Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Making big mortises for my workbench

Posts

Making big mortises for my workbench

#1

Making big mortises for my workbench

wilbur

>To paraphrase the Thing, it's mortising time!

So my modifications to Chris Schwarz's Roubo bench plans included making a bunch of 1" wide mortises for the stretchers, and to set the legs into the top. That's why I asked a few days ago about how you all make mortises. I really appreciated the all the input and suggestions, and after trying a few different methods, I thought I'd show how I wound up making these things.

The mortises for the leg stretchers are going to be 1" wide by 3-1/4" long by 2-1/8" deep. To make a mortise 1" wide, you need a 1" mortise chisel. Here it is, next to my normal sized 1/4" mortise chisel.


Now that's a mortise chisel! :@)

By the way, if at this point anyone thinks I'm nuts for trying this, it's all Wiley's fault. :@) I'm sure that he doesn't remember, but a while back we had exchanged some emails about making big mortises, and one of my plans was to drill and pare these 1" mortises, and then had this crazy idea about getting a big honking mortise chisel instead. He said, and I quote, "I'm not the best one to ask, because I tend to aid and abet these big dreams." He also suggested that it would be fun to document the process. As it turns out, getting a big chisel was the thing to do. So thanks, Wiley! And this write up is for you.

Now, I've been chopping 1/4" mortises by hand without much problem, and I thought it was pretty quick work. To my surprise, after making some practice runs, it seemed that my 1" mortise chisel was cutting much more slowly. I couldn't figure out why that would be so -- after all, bigger is better, right? It took me a while, but I finally realized that since this chisel is 4 times as wide, the force from the hammer is going to be spread out over a wider area, leading to less penetration. Here's a little experiment I did to prove this to myself. I took a piece of wood, and made a mortise chop with each chisel, with the same number of hammer blows. Then I sawed the cuts in half to get a look at the cross section. You can clearly see that the wide chisel won't penetrate to the same depth as the narrower chisel.


So now I had some perspective on how my big mortise chisel was going to perform, and learned to have some patience. Here's the layout.


And here's my secret weapon for making mortises.


This is a pair of low horses. By putting the workpiece on these, I can sit and chop the mortises. Since I'm sitting on the workpiece, I can straddle it, which means that I don't have to twist my body and strain my lower back leaning over a workbench, and making sure that the chisel is straight is easy. Also, sitting on the workpiece makes the ergonomics of pounding with a hammer much better.

The first thing I do is drill a hole towards one end of the mortise. The line in the middle of the mortise is centered, to help me with locating the drill bit. I made a mark on the drill bit so that I knew when I had drilled a hole 2-1/8" deep or so.


Then I start chopping. As I mentioned above, sitting on the workpiece with the mortise between my legs makes holding the chisel straight very easy.


The hole I drilled gives the chopped waste a place to go. The first few chops are mainly to get the walls of the mortise straight. Here's what it looks like after the first few chops.


Note the fancy mortising hammer! ;)

The bevel of the chisel is facing the drill hole. I tend to do 8-10 hammer blows, and then wiggle the mortise chisel to break the chips free, then hit the chisel again 8-10 times. I'm not really pounding away with the hammer. My guess is that I'm hitting the chisel with about 75% of the force that I would use if I was hammering a nail. You don't need the hammer blow to be forceful -- if there is an issue with penetration, sharpening the chisel is better. What you want is the hammer blow to be controlled, because at this point it's more important to make sure that the walls of the mortise are straight.

At some point it will get difficult, since even though I have a drill hole that the waste can go into, it's not completely the width of the chisel, so then I stop. As I work back along the mortise, I start the next set of chops about 1/8" back.


And this is where I'm at after 4 minutes of chopping. It may not be completely clear from the photo, but I'm already 1" down.


Now, I'll go back over the section I've worked on, and chop down until I'm at the depth that I want. This takes about 4 minutes as well.


At this point, I have a decently sized section of mortise cut down to full depth. This makes chopping the rest of the mortise really easy. I move back about 1/8" at a time. Again, I do 8-10 hammer blows, then wiggle the chisel to break the chips, chopping all the way down. I used a Sharpie to mark on the side of the chisel so that I know when I've hit bottom. Here you can really whale away on the hammering, since the walls of the mortise are already established. I keep going until I hit the end of the mortise. This takes me about 5 minutes.


Then it's just a matter of cleaning up the other end. Here I'll reverse the chisel so that the bevel is facing me. A little more work, and I'm done.


Total time, about 15 minutes. Not bad, I'd say. My first mortise took me about half an hour. I'm definitely getting faster with practice.

Now, I'm sure that using a mortising machine would be faster, but there isn't a 1" wide mortising bit that I know of. So with a mortising machine I'd have to make one run along one side of the mortise, and another along the other side, and then waste out the middle. Over the several mortises that I need to make for this workbench, I'm sure some amount of error will creep up. This way I know all my mortises are the same width as my chisel. In addition, I have to make mortises in the underside of my workbench top, and there's no way I'm getting the benchtop in a mortising machine.

One thing is for sure -- next time I make some more normal sized 1/4" wide mortises, it's going to go a lot faster.

Hope that was entertaining, and thanks again, Wiley! :@)

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#2

Re: Nice work, there!

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I have one of those mortising hammers, too. But it doesn't get much use any more, really. When I got a lathe a while back, I turned a substantial chisel whacking club from some tanoak that was hanging around the shop. Much classier - almost Japanese in it's approach ;-)

Thanks for the pictures!

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#3

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Brilliant!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#4

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Wilbur,

That is a beautiful workmanlike mortise. I remember very well your decision to order that mondo mortise chisel, and am chuffed to bits (quoting ALF now) to be mentioned in association with such a glorious undertaking!

Steel hammers go well with Japanese mortise chisels IMO. I've grown to like them heavy with a short handle. Heavy enough to where there is no rebound.

That's a heck of a nice brace too, to round out a great show and tell.

Please keep the pictures coming--can't wait to see the benchtop work proceed!

Thanks a lot,

Wiley

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#5

Thanks for the demo, Wilbur

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Very nice pictures, very clean work.

You mention, "Now, I've been chopping 1/4" mortises by hand without much problem, and I thought it was pretty quick work. To my surprise, after making some practice runs, it seemed that my 1" mortise chisel was cutting much more slowly. I couldn't figure out why that would be so -- after all, bigger is better, right? It took me a while, but I finally realized that since this chisel is 4 times as wide, the force from the hammer is going to be spread out over a wider area, leading to less penetration."

I recall some professional here or elsewhere (Adam Cherubini?) mentioning that he rarely uses chisels much larger than 1/2". Certainly, I expect my 3/4" and 1" chisels to last my lifetime and more.

I do have a 2" paring chisel that's great for cross-grain planing (such as you might find in paring mortise sidewalls, just for instance), but, were it thicker, I'd sure never want to use it for hogging out!

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#6

you know you are making big mortises when....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>you can sit on the piece being mortised! Are you glad its pine and not white oak?

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#7

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Great job, Wilbur, now you know why the largest official mortise chisel is about 3/4". You're definitely into chutaki/atsu nomi range.

I'm also a fan of 2/3 lb mallets/hammers (the daruma model) that I picked up making dai. Another style that might work well is the Vietnamese wooden mallet made of some dense, heavy wood. Tools for Woodworking has a museum site showing this stuff.

And I wonder if a huge bachi nomi shape (thinner at shank, sloping to wide edge) would work to force the power into the edge better than a straight sided chutaki?

I see this workbench as a cross between timber framing and furniture. Suppose you went a tad into furniture territory and made double M&T's rather than single?

Just some random thoughts, not intended to criticize anything you've done.

Pam


img

Viet Nam tool set

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#8

Should be "2 to 3 lb hammer," not "2/3"

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#9

Thanx, Wilbur! Now I need a new tool

Stuart Hough

>for when I get to that part on my workbench. Thanx for posting the progress. It has both been a tutorial and an inspiration to shake off the jitters of beginning such an undertaking and getting serious about the craft.

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#10

Well done Wilbur!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>This is a well written and documented article! This and all your bench "notes" should be one BIG Shop Shot!!

Keep us updated on your progress.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#11

Re: Thanks for the demo, Wilbur

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

Believe it or not, these mortises are actually scaled down from the original plans. In Chris Schwarz's Roubo article, the mortise and tenon joints for the leg stretchers are 1-1/4", which is 25% bigger than mine.

I've seen the advice not to go much above 1/2" or 3/4" for mortises. But as Pam mentioned, this style workbench really blurs the line between furniture construction and timber framing.

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#12

Re: you know you are making big mortises when....

wilbur

>Now I'm tempted. I have a scrap piece of 8/4 white oak. I might give it a try when I have some free time. :@)

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#13

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

I think my 1" mortise chisel is a real mortise chisel (mukomachi nomi). It has straight sides, tapered a hair inward, so like an almost square trapezoid, and the sides themselves are slightly concave. These are all characteristics of Japanese mortise chisels.

My understanding is that the timber chisel (atsu nomi) and chu tataki nomi (no translation that I know of) differs from the basic bench chisel (oire nomi) only in size, and that these two chisels have the same overall shape as the Japanese bench chisel.

From what I remember from physics, I don't think that the fishtail chisel would transmit any more or less pressure than a mortise chisel with the same width at the cutting edge. I think that the only determining factor here is the width of the cutting edge. Assuming there's no loss of energy transfer, the body of the chisel could be any shape, but the force deliverd at the edge would be the same.

As I mentioned before, these mortises are actually scaled down a bit to fit my mortise chisel. The plans I'm working off of call for 2-1/2" M/T joints to hold the legs into the top. I'm going to make these into double M/T joints, using my 1" mortise chisel.

By the way, Hida Tool lists a 30 mm (!) mortise chisel.

I am thinking of getting a heavier hammer. I guess one good thing is that today I was making a quick and dirty compost bin for the backyard out of 2x4's and 3/4" pine, and hammering nails into those boards was like cutting into Jello in comparison to this run of mortise chopping. :@)

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#14

Re: you know you are making big mortises when....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I used to know a guy who sat on every piece he mortised. If he had something like a 1X3 on edge, he had a thick little rug he put over the stile so it would be more comfortable. I have also seen pictures of old guys sitting on the bench next to the piece being mortised and I have done this sometimes myself.

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#15

Re: Well done Wilbur!

wilbur

>Hi Dominic,

The thought that this could be a Shop Shot is one of the nicest things I've ever heard. Thanks!

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#16

Nice chisel Wilbur!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I have a few myself. Nice demo on cutting those big morti as well. Next thing you'll be building a mortising bench or stool.

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#17

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

ThomD

>Judging by the picture that comes after the ruler picture the cutting action is not what it might be. I would try the 180s method by which the Japanese typically seem to work based on the pictures I have seen, you get big orderly chips.

I have a Tasai 1" mortising chisel that is pretty conventional, no shoulders, so I know they make them up to that size. It isn't much trouble getting a hollow chisel in that size. I have a machine that wields them, though I haven't bothered with sizes larger that 1/2". The outlining method is pretty quick, for through mortices, where the center doesn't need to be cut. Hollow chisel mortising is so much quieter, not something one can normally say about a machine! Of course if you want to cut big mortises with a lot of noise, there is always the chain mortiser. They seem pretty practical, more a timber framing device.

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

#18

Re: Making big mortises for my workbench

wilbur

>Hi Thom,

"Judging by the picture that comes after the ruler picture the cutting action is not what it might be. I would try the 180s method by which the Japanese typically seem to work based on the pictures I have seen, you get big orderly chips."

Can you clarify? What is it about the cutting action that are you concerned about? And what do you mean by "orderly chips"?