Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

Posts

Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#1

Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

Stuart Hough

>Is there any reason that anyone knows of why most workbenches are 24" deep, historical or practical? I'm set to start on the top and have been planning on a 26-28" depth, but after reviwing the plans for the Holtzapffel, and others, most are built to a 24" standard. Since this is my first (and maybe last) workbench, I was wondering what the rational was for that size. I appreciate any and all advice...no matter what LOML says (wink..wink)!

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#2

How long are your arms?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Unless you work on both sides of the bench, the back of the bench ought to be no further than you can comfortably reach. 24" worked for most folks, I suspect, so it became one of the standards (though some of the Continental European benches are 18", which seems very narrow to me - although if most of your work involves planing the length of, say, architectural trim, it would be fine).

If you've got long arms, a few more inches should be fine.

Digressing...the trick, I've found, though, is keeping the back of the bench from becoming a clutter closet. I SO often find myself working on the front 12" of my 24" bench because the back 12" have things I haven't yet figured out where to put.

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#3

Coupla considerations

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Stuart,

Congratulations on getting started!

Are you going to use the benchtop for glueups? Or will you have a separate assembly/gluing table? If the bench will be doubling as a glueup surface, then think about the width of things you might be gluing. For example, if you want to glue up a 24" wide panel, it is nice to be able to lay out 4 to 6 Bessey (or Jorgenson or Gros Stabil) clamps in a row, to form a bed for the gluing. But if the panel is to be 24" wide, then you'd be unhappy that the bench is not, say, 26" wide, so the feet on your clamps could sit on the bench. So think about your needs. Here's one metric: a 31" Bessey clamp, fully opened with 25-3/4" clamping capacity, can sit down on a 28" wide bench. None of this is a consideration if you're not clamping on the bench, but if you are give it some thought.

Another thing....different trades use different benches. A cabinetmakers bench is pretty narrow, for the reason Bill says. But what if you're sometimes a joiner and want to make an interior or even exterior door on your bench--24" would not be enough.

Wiley

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#4

Re: When I bult mine...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>it was 32" deep, and 6' long. Mine wasn't a treasure bench, or fancy in construction values - tubafors, and cabinet plywood from the Southeast Asian area.

I work across the end of it now, because of the crowded conditions (and a misplaced vice, another story). If, when, I build a trophy bench, it will be narrower, longer, and in fancier materials. And it will have vices where they belong.

And this one will be for gluing things together.

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#5

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

ThomD

>One thing to consider is how wide a table top you think you can keep flat for the duration. The basic euro style that consists of a beam that is fairly deep and a tool well is easier to keep flat than a really wide, and normally thinner version like a Kirby. Also it is easier to keep a workpiece level on a bench that isn't too wide, because some of the irregularities of the part may just run wild. If you want a wide and permanently flat bench, that can certainly be done, but it may prove a little harder to engineer, and if I was doing it I would use lamination and composite technology. In fact I am currently working on a bench that can be left out of doors on a permanent basis without any cover over it. That requires composite technology, or it could be a simple beam. There is an out of door beam type bench in one of the Woodwright books.

I agree with all the stuff about reach and so forth. This also varies as to whether you can access both sides of the bench, have multiple workers etc...

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#6

mine is 43"

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The width was determined by the lumber that went into it (12/4 poplar). I assemble on it and the width is advantageous when gluing up stuff.

The bigger it is the more stuff you can "store" on it that will be in the way of what ever you need to do.

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#7

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

Christopher Schwarz

>Stuart,

Late to the party (as usual).

There isn't much to add here, except for the fact that assembly of wide panels (for me) occurs on the ultimate workbench. The floor.

For me, the bigger consideration is *working* those panels. Making them flat etc. And for that, a 24"-wide bench is great for traversing with a jack/fore plane. Wider benches (which I have worked on) are counter-productive in this department.

Chris

Re: Workbench advice needed. Chris Schwarz?

#8

Arms 26", bench to be 24". Thanx for the advice!

Stuart Hough

>