Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Use of Snipe Bill

Posts

Use of Snipe Bill

#1

Use of Snipe Bill

Ed DeLauter

>I am looking for information on the correct use of a snipe bill plane when making molding.

I have one and am a little fuzzy as to the proper method of using it.

I understand it is supposed to make a registration point for a hollow or round when making a particular molding profile.

Thanx,

Ed

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#2

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Chuck Nickerson

>Don McConnell has a DVD on this topic, available from Lie-Nielsen. It's called "Traditional Moulding Techniques". I own it and it's very informative. Don's snipe bill technique is quite slick, but some will tell you it's not necessary. But then, people used to do all their woodworking with dull rocks.

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#4

Re: new DVD

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, enjoyed the first dvd, so am ready to order the second (I'm also half way through your's, very good). There is also an interesting sounding dvd on furniture design by George Walker. Do you know who he is?

Pam

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#5

George Walker

Larry Williams

>Pam,

I don't know George Walker and haven't talked to him. Don spoke to him at length a couple times, if I remember right. I believe Don's impression was that he had some good information planned for the DVD.

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#6

OK, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#7

Re: new DVD

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>Pam,

I've known George 3-4 years through SAPFM. He has done a very large amount of research into classical design and demonstrated much of what was to be on the DVD at Ohio River Valley chapter meetings. I haven't seen the DVD, so I can't comment on content other than to say it probably gathers more information about Classical Design and the Classic Orders into one place than is available anywhere else.

He has written several articles that have appeared in Fine Woodworking and has some articles planned for Popular Woodworking(I think).

Jim

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#8

Thanks, Jim

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'll probably buy it after processing Don's and Larry's. Learning takes so much time. :)

Pam

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#9

Re: Use of Snipe Bill *LINK*

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I don't about the word "correct" in your question, Ed. I think the original intended purpose for the snipe bill plane was the obvious purpose, the creation of quirks. I think Don's approach is a good one, but I'm not as convinced as he is that this was how things were done.

You don't actually HAVE to use a snipe bill to make a molding- it's not essential, it's one of many approaches. I've used a plow with an 1/8" cutter for jobs like this. I also tend to just waste away excess material with a jack plane, then do the concave portions first, fencing the planes with my fingers- a technique I think I learned from Don long ago.

It's not actually possible (for me at least) to disagree with Larry or Don and not have the discussion turn ugly. So this will be my last word on this thread. I liked the video. I learned stuff I didn't know. I'll get the next one. I don't think snipe bills were designed to create features for other planes. I think they were designed to make quirks. But the technique is a good one and people may well have done exactly what Don shows.

Also, the process of making the molding by setting in every cut seemed painfully slow to me. I found that off-putting. For architectural molding, where you need 200 linear feet all exactly the same, such an approach may be absolutely essential. I've done some architectural molding and I tend to use complex molders for just that purpose. For furniture, I find this less so. I make one single run of molding. I cut it up and piece it on, keeping the ends together. This reduces any ill effects of variation in the profile.

Another aspect that I'd like to hear more about is the link between the species and the set-up of the planes. At WiA, Don had these large crown sections in cherry, I think he had one in maple. I've never seen 18th c architectural moldings like those in anything but pine. You might want a different answer for an architectural molding in pine and furniture moldings in mahogany, walnut, or cherry. I think Don was using "furniture planes" for an architectural molding in his dvd. Many of us have "architectural molders" we try to use as furniture planes.

For folks fascinated by moldings, the Philadelphia Museum of Art is hosting another open house at Mount Pleasant in Fairmount Park Sunday, April 26. This mansion's impressive and intact woodwork, dating from the early 1760's, is on display. The house really hasn't been refurnished since restoration was done a few years ago (new roof, some structure, fixed up dormers), leaving the interior woodwork accessible. The tour guide will very likely be the Director of Education from the museum. The museum's conservators will likely be on hand as well.

The original builder's documents including his account book and the price book he personally owned and annotated are in public hands. The latter, featuring molding profiles with hand written prices next to them, is available in the HABS (search for Thomas Nevell). You should be able to print out a few pages, locate the moldings in the house, and find out exactly what Nevell thought was a fair price for that profile. Close examination will reveal how large moldings were split up into smaller sections. You should be able to tell what was cut with a complex molder and what wasn't. I warn you, however. This is not Williamsburg Virginia. All the ballusters match, no slaves were used to cut these moldings and almost everything is original. This is probably the best of Colonial America's interior woodwork. This is the house John Adams said was the finest seat in all of Pennsylvania. If you go, be sure to ask about paint finishes. They are doing some new research on that subject.

Oh, and if you are unsure of the connection between architectural and furniture design, be sure to visit the second floor where an Affleck highboy sits beside a mantle piece for your comparison.

Adam


Mt. Pleasant Open House

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#10

Large Mouldings

paul womack

>Here in the UK it's quite common for large (12" and up) visible beams (Oak, obviously) to be quite elaborately moulded, and the mouldings atre commonly "stopped" too.

Does anyone know how these were cut? They certainly weren't built up!

BugBear

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#11

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Don McConnell

>Having already been cast the villain, I'm really disinclined to respond to your post, Adam, but I feel compelled to at least correct a few points of fact.

As to using "furniture planes" for an architectural moulding in my first DVD, that simply isn't true. (Though other than casting doubt on my credibility, I'm not sure exactly what you were driving at.) Yes, the Corinthian ogee from Chippendale is based on ancient architectural forms, but if you leaf through his _Director_ you'll see that he shows it a number of times in conjunction with specific pieces of furniture. The H&R pair I used to produce that moulding is at half pitch, appropriate for woods other than pine, and Cherry was a perfectly appropriate timber to use. Though Chippendale likely would have been using mahogany.

Secondly, you state that you've only ever seen cornice mouldings, such as the ones we had in our booth at WIA, in pine. Implying, I guess, that they are architectural mouldings and that to show them in Cherry is, somehow, inappropriate. One of the cornice mouldings is directly out of Sheraton, and he calls for it to be made of Mahogany. I'm assuming it would be intended for a piece of furniture, albeit a larger case piece. The second cornice was from a built in eighteenth-century cupboard of pine, and so was originally more of an architectural form. The third was from a nineteenth century "vernacular" cabinet, made of walnut. The perplexing thing is that we had a drawing or a photo, under each of the cornice mouldings, identifying its source/usage. So you could have discovered that for yourself if you had actually been interested enough to take a look. We used Cherry because that was what we had on hand, and chose three cornice mouldings with some similar features but very different overall appearance in order to illustrate some of the great variety of possibilities available if one has the right tools and knows how to use them. So, I fail to see how we were misrepresenting anything, which, I guess, is what you were attempting to imply?

Which leads directly to more subjective issues of interpretation. I guess we agree that drawings were often provided for laying out and executing architectural mouldings. Well, I don't know how representative it was, but Sheraton clearly implies that the same was true for cabinetmakers. At least in some instances. Dare I say, possibly in the better shops? This is in keeping with the fact that both Chippendale and Sheraton spend some time showing how the proportions of mouldings can be accurately laid out. Why bother if one was then simply going to wade in freehand? So I think a case can be made that some cabinet-makers in the eighteenth century worked from drawings and took some care in laying them out prior to putting tool to wood.

Obviously people are free to do as they please, but my feeling is that taking some time to design a moulding gives you a chance to assess whether the tools you have on hand will allow you to execute the design (and make adjustments if necessary), as well as plan out an orderly progression of steps which will allow you to work as directly and accurately as possible. In other words, I feel a little planning and layout is conducive to a satisfying and successful outcome. I find needless frustration and mediocre results to be off-putting.

As to the role of snipe's bill planes, I hope I made my case for them in the new DVD, so I'm not going to try to argue that in detail, here. What I present in the DVD is my best interpretation of Sheraton's intent in his section on Cornices, but, obviously, it will be up to others to decide if it makes sense to them. I may be lacking in imagination, but have not been able to come up with a satisfactory alternative explanation. In the meantime, what I do know is that this interpretation, in which snipe's bill planes play a pivotal role, allows one to design and execute complex, and sprung, mouldings in a very direct and satisfactory manner.

As Sheraton says, in introducing the topic of working cornices: " ... but from the bungling manner in which I have seen many workmen proceed to stick cornices, I am certain that a few hints will be of service, especially to the inexperienced. ... " All I can say is that my previous efforts at producing cornice mouldings now seem "bungling" by comparison, and I hope the information in the DVD will be helpful to other people. I know that Larry and I have remarked to each other that we wish we'd figured this out some thirty years ago.

As Sheraton's remark makes clear, not every cabinet-maker of his day used this approach. So, again, people are free to proceed in a manner which makes the most sense to them. And I do want to caution that success with this approach does largely depend on being able to sharpen and tune your tools to near optimum performance. Given that caveat, I am comfortable in stating that this approach will enable anyone, willing to give it an honest chance, to create any moulding they can envision and draw-out in a direct and predictable manner. In which case, it can also be fun and satisfying.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#12

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used the marking gauge/snipe bill method for starting a rabbet occasionally since around 1988. But I think it is wrong to give the impression that the snipe bill is needed to produce fine complex moldings. One technique I sometimes use for crown moldings is to glue the secondary wood (which is somewhat narrower) to the back of the piece to be molded and leave it with its square corners until after the piece is molded. That way the backing piece can be held in the vise while the molding is worked with plow, rabbet, molding planes, etc. This is nice for somebody like me who uses an older style bench without benchdogs. The plow and the moving fillister, with their fences and stops are really handy for making molding, and especially for making identical moldings, or for making the same moldings years later from shop notes. And I think plow and fillister are both simpler to sharpen and maintain than the snipe bill.

Peter Nicholson worked as a cabinetmaker in late 18th century London; he wrote this about the snipe bill. "A snipesbill is a moulding plane for forming a quirk: snipesbills are of two kinds, one for sinking a quirk, called a sinking snipesbill, and the other for cleaning the vertical flat side of the quirk, called a side snipesbill. Each of these two kinds are right and left." Nothing about complex moldings. And frankly, I am having trouble remembering seeing many quirks on 18th century American furniture.

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#13

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Ed DeLauter

>Warren,

I am mostly inexperienced when it comes to producing handworked moulding. I own a couple complex moulding planes, a couple H & R's, and the ubiquitous bead moulders. I am afraid Adam and Don's (whom are both vastly more experienced than myself) snipes bill analysis is a bit of overkill for me.

From what you mentioned evidently the snipes bill I just purchased is a "side" version. The profile goes down to a sharp narrow angle with about an inch or so of straight vertical iron. In playing around with it you can only have the slightest protrusion of the iron or it will grab and chatter against the work.

I was trying to envision how this "side snipe" would be used any differently than say a rebate plane. Since the iron profile is so narrow at the bottom does this allow the woodworker to work down inside a hollow to modify an adjacent vertical face?

I am hoping I can gather enough information to properly use this new tool and avoid the historical minutiae. I'm just a pragmatic Arkansas hillbilly trying to make some furniture moulding and maybe employ this new plane to my advantage.

It seems the purchase of a book or DVD dedicated to moulding and it's creation is now in order.

Further suggestions from the members on books and videos is always welcome.

Ed -in the Ozarks of north Arkansas

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#14

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Don McConnell

>First, Warren, I find it interesting that you choose to characterize me as giving the impression that the snipe's bill is "needed" to produce complex mouldings. I never said any such thing in my previous message - in fact, I explicitly acknowledged that not all cabinetmakers in the 18th century worked cornices as Sheraton described. Also, that people, today, should feel free to work as best fits them. Surely you can disagree with me about the efficacy of Sheraton's approach without mischaracterizing my position?

Obviously the approach you outline will work, but let me touch on a couple of benefits of working in the manner described by Sheraton. For one thing, because the spring and top lines have already been defined by planing away the waste, the primary work of creating rabbets to define the elements of the cornice moulding can be done while working on the plumb and level. For another, since the waste is already planed away, there is no necessity to lay the cornice on its moulded face, or devise some messy work-around, in order to plane/cut away the waste. Beyond that, I'll simply ask that people at least watch the DVD before they start casting doubt on it.

As to Nicholson, it might be useful to consider this sentence from his _Mechanic's Companion_, 1832. It occurs in his paragraph on "Hollows and Rounds": " ... Mouldings depressed within the surface of a piece of wood, or those which form quirks, must first be sunk by the snipesbill, and formed into the intended shape by hollows and rounds. ... [p. 111]" This sounds remarkably similar to Sheraton's approach for "gaging and working cornices" as I understand it.

I think it also elucidates a passage from Richard Neve's _Builder's Dictionary_, third edition, published in 1736. I've included an image of the crucial paragraphs from his description of planes. These prominent mentions (occurring over a period of nearly a century) of snipe's bill planes in the context of hollows and rounds indicates, to me, that Sheraton's approach wasn't a singular, or momentary, event in the history woodworking.

Again, I'm in no way attempting to imply that everyone must work this way. Rather, I think it's becoming clear that Sheraton's approach was one representative trade practice of his time, and people may find it useful if they are interested in creating complex, especially sprung, mouldings. Or, at least, they may, hopefully, feel somewhat enriched simply knowing something more about trade practices in the eighteenth century.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR


img

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#15

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Ed, the snipe bill has the cutting edge on the bottom (curved part of the iron) and works to cut a quirk (narrow groove) in the stock. The side snipe has the cutting edge on the side of the plane and is used for cleaning the vertical surface of a quirk. I think the side snipe is not very useful without a matching snipe bill.

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#16

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Ace Karner

>Don, I ordered your new DVD when Larry mentioned it when this thread first started, got it in the mail today and all I can say is WOW!!

I'm already thinking about a project that I can make that will need a proper cornice.

You've done a wonderful job of taking me (the student) from the beginning steps in the first DVD to the next rung in the molding ladder.

I had seen your post a few months back about this DVD and had been waiting for it to come out, it was well worth the wait and is even more than I could have hoped for.

Thanks for sharing with a humble apprentice, :)

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#17

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I took Nicholson's "mouldings depressed within the surface of a piece of wood" to be moldings like a sunken bead, which would require two quirks, or a sunken ogee, which would require one quirk. I thought "or those which require quirks" made that clear. Perhaps you consider all moldings to be "depressed within the surface". If so, why does Nicholson distinguish some as "depressed".

Do you advocate the use of the snipe bill for all rabbets on the edge of a board, like those for sash, or the back of a case, or bottom of a drawer?

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

#18

Re: Use of Snipe Bill

Don McConnell

>Warren et al,

I can't really claim to read Nicholson's mind, but I think it's a bit of a stretch to read ... "... Mouldings depressed within the surface of a piece of wood, or those which form quirks ... . ..." as including only those mouldings with quirks.

What I can say is that if one follows Sheraton's discussion "Of the Method of gaging and working Cornices," one arrives at a point where he, or she, is faced with a sloping surface, adorned only with previously struck gauge lines, into which the entire cornice moulding needs to be sunk. And a fenced plane, such as a moving fillister, simply can't be used. Did Nicholson absolutely have this in mind? Obviously, I can't say for sure, but the scenario sure seems as if it could fall into the category described by him.

And, no, I don't take Nicholson's description as including all mouldings. Many, maybe most, are worked at the edge of a piece of stuff, as everyone knows. And, obviously, the rabbets used in defining these mouldings can be wrought in a variety of ways, including the use of a plough plane, a moving fillister, or rabbet plane for part, or all, of the process. But, though I don't necessarily "advocate" the use of a snipe's bill plane in this situation, it can be useful, sometimes. I demonstrate one such scenario in the DVD.

In any event, if any of these mouldings at the edge of a piece of stuff has a quirk, then, of course, a snipe's bill is ideal for creating this. Possibly what Nicholson intended in the second part of the above sentence?

Which leads to the issue of "wear" on the snipe's bill plane. Yes, it does make sense to do as much of the work creating rabbets with planes whose irons have straight cutting edges as possible. Which is why, even in those situations where it makes sense to use a snipe's bill plane to start the process, one switches to a rabbet plane as soon as possible. This, too, I hope I adequately demonstrate in the DVD.

In line with this, where Sheraton describes using a snipe's bill plane, his wording includes ... " ... run on a side gage [essentially a very small batten] , and entering in by a snipe's-bill ... . ..." Again, though he doesn't make it explicit, I think the implication is that one switches to a rabbet plane as soon as the cut is adequately established.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR