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#5

Re: The Record 043 is a SMALLER plough plane

David Cockey

>And the Record 050 / Stanley 50 are good somewhat larger plough planes.

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#6

Re: Plow plane blades

Terry in Ottawa

>I think he's saying that the Record plane can cut a dado 4 1/2" in from the edge and can cut a dado up to 9/16" side. I don't think he was talking about blade projection.

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#7

Good, cause what I thought won't work.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#8

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Patrick

The ideal use for the Veritas Small Plow is grooving boxes and drawers for bottoms or lids. It is not intended for dados, since it lacks a nicker, but I have used it successfully in the way. Use need then to do so with a batten for a guide, not rely on a fence. I doubt that a long fence would be stable enough on the #044 as well.

I have also used the Veritas SP comfortably to cut rebates.

Keep in mind that the Veritas SP really is aimed at the #043/#044, which is a small plough. I understand that there is a large version in the pipe line (according to a certain R. Lee :) ).

Regards from Sydney (for the weekend)

Derek

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#9

Large plow plane *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Why, yes, there is one in the works - and we saw it here first.


Large plow plane photo last year

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#10

Joe McMahon

Re: Large plow plane

Joe McMahon

>Yeah Bill, but do dat large 'un come in a lefty version??? ;-)

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#11

Hey Derek

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I read your review before I posted my two objections. These objections are really questions. I'm trying to determine, since a left-handed version is now available, if this plane would suit my needs. I have a Stanley combo that I've grown dissatisfied with over the last many uses. For dados I too prefer to use a router plane. So maybe I can go into the shop without my nickers and be OK. At least as long as I'm covered. Do I need a plow that will make a trench wider than 3/8" and do I need to make it further than 1 1/2" from the edge. I haven't been able to think of a time I needed to plow a groove further from the edge than that and indeed, generally much closer than that. Because plows traditionally had greater perameters than the Veritas plow (I'm talking about wooden plows mostly) I was hoping others could give me some insight. I was also hoping Mr. Lee might shoot us a picture of anything new in the works.

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#12

Of course, but then

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>you have to buy left-footed dogs to run it.

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#13

I'm not Derek, couldn't even play him on TV

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but I've got some thoughts (mine alone - YMMV, naturally):

1. I've decided against replacing my RH plow with the left hand version. I realized in thinking about it that all my other fenced planes are right handed, and, like most lefties, I've gotten used to using right handed tools over the year, to the point that left handed versions often feel awkward (I can't abide left handed scissors, for instance); so I think one LH fenced tool would feel odd. Of course, if the lottery gods smile down on me (we give them and Publishers Clearing House the opportunity regularly, but, so far, they've been sourpusses), I might get it just in case, but in the meantime, I'll soldier on with the original.

2. I've made limited but very satisfactory use of my LV small plow so far. It's been referred to as a Record 044 equivalent, but I think Rob and his elves were really shooting for a target placed between the Record 043 and 044 (the VERY rare Record 043-1/2, found only in antique stores with stocks of $3 bills). There's no sliding section, and the cutting irons reference against the right edge (on the RH version...), so you're supporting just part of any iron wider than 1/8", and that along one side of the iron's face. This seems to work up to the 3/8" max iron provided, but I visualize wider irons trying to fall off the skate. I could easily be wrong, here - as best I can tell, the 044 didn't have a sliding section either, and it's not clear to me how the irons registered; but I think a relatively narrow limit was a good engineering move on LV's part.

Wooden plows seem to reference the iron on the centerline of the iron, so wider irons are feasible, and, of course, the 050, Stanley 45/55, 46, and so on, have sliding sections to support each edge of the iron.

But: When I got the LV plow, it became the third plane of this type I owned (along with two 45 bodies), and is now the fourth (added a 55 since then; actually, maybe fifth if you count the Stanley 48 - he looks slightly abashed and shuffles his feet), so I saw the LV plane as a specialist, intended as a plow only, and focusing on such tasks as tonguing and panel-groove making. I have found it helps make good rabbets wider than 3/8", by establishing the inside wall of the rabbet, with the remainder to be cleaned out with an appropriate bench plane; faster, actually, than a 78 will in my hands.

Hope this will be helpful.

One of the problems LV has been creating for me with its regular introduction of new toy-- scratch that, tools - is that I think I'll want to spend some more money down the line, but really can't get more than one, and so am currently suffering from the agonies of the gleaner - is the skew rabbet the tool, or should I wait for...?

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#14

Re: I'm not Derek, couldn't even play him on TV

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Alright Bill, you convinced me. That and the fact I was hoping no one would talk me out of it. But have you ever needed to plow a groove more than 3/8" wide?

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#15

wide grooves...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think the business card holder I made by grooving some stock and then shaping it may have had a wider groove.

But you can't rely on my experience here. Furniture-making's been far, far too infrequent in the last 20 years (the period when I finally got tooled up and marginally skilled-up), and modern carpentry doesn't use a lot of grooves, dados, or other joinery; and plumbing, electrical work, car repair, etc., even less.

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

#16

Re: Shortcomings of Veritas Plow Plane

Chris Friesen

>I wonder if the longer rods (originally for the skew rabbet plane) would work with the plow? They're 2 1/2" longer than the original rods.