Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

Posts

OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#1

OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

cooper suter

>There's been a heavy flow of industrial auctions in the mid-west the last 6 months and I've been trying to hit my share.

Through a social contact, a reporter from the Detroit News asked to ride along and take a look.

I figured he'd go more for the big picture, but his style is little illustrative vignettes; I unwittingly became the everyman for his column.

This auction in Ypsi. was very good for me initially (anvil, many benches, a lot of shop fixtures, saws, etc.), and I was then able to go back and deal on leftover items (more benches and fixtures) after the auction pick-up (hence the "cockroaches/crumbsnatchers).

Coop

PS, Don't worry,contrary to the picture painted by the article my personal professional/financial picture is fine, & my "sabbatical" from carpentry is by choice.;)


Charlie LeDuff: Travels with Charlie

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#2

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Cooper,

Thank you very much for posting this story. This is a big story, not a small story, and I am wondering where it goes from here. Am very much interested in your observations, since you are attending many auctions.

Does it seem to you that a deindustrialization is going on? Or is the auctioned equipment going to be recycled into new industrial businesses? Are the auctions heavily attended, or is there not much interest? Whatever observations and opinions you have formed would be much appreciated.

Tell you one thing, though. And this is after reading your piece. I'm taking my stimulus money and it's going into a Baldor 7", 1800 rpm grinder. It was that or some Snap On or SK stuff, but I decided on the grinder.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#3

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper

Victor Parisian

>Thanks for posting this Cooper. This is a very sad story.

My family is from South Eastern Michigan. My great granddad Keller was a contemporary of R E Olds and the Dodge Bros. My Dad was born in Milan Mi and worked in those plants during WWII. (He later got smart and moved into sales.) My uncles built cars for Oldsmobile in Lansing. For a short while during college I tended a automatic screw machine in a machine shop in/near Okemos. My sister waited on customers in the A&P in Adrian and later was a head cashier for Farmer Jacks in Detroit.

I think the average American(and Canadian)worker automotive or other is going to give up a lot more before this economy gets better. It is beyond our control. The world economy dictates this. The worker who is going to get ahead needs to find some niche/specialty that other workers either can't do or won't do. A lot of this is education, some of it is dumb luck, but most is going to be by sheer determination. For most of us the idea of the 40 hour work week is over. To compete in the world economy we will have to work more like 50-60+ hours a week for less money and benefits and be damned happy we have a job at all. (And forget about retirement with a cottage on a lake somewhere.)

Victor - just some rambling thoughts from a Michigan (and Ohio) guy who has spent over half his life in Houston.

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#4

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper

Paul M. in San Diego

>Hi Cooper,

Thanks for posting this. It's very appropriate for both this forum and these times.

I never realized until reading this article how you are named after two great NHL names. Both Cooper and Suter. Any relation to the prolific Suter family? Do you have brothers named Koho, Bauer, and Christian? ;-)

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#5

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Wiley,

Hopefully, Cooper will chime in on this, too, but I thought I would offer my thoughts since I have bought some items through him at these auctions(and am storing lots of items from several recent auctions). When I graduated from high school in the mid- seventies in the Toledo area, you had to make a decision whether you wanted to continue on at school or get a job in industry, the monetary rewards from either were about the same. At that time within a 10-15 mile radius, there were a BP and Sunoco refinery, Jeep, Chrysler, Champion Spark plug and several other large auto parts suppliers, 3 large glass factories and Toledo Edison that offered well paid, hourly positions. Today all that is left is the refineries, Jeep and Edison, and those have all cut back on the number of employees. There has been a exodus of recent college graduates from Ohio and Michigan because there are no jobs when they graduate from school. The general morale of people in this area is pretty poor right now.

I have attended a few industrial and business auctions over the years, but have attended an equal number since the beginning of 2009. So the number is up and the shear size of the factories that have closed and are having their equipment auctioned is amazing. The two places that Cooper sighted, the Ford plants in Ypsi and Monroe both probably employed 2500 people or so in their heyday. Some of the people previewing and buying at these auctions seem to be looking for specific pieces of equipment to use, but I would say the majority are brokers trying to buy cheap and resell for profit or scrappers buying to dismantle and sell for scrap prices.

It is good to hear that you are going to purchase a Baldor grinder to do your part to stimulate the economy, they are a great grinder. I'd hate to say how many of them were for sale at the two Ford auctions and how cheap they went.

Hopefully, this will all soon be straightend out and we can all move forward back into properous times.

Jim

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#6

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper

cooper suter

>Wiley,

Yes, it is a big story, and one that has been going on in the midwest for my entire adult life (I graduated HS in '82 right into the previous worst recession since the depression);I can't do it justice myself.

For what it's worth, and in no particular order, off the cuff things that strike me about these plant auctions/closings:

-The basic circus of these auctions; the scale of liquidation, the personalities, the marathon duration, the money spent/made, the path these objects will travel from the top of the American industrial economy (as it used to exist) to wherever (reuse in US industry? scrap? China? a hobbyists workshop? someones loft in Soho?), the deals/money made, etc.

-The finality of these closings; these plants, the sites, the jobs, the paychecks, the industry aren't coming back. Will the US ever be a preeminent manufacturer again? Will the skilled trades that were in these plants/industries ever come back? What if we need them?

- The history in these sites; 80 years of industry, from Henry Ford and farm land to abandoned brown field with "the best American years" in between.

-The personal stories; people who gave 30-40 years to a company/industry and are watching it piss away. People who are my age (44) and have no idea what they are going to do, how they are going to live on $12 an hour w/out benefits when they're used to $29 w/beni's. The people who never had and now won't have access to these type of jobs.

From my small view of things, I'd definetly say industries are going for good, at least on the scale we've based our economy on for the last century; the thing that harder to see, but even more insidious is that for every medium/big plant that goes theres literally hundreds of small shops and suppliers that are going.

The auctions are attended, but not overwhelmingly (fifty to a couple hundred people present in person, I can't say how many online bidders).

The bulk of buyers I talked w/are resellers (some very large volume), small shop owners (w/a couple dozen employees at most), there's a smattering of individuals buying for personal use.

I haven't seen a heavy corporate or foriegn presence buying at these auctions.

The biggest machinery is not always going at the auction, or it has a shill bidding to keep it if it doesn't reach minimum; but at every auction theres been big stuff going for penny's on the dollar.

The real deals I see are buying hundred grand or five hundred grand machines for couple of grand, but you need to be able to move it and either use or resell it.

There's more, but I gotta hit the hay.

Coop

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper *LINK*

#7

Re: OT-Went to an auction, ended-up in the paper

cooper suter

>I gather being names Suter in Switzerland is like being named Smith here.

The Suter's are of that old pissy Swiss/German stock and from what I know the local Suter family kind of gave-up on each other sometime in the 60's, so I don't really know that many of my Suter relatives.

I once asked my uncle about it, and he said that whenever the Suter's got together they ended-up bickering over something. I asked him what was the favorite topic of dispute: money? religion? politics? He said it didn't really matter, they just liked to argue.

Coop