Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Question about English stanley 4 1/2

Posts

Question about English stanley 4 1/2

#1

Question about English stanley 4 1/2

Stuart Hough

>I won a Stanley 4 1/2 smoother on the 'bay last week. When it arrived I found out it was an English-made model. Are these anywhere near as good as the originals? Did I waste my money? It looks to be in great shape, with no damage to the mouth, and the sides and sole smooth and square to each other. Never had an Englisher before, so I'm not sure if you look for the same issues as with the U.S. models. Any advice is appreceated.

Re: Question about English stanley 4 1/2

#2

Age, not country

paul womack

>The English Stanleys are (in general) rather recent, and we all know what the passage of time, and the rise of the accountants, did to tool quality.

(Until recently, I'm happy to say).

BugBear

Re: Question about English stanley 4 1/2

#3

Decent enough plane

David Miller from Iowa

>The English Stanley planes have a lighter casting, but properly tuned with good technique it should be a serviceable plane for light to medium duty work on cooperative wood

Re: Question about English stanley 4 1/2

#4

Re: Decent enough plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi David

It's the other way around - the English castings are heavier, at least the #4 1/2 I had certainly was.

It tuned up really well. Again if mine was a typical example, the mouth was a touch wider and I was able to fit a Clifton blade and stayset cap iron. That is a thick and heavy combination.

Seduced by a USA Type 11, I sold it (minus the Clifton upgrade). The Type 11 was (is - I still have it) definitely lighter. I have only just managed to fit the Clifton blade but cannot add the stayset cap iron as the combination is too thick for the screw.

It is difficult to compare the finishes of the two planes - the Type 11 is about 40 years older than the UK plane. The UK plane was NOS while the USA plane needed cleaning up. I am very happy with the USA plane and I have no doubt that you will be the same with the UK plane.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question about English stanley 4 1/2

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Same opinion

Jim in Burlington On

>English stanley's aren't collected like older american ones are. The couple english stanley's that I own are in fantastic shape. If anything they do weigh slightly more.

Re: Question about English stanley 4 1/2

#6

Thanx, I feel better now!

Stuart Hough

>