Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Question about traditional practice

Posts

Question about traditional practice

#1

Question about traditional practice

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Say you're making a cabinet door that will be glassed. I have a question about the stiles--the vertical members of the door frame that carry the mortises. What was the traditional trade practice for making the stopped rabbets in the stiles? For some reason, I'm finding that doing 98% of the waste removal with a hammer and chisel, and finishing with a router plane, is about as good as making more use of the router. This is using wood that is quite hard--satinwood.

How did the old guys do this job?

Thanks, Wiley

P. S. It's a greater router plane (LV large) and I like it a lot. just finding that the wood to be wasted disappears faster using the chisel.

Re: Question about traditional practice

#2

Re: Question about traditional practice

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The rabbets are made with a moving fillister. The rabbet extends the whole length of the stile. The rails have different shoulder line for the tenons on the back so as to fill the void made by the rabbet.

Re: Question about traditional practice

#3

Re: Question about traditional practice

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

I think Warren got it right or at least the easiest way to accomplish that task. Given that stop rabbits do show up on old pieces and as to how they could easily be done.

The rabbit is laid out using a marking gauge to mark the width and depth of the rabbit. Next use a saw or chisel to make the stop cuts on both ends first. The easiest method is to use a coach-makers rabbit plane with a short sole. Then finish with router plane or chisels.

On softwoods, I have used a slitting gauge and saw to make stopped rabbits. I slit in from the top and side, easily starting and stopping at the end cuts.

I don't know if that is how the old guys did it, but it is how this old guy works.

Stephen

Re: Question about traditional practice

#4

Re: Question about traditional practice

Bob Rozaieski

>I agree. I think one would make a full length rabbet and make the shoulder of the rail tenon different lengths front and back.

Doing a raised panel door with coped or mitered sticking is a similar process except the longer shoulder is in the front instead of the back because the sticking is removed from the cope to the end of the door frame.

Something like this except you would have a rabbet on the inside edge instead of a groove.


Your stile would look something like this but where I have the sticking you would have a full length rabbet (like where the sticking is removed).


The different length shoulder fills the rabbet when the mortise and tenon are joined.

Re: Question about traditional practice

#5

Re: Question about traditional practice

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thank you very much, Warren, Stephen and Bob! I'm sitting here laughing and crying at the same time, at having done the job so stupidly. I also seem to recall that Don McConnell even explained this all to me at great length before, in a bit different context, but the lesson didn't stick. Well, it'll stick now.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: Question about traditional practice

#6

Very nice pics Bob...

John in NM

>If I were to, say, hypothetically, use a table saw to make doors, I'd probably even use it to do the same! Of course no one over on this side would actually use a table saw! ;)

Re: Question about traditional practice

#7

Re: Question about traditional practice

Don McConnell

>Wiley et al,

Now that you mention it, I do recall we had a discussion about this, but am not sure we got into a lot of detail.

In any event, as has already been mentioned, the traditional practice was to take the rabbet clear through on both the rails and stiles. However, if you are using a moulding stuck from the face of the rails and stiles and mitering at the joint, you won't have tenon shoulders of differing lengths. Rather, on the stile, you cut the moulding down level with the floor of the rabbet from the terminus of the miter outward. I'm including a scan of an illustration, taken from Charles Hayward's _Woodwork Joints_ which, hopefully, makes this clear. Personally, I would probably add a sloping/hidden haunch to the joint in the illustration.

Incidentally, this image is part of a three page layout of illustrations showing the "Stages in cutting Mortise-and-tenon joint for Framework with rebated-in panel and stuck moulding," pages 39-41. Really helps visualize the basic steps in creating a cabinet door of this type.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR


img