Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

A mighty nice broadax

Posts

A mighty nice broadax

#1

A mighty nice broadax

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I was visiting an old friend the other day and spotted this ax hanging on the wall of his shop. It's a Rohrbach right-handed broadax, made around 1810 in southern Lehigh County, Pennsylvania. Rohrbach was an edge tool maker known for his axes and slicks and mortising chisels. This particular ax is in particularly good condition, as most other existing examples are badly rusted. The late Bill Phillips was known to have lusted for this piece. Can't win 'em all.

Ellis






Re: A mighty nice broadax

#2

Yes indeed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>that is a nice looking, and nicely preserved, tool.

How is the handle held on? It looks like the socket tapers - is it a press fit, like a socket chisel? Seems it would fall off in use, endangering toes.

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#3

Re: A mighty nice broadax

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Interesting choice to use screws instead of forge welding to mate the steels. Do you know whether or how much this axe was used? How are the screws holding up?

Pam

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#4

Re: screws or "decorations"?

Dave Mount

>I thought the same thing at first, then noticed that on the view of the other side there's no seam evident, suggesting a weld as one would expect. I'm thinking those aren't actually screw heads but something else, a makers mark or something.

Hopefully Ellis will resolve the mystery.

Dave

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#5

Not screws

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Those are makers marks of some sort, stamped into the steel. We couldn't quite make out what they were supposed to represent, but here's a closer view in case that helps.

Ellis


img

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#6

Re: Not screws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Oh, my bad, didn't see the original two additional photos.

Thanks, guys,

Pam

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#7

Re: A mighty nice broadax

Alan DuBoff

>Wow, that's a beauty!

Coincidentally, I'm flying into So. PA tomorrow morning to meet with a log craftsman in No. WV. We just might be hewing some logs ourselves.:-)

B. Allen Mackie, who many consider the grandfather of log home revival in North America, has dimensions in his legendary book, "Building with Logs", for forging a broad axe, since it is very hard to find them anymore.

Hard to tell from your photo Ellis, but the handle should be offset to the bevel side to allow one to stand on the side of the timber being hewed to provide clearance. Hard to tell if that is the case in your photos. In this regard, there are left and right handed broad axes. Somehow that looks like it could be left handed if the handle/helve is offset on that side. Do you know if it is left or right handed?

Nowadays many craftsmen will mill the sides of the timber, and use an adz, and it achieves a nice result, just that the broad axe was how it was done traditionally.

Some of the oldest structures still standing were hand hewn with a broad axe and notched together with either dovetail, v-notch, lap or diamond notches.

Beautiful tool your friend has there.

It was said in days of lore that all you needed was a broad axe, a mule, and 5 acres of wooded land to build a life for yourself in America! Mackie proved that is still the case! The craftsman I'm meeting with was lucky enough to learn from Mackie back in the 70s. Mackie did consider the hewn structures to be some of the most sound, and solid structures ever built.

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#8

Apologies to B. Allan Mackie for typo, R.I.P.!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#9

Nice Beard

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#10

Is a Goose Wing Axe

Todd Hughes

>This type is called a goose wing because of it supposedly looking like a gooses wing. Is more of an Europeon design though was made here to mostly probably by europeon immigrants and 'smiths influrenced by them. Was made much later and in much larger numbers in Europe

If not signed a few ways to tell an American one is that they have the socket the handle goes in bent outward, europeon ones have straight sockets and bent handles.

Also europeon ones often are more ornate with fancy treatment to back of blade and more punched decorations.

American ones often were made out of bad iron that had flaws in it while Europeon ones made out of higher quality iron and steel.

Big difference in prices between an American axe and a Europeon one as more people want the American ones. Funny but they were probably more popular...and expensive..with collectors 20 years ago then today. A 200 year old (maybe) Europeon one will sell for less then an in the box Stanley number 3 from 1930.

I don't think they were used so much to hew logs for buildings but probably more for smaller work and even furniture. More like you would use a hewing hatchet for today then a hewing axe.

I used to make small goose wing axes sort of like these but with blades only about 4 inchs long. Made them like the originals out of iron with a steel cutting edge..Not easy to make but kind of fun I guess.

I got a few of these old Goose wings including a very rare Baltimore made one, maybe when I get home I will post a photo of them....Todd

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#11

Seems it was used for hewing...

Alan DuBoff

>Todd,

Definitely a goosewing axe as you point bout, but most of the reference I can find on the web do say that it is used for hewing.

Pretty in depth study at the following link:

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3983/is_200112/ai_n9013872/

Here's another online link that also mentioned it is for hewing:

http://books.google.com/books?id=x5ZiYCZRdHwC&pg=PA28&lpg=PA28&dq=goosewing+axe+function&source=bl&ots=1B7CetekqK&sig=WRl1oAragftrWA1oN1MzG2xVHOA&hl=en&ei=defbSciLDJrMMKrZlNUN&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1

Very cool looking axe, IMO. It is a tad different than the design that Mackie shows which has a ridge perpendicular to the cutting edge. Do you know, is that ridge there to make the broad axe head more durable? Have you seen the style that has a ridge on the bevel side?

Mackie shows it as having soft iron from the eye to about half the blade (where the ridge extends to), and steel on the edge, so it is clearly laminated in his example.

However, Mackie also shows it as being a straight edge, and not curved.

I take your word on the steel, as many of the American broad axes I've seen are fairly pitted and do look like pretty crappy steel, which is why I haven't bought any. Still would like to have one though. :-) (I do have a hatchet with a chisel edge)

Although not clear, it would seem the offset handle, along with the chisel edge would distinguish it for hewing, maybe not.

Whether for hewing or not, definitely a cool looking axe.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#12

It's a rightie

Ellis Walentine, Host

>... and the handle is indeed offset for clearance. You can see it best in the top photo.

Ellis

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#13

Photo of a few

Todd Hughes

>I have a few more of these things out in the barn but here are the 3 I keep out by my fireplace and were handy to get together for a photo. You can see the difference between a right and left handled one. The two in the front are American, the other one hard to tell, some of it looks American but to me has a German looking stamp.Socket comes out at a slight angle. Maybe made by an German immigrant?...who knows?

maybe I should go make a little one?....not today....Todd


img

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#14

Very nice, they are...

Alan DuBoff

>Todd,

those are nice. The handle is a tad different, but I see what your talking about with the eye, and how it is angled.

Online it did point to mostly German immigrants that would have made them in America, most likely. Useful tools in the old days, no doubt, could build a life for one's self by having one. I would imagine they were highly sought ofter.

Thanks for posting pics, would love to see one of you make another.

Regards,

Alan

Re: A mighty nice broadax

#15

Mackie does in fact live on...

Alan DuBoff

>Ellis,

Sorry to be slow to respond, was jetting out to the airport last week and didn't have time to reply.

A rightie would be my preferred since I am right handed. If your friend wants to sell it, let me know! :-)

I found out while back in West Virginia that Mackie is still in fact living, contrary to what I was told a few years ago. Not only that, but his last home he built was done when he was 78 years old. That in itself is inspiring!

Hewn timbers are known to last for a long time. A single broad axe was a most valuable tool in days of lore. Still could be today with the right skills to know how to use it. :-)

Regards,

Alan