Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

Posts

A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#1

A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang,

I got this No 4 1/2 from Ebay some time last week with the plan of cleaning it up and offering it up sale in the Classifieds. When it arrived it was in sadder shape than I expected. The iron was from a No4 sized wood plane and was the tapered variety and the chip breaker was from a Sargent (which would not work with this yoke). The tote was from another (larger) handplane and the rear hardware was missing. With some help from a couple of my friends I got (or am getting) the parts I needed.

Before:

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

I had a heavy old Hudson Tool Company iron that was sharpened to the point where it would almost split an atom. I stole a Chip Breaker and Lever Cap Screw from my beater No6, and the tote was one I had in the bone yard. The entire plane was soaked in Evaporust then the sole was flattened, and the body cleaned up and polished.



After:

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket



One I got the sole flattened the performance of this plane went through the roof!

Gratuitous Action Shots:

Photobucket

Photobucket



If you think this was a "rag to riches" story, then wait till you see the other plane that I got along with this 4 1/2! It is coated entirely in black glossy paint! (E-YUCK!!). That one will take a bit longer to clean up.

Thanks for viewing!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#2

the flat sole society

paul womack

>Once I got the sole flattened the performance of this plane went through the roof!

Interesting, since many people view sole flattening as "often not needed".

Do you have any quantitive idea of how un-flat it was before your work, and how did you do the flattening, please?

BugBear

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#3

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: the flat sole society

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Paul,

You wrote:

"Interesting, since many people view sole flattening as "often not needed".

Just after the Evaporust bath and general cleaning this plane was re-assembled and tested with a donor iron and chip breaker (one that had been tuned up as well as possible). I then ran it's through it's paces and noticed an issue right away. I was unable to get the kind of shavings that I could with my Type 11 No 4-1/2. This caused me to look at the sole with a critical eye.

"Do you have any quantitive idea of how un-flat it was before your work, and how did you do the flattening, please?"

When you say "quantitive" I assume you want to hear "It was 0.005" out over an area such and such wide". Not going to happen. I tested it with a machinist's straight edge and feeler gauges. The area near the mouth was out of flat enough to make me feel that flatenning would help.

Were you going to point me here?

Sole Flatness

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#4

Large Mouldings

paul womack

>When you say "quantitive" I assume you want to hear "It was 0.005" out over an area such and such wide".

That would be ideal, but I'm aware it's unlikely. It's rather hard to measure.

Not going to happen. I tested it with a machinist's straight edge and feeler gauges. The area near the mouth was out of flat enough to make me feel that flatenning would help.

Were you going to point me here?

Sole Flatness

Well it might have come up :-) But I wasn't simply going to force my methods down your throat - I was genuinely interested in what you found effective.

BugBear

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#5

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Re: Large Mouldings

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>OK, what the heck is "Large Mouldings"???

Anyway...back to the matter at hand....

Typically if I suspect a sole is not flat (in the critical areas), I will check it with a machinist's straight edge and feeler gauges. If I'm not satisfied with the results (i.e. I get contradictory or way over the top readings) I'll bring the plane into work and use our granite inspection table to check it. I've toyed with the idea of using a jig to securely hold the plane upside down on an inspection table to run a dial indicator across it. But I decided that would be a "bit much". :>)

After determining that the sole is not flat, I coat it with Dye Chem and then give it a couple of swipes on my lapping surface (my jointer table with 80grit PSA attached). And yes, I checked the jointer table for flatness. A visual inspection will usually confirm my findings and highlight the are that is not flat.

This being said, I have started to re-evaluate sole flattening. If a plane does not need it (it works just fine as it is), I will not try to flatten the sole.

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#6

aargh!

paul womack

>OK, what the heck is "Large Mouldings"???

It's my browser remembering the subject of the LAST thread I posted to :-(

BugBear

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#7

metrology

paul womack

> I've toyed with the idea of using a jig to securely hold the plane upside down on an inspection table to run a dial indicator across it.

Easier like this (since you've mentioned access to all the component parts)

measuring a plane sole

(I guess you hadn't seen all my pages ... )

BugBear (slightly obsessive)

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#8

Large Mouldings happen when...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>You actually modify a 4.5 smoother into a moulding plane. Of course these are pulled by horses or man, what ever was cheaper at the time...

Re: A cleaned up Stanley Type 19 No 4 1/2

#9

Sorry Dom!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Another sweet one!