Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Wooden screw in leg vise

Posts

Wooden screw in leg vise

#1

Wooden screw in leg vise

wilbur

>I have a wooden screw that I want to use in a leg vise for my workbench. The screw comes with a wooden nut already made, in the form of a rectangular block. My workbench leg is a bit over 5" thick.

The two ways I can think of to do this are:

1. Drill a hole through the leg big enough for the screw, and attach the nut on the backside. The advantage of this is that it will be easy to build. The disadvantage is that I lose 5" or so of vise capacity.

2. Cut a mortise in the vise to accept the nut, and glue it in. The advantage is that my cise capacity will be about the length of the screw. The disadvantages that I can see is that this is more complicated, and I might weaken the leg in the process.

Which would you do, or are there any other suggestions as to how to do this?

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#2

I think it depends, Wilbur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>on what kind of work you see yourself doing. If you're planning to build more stuff at the scale of your workbench legs, you want all the capacity you can get, and time spent on putting the nut on the front makes sense.

On the other hand, gluing the nut in the leg commits you forever, and any weakness in the gluing could doom the vise. If you're going to that trouble, you might consider a two-level mortise, deeper for the nut, with a larger, shallower mortise for a steel or brass plate from the salvage yard holding it in (this week's game: let's see how we can over-complicate Wilbur's project!).

My vise rarely opens more than 3-4", and thicker/wider stuff tends to go on the benchtop. If this is likely to be your case, putting the nut behind is a stronger construction.

I will repeat a warning I've offered earlier with leg vises. Although Chris Schwarz does not mention this to my memory, if you use the benchtop as part of your vise's back jaw, make darned sure the top is firmly fastened to the legs, or else extend the leg somehow to the top of the benchtop. My grandfather's leg vise, an otherwise excellent device, levered the benchtop backwards over the years, so that clamping actually occurred 1-1/2" down in the jaws, at the top of the leg.

I plan to use his leg vise screw to reconstitute a leg vise (love 'em and am not impressed with conventional iron vises, after experimenting with one for a while), but will probably notch out the benchtop to permit extending a full-thickness vise jaw up to benchtop level.

I note that the several commercial leg vise screws I've picked up over the years (another $1 item I can't turn down...) are short, not much more than 12", with the nut designed to go behind a leg. Between the leg and the movable jaw, the vise capacity's probably not more than 8".

Incidentally, if you decide to put the nut on the back, it may not need elaborate holding. My grandfather's leg vise screw, made (I believe) by my uncle in the 1930's, has a similar block-shaped nut, but of iron. When I examined his bench after getting it from my cousin some years back, I found the nut held in place behind the leg with four scraps of wood, obviously grabbed off the shop floor (two of them were splits, just kind of tacked in place to hold the other two still). You might consider trapping the nut in a (gasp!) plywood cutout or two, so as not to make holes in it.

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#3

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

How much meat do you have to cut out of the leg if you mortise for the nut?

Wiley

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#4

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

The wooden nut that I have is 12"L x 3-1/2"W x 2"D, and would be set in a leg that's 5-1/4" square. I could always cut down the length without problems, I'm sure.

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#5

Re: I think it depends, Wilbur

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

The wooden screw that I have is 14" long. Subtract the thickness of the leg, the thickness of the front jaw of the leg vise, and another inch for the screw to be engaged in the nut when fully open, and that leaves me with a vise capacity of 5" max. Do you think that's enough?

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#6

How I Made Mine >> Pic

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi Wilbur,

I used much the same leg vise components that you describe. I used laminations of 1 3/4" maple to make my leg for the vise, I cut my mortice in to fit my nut. The nut floats in mine, but is a snug fit.

Hope the picture helps

Photobucket

Be Well,

Jim

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#7

Jim got it right

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>the nut should float. On old benches, the nut would be just under the bench top and the rectangular shape prevents it from turning but it still works the chops.

Stephen

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#8

Does seem kind of minimal, probably inadequate

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#9

Another alternative

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Jim Shaver's picture brings up the point that you could mortise the back of the leg as easily as the front. If I'm reading his picture right, it appears he may have mortised in from the side, halfway through the leg - ? Another chance to use your big mortise chisel and newly acquired skills...

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#10

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

2" deep. So you could mortise it into the middle of a 5" leg, and have 1-1/2" of meat on either side. That seems OK to me. I think the only thing to watch for is not to make the mortise too near the top of the leg where the tenons emerge.

Because the vise action is trying to shear the tenons off the legs. It can't do it, of course, but if the mortise is too near the tenons, there would be some short grain between the tenons' bases and the mortise which might fracture.

Wiley

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#11

P.S.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>When I said the vise is trying to shear the tenons, I was assuming that the vise chop is pressing the work against the edge of the benchtop. However, that may not be a good assumption on my part. If the leg is installed so that it is set flush into the edge of the benchtop, then this leg-strain thing would not happen. I think I recall that the original Roubo bench had such a design, with the near tenon being dovetailed into the bench top right at the edge.

Wiley

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#12

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

Dan Donaldson

>How about notching the front of the leg to take the nut and putting a metal plate on the front to hold it in. The green part of the attached image would be the metal plate, with the nut captured behind it and a hole in the plate and the leg for the screw.


img

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#13

Great minds

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>or, in this case, one great one and one (mine) marginally functional one. I offered the same thought, but less elegantly than you did.

Still, it could be complex, especially with such a big nut - I'd pictured one about 3x4 inches.

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#14

Re: Jim got it right

ThomD

>Is it right, or is a tapped hole in the leg better. Would be my assumption but the floating nut might reduce binding somehow. Or allow replacement with wear.

What are the typical dimensions for these things: Diameter of the threaded section, the end that holds the handle, and the pitch of the thread. I was thinking of setitng up a lathe to cut these.

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#15

Re: Great minds

Dan Donaldson

>Not really, just get a chunk of 1/4 inch steel plate large enough, cut a slot for it, then cut the groove for the nut. Use a few screws to hold the metal in and it should take any amount of force you would apply with a wooden screw, plus it would not take up much of the screw length.

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#16

Floating nut and wear

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I had my nut loose under the bench top for about 25 years. Then about five years ago I made a shallow mortise in the back of the leg. It is perhaps a little more stable, but this is certainly not necessary. I do not think wear will be a problem for the next century.

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#17

Yep, That's it...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Scott Perry did a great thread on this. Check the archives!

Re: Wooden screw in leg vise

#18

Duh...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Great idea. I always feel better and less for wear when my nuts...

Never mind, too much info ;^)