Re: Use of Snipe Bill
Don McConnell
>Having already been cast the villain, I'm really disinclined to respond to your post, Adam, but I feel compelled to at least correct a few points of fact.
As to using "furniture planes" for an architectural moulding in my first DVD, that simply isn't true. (Though other than casting doubt on my credibility, I'm not sure exactly what you were driving at.) Yes, the Corinthian ogee from Chippendale is based on ancient architectural forms, but if you leaf through his _Director_ you'll see that he shows it a number of times in conjunction with specific pieces of furniture. The H&R pair I used to produce that moulding is at half pitch, appropriate for woods other than pine, and Cherry was a perfectly appropriate timber to use. Though Chippendale likely would have been using mahogany.
Secondly, you state that you've only ever seen cornice mouldings, such as the ones we had in our booth at WIA, in pine. Implying, I guess, that they are architectural mouldings and that to show them in Cherry is, somehow, inappropriate. One of the cornice mouldings is directly out of Sheraton, and he calls for it to be made of Mahogany. I'm assuming it would be intended for a piece of furniture, albeit a larger case piece. The second cornice was from a built in eighteenth-century cupboard of pine, and so was originally more of an architectural form. The third was from a nineteenth century "vernacular" cabinet, made of walnut. The perplexing thing is that we had a drawing or a photo, under each of the cornice mouldings, identifying its source/usage. So you could have discovered that for yourself if you had actually been interested enough to take a look. We used Cherry because that was what we had on hand, and chose three cornice mouldings with some similar features but very different overall appearance in order to illustrate some of the great variety of possibilities available if one has the right tools and knows how to use them. So, I fail to see how we were misrepresenting anything, which, I guess, is what you were attempting to imply?
Which leads directly to more subjective issues of interpretation. I guess we agree that drawings were often provided for laying out and executing architectural mouldings. Well, I don't know how representative it was, but Sheraton clearly implies that the same was true for cabinetmakers. At least in some instances. Dare I say, possibly in the better shops? This is in keeping with the fact that both Chippendale and Sheraton spend some time showing how the proportions of mouldings can be accurately laid out. Why bother if one was then simply going to wade in freehand? So I think a case can be made that some cabinet-makers in the eighteenth century worked from drawings and took some care in laying them out prior to putting tool to wood.
Obviously people are free to do as they please, but my feeling is that taking some time to design a moulding gives you a chance to assess whether the tools you have on hand will allow you to execute the design (and make adjustments if necessary), as well as plan out an orderly progression of steps which will allow you to work as directly and accurately as possible. In other words, I feel a little planning and layout is conducive to a satisfying and successful outcome. I find needless frustration and mediocre results to be off-putting.
As to the role of snipe's bill planes, I hope I made my case for them in the new DVD, so I'm not going to try to argue that in detail, here. What I present in the DVD is my best interpretation of Sheraton's intent in his section on Cornices, but, obviously, it will be up to others to decide if it makes sense to them. I may be lacking in imagination, but have not been able to come up with a satisfactory alternative explanation. In the meantime, what I do know is that this interpretation, in which snipe's bill planes play a pivotal role, allows one to design and execute complex, and sprung, mouldings in a very direct and satisfactory manner.
As Sheraton says, in introducing the topic of working cornices: " ... but from the bungling manner in which I have seen many workmen proceed to stick cornices, I am certain that a few hints will be of service, especially to the inexperienced. ... " All I can say is that my previous efforts at producing cornice mouldings now seem "bungling" by comparison, and I hope the information in the DVD will be helpful to other people. I know that Larry and I have remarked to each other that we wish we'd figured this out some thirty years ago.
As Sheraton's remark makes clear, not every cabinet-maker of his day used this approach. So, again, people are free to proceed in a manner which makes the most sense to them. And I do want to caution that success with this approach does largely depend on being able to sharpen and tune your tools to near optimum performance. Given that caveat, I am comfortable in stating that this approach will enable anyone, willing to give it an honest chance, to create any moulding they can envision and draw-out in a direct and predictable manner. In which case, it can also be fun and satisfying.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR