Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Question about backsaw backs?

Posts

Question about backsaw backs?

#1

Question about backsaw backs?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Does anyone have personal knowledge or perhaps links to written information as to how the steel backs were bent for backsaws? I'm especially interested in the longer lengths, such as those made for a 30" miter saw, for example.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#2

Darn good question !

steve mackay

>

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#3

Re: Question about backsaw backs? *LINK*

L. Hanson

>Can't say for sure about historically what was done - and I don't have any written information. But I'm quite sure today's sawmakers roll the steel into the shape for the backs and then simply cut them for length and insert the blade.

This video from "How It's Made" might interest you. It shows everything else about making a saw - even shows backsaws - but not how they bend the steel for them.

Leif

Norse Woodsmith.com


Youtube video

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#4

Re: Brake?

ThomD

>Some kind of metal brake would seem like the tool. This is a tool that holds a piece firmly while it folds like a door, causing the sheet to bend crisply. A version can be made by holding a sheet in a vise, then taking a second tool a bit like the handle on a drywall knife, a slot on a handle and carefully tweaking it along. The second tool has to get right in to the fold area and be sharp enough that it can still be bent. Getting the initial bend in is a big part of the problem, once a fold line is extablished rollers, etc... can bear it home.

Don't know how they actually did it, but I would love to hear about such methods, because breaking metal is very useful.

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#5

Re: Brake?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I think Thom has it right both brass and iron backs were easily bent on a brake. However after having looked at a number of backed saws, it looks like the metal is creased before it is put in the brake.

I think this was done to allow for the thickness of the blade.

Stephen

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#6

Re: Brake?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I'm familiar with brakes. The brakes I'm familar with will not make a closed bend such as a saw back. They will bend a little beyond 90 degrees but not all the way flat. There would have to be some kind of secondary bending operation to bend the two sides together. The thickness of most older saw backs is close to 1/8", maybe 10 ga. To bend that thickness 30" long takes a pretty hefty brake. These kind of brakes are called "box and pan brakes". I think saw makers like Disston might have used a type of brake that formed the metal into a V shaped die, but would still require a secondary step to bend the two sides almost flat together.

I suppose a strip of metal could be forced through a series of dies slowly forming little at a time until the two sides are formed flat together. This might be what Leif is referring to.

It would be most interesting to know how Disston and other saw makers actually did it.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#7

I've never done it with metal that thick

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but we regularly flattened up to 16 gauge (roughly 1/16") sheet metal on a brake, in a two-step operation: 1. Fold the metal up to as acute an angle past 90 degrees as the brake would achieve, 2. Tuck the folded edge into the brake and flatten with the clamp bar.

Granted: a) this was relatively narrow hemming edges on, say, flashing, b) we weren't going for precision of the grade you would need for a backsaw back, and c) this approach tends to create a kind of tear-drop shaped gap in the hemmed edge, rather than parallel sides.

It seems to me it must have been done hot - I don't know how you could get a fold like that in cold metal without a lot of distortion. But I'm not a machinist, and am sitting here speculating wildly.

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#8

Re: I've never done it with metal that thick

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Bill,

Most backs are teardrop shape that have been bent. The hardness of the metal will determine how mallable it is.

I have bent 16 ga. on a box and pan brake many times. I'm thinking that when the saw makers did their heavier gauge backs the secondary bending was done on a press of some kind. I don't think it would have to be done hot. That would add a lot of production cost, both in the heating and the cleaning afterward. Their steel backs were either polished or blued.

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#9

I've done 14 ga. in a bench vise *LINK*

Bob Rozaieski

>Granted I started with 14 ga. angle since I had no means of making the initial bend but the vise was capable of closing the 90 degree angle to the teardrop shape of a saw back. Doing so slowly and gradually along the length of the piece of steel kept it from deforming so it stayed straight. I did them cold. Took only a few minutes per back. I've done 4 backs this way so far without any problems. The first two I did were small backs for dovetail saws made from 14 ga. 3/4" x 3/4" angle. The two saws I'm working on now are 16" and 19" tenon saws with larger backs made from 14 ga. 1" x 1" angle. I got the angle steel from Lowes.

I'm thinking that the initial bend could be made with a vise like press and two piece die of sorts where there is a "V" shaped female die half and a male die half that would press the steel into the female half to form the initial bend. LV sells a small one for light gauge metal but a heavier one would be possible. Honestly I think the initial bend was likely harder to do and get correct as any misalignment of the initial bend would be impossible to correct when closing the back. In my experience, the second bend is the easy part if you start with a good even initial bend.


img

Steel Saw Backs I've Bent

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#10

Question for Marv

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Marv,

Are the backs made of steel or iron?

Stephen

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#11

Re: I've done 14 ga. in a bench vise

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Bob,

Your method of bending is pretty much what I was referring to, but using the dies on a huge power break and bending the entire length of the back in one downward stroke. Then with a power press, mash the two sides together.

What I'd really like to find is an article about how Disston and other saw makers did it. Maybe pictures of the machines they used. They had to have come up with a fast way to do it due to the fierce competition and having to keep their manufacturing costs down.

Your method of inching along a little at a time to bend a back is very ingenious. I wouldn't have thought it could be done and end up with a back straight enough. Sure hard on the vise screw though. Doing it your way is ok if you are only making a few backs, but if one wanted to do it on a production basis, it would be too time comsuming.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#12

Re: Question for Marv

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Stephen,

The backs on all the backsaws I've worked on, other than brass, are made of a type of steel that is quite soft.

Not being a metalurgist, I have no idea what the composition is of either iron or steel. I've heard that high carbon steel is more malleble.

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#13

High carbon more malleable???

John in NM

>That is surprising. I would expect iron (NOT cast iron) to be more malleable than steel, with tool steels being even less malleable than mild, and cast irons being even less malleable than high carbon (tool) steels. But that expectation is just following a general rule that may have exceptions.

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#14

I got it backwards...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>John,

I got it backwards....it's "low" carbon steel that is easier formed.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#15

Ahhh, that makes more sense, thx!

John in NM

>

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#16

Roll Forming Machines

L. Hanson

>If you've ever seen a roll-forming machine in action, the concept is quite simple - it's just a series of rollers that in series bend a piece of steel to the desired shape (and pretty much any desired shape is possible) - an example you might see of such a forming machine you see used at construction sites for seamless siding or seamless gutter - or for making standing seam roofing products.

They are a staple in manufacturing today, and have been for at least most of the last century if not longer.

Older manufacturers - before the industrial revolution, would surely have used a custom made brake (or a couple of specialized metal brakes) I think.


img

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#17

Re: Roll Forming Machines and Press Brakes.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Leif,

I had some seamless rain gutter made a few years ago by a guy who showed up with the machine on a trailer. I think the progressive forming method is used mainly for thinner metal than a backsaw back.

I've been doing some googl'n on the subject and find that a hydralic or neumatic Press Brake is the way to go. There's some videos on YouTube that demonstrate how they do it. They use a V die at the bottom with a male die above. It looks effortless. The same Press Brake could be used for mashing the two sides flat together. Some of the Press Brakes are as big as a house and no doubt cost as much.

Wonder if Grizzly has one that will last for more than a week before malfunctioning.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#18

Re: Roll Forming Machines and Press Brakes.

L. Hanson

>A press brake (or pair of them) would be an excellent option...

On the roll-forming - they can bend up to 1/4" thick steel with them... and they too, likely cost as much as a house.

Leif

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#19

Re: Press Brakes.

MikeW

>We use a 12' 100-ton press brake, acute die on the bottom and knife die on the top. This bends the pieces to about 135 degrees. Then flattening dies are used. CNC controlled. Nice press brake. Isn't mine.

The press, which has a digital readout for pressure being exerted, shows an average of 18- to 20-tons during the acute 'V' bend for a 20" x 1/8" x 2 1/8" piece of 260 brass. Less on the flattening.

Flex on the press brake is the killer. A 4' 25-ton press brake isn't stout enough without flexing. It takes a good-sized press. Yeah, yeah. I too have used lesser presses--including a 20-ton H-frame. And a 50-ton H-frame. There is no comparison to a "real" press brake in efficiency and quality of bend. Only doing a few at a time, one can get away with a lighter press. Our last batch was (2) 3' x 8' sheets whacked up on the shear and folded. A little over three hundred backs in an hour and a half. And we gab a bit while doing it.

Brass takes more umph than steel.

Mike

Re: Question about backsaw backs?

#20

I did a spark test

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>on an old Disston Backsaw, the blade sparked like steel and the back sparked like wrought iron.

Stephen