Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

Posts

Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#1

Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

wilbur

>I've been on a run of chopping some large (for me) mortises. These are about 1" wide, 3 1/2" long, and 2 1/8" deep, and I'm using a 1" mortise chisel to make them.

There seems to be two methods of mortise chopping. Many sources I've seen seem to advocate chopping out a V in the middle, and working out towards the ends. The bevel of the mortise chisel faces the ends. When the V is cut to depth, the chisel is reversed so that the flat side faces the ends, and the rest of the mortise is chopped that way.

One disadvantage I've found is that my mortise chisel seems to be a little asymmetric, so that when I reverse the chisel when going from one side of the V to the other, there will be a little unevenness in the wall of the mortise. I know that I can pare the sides of the mortise, but I always thought that it was best to avoid paring the sidewalls of the mortise whenever possible.

On the other hand, other sources, including Frank Klausz, suggest chopping a mortise starting at one end, and working across the length of the mortise. I actually find this to be easier in terms of keeping the walls of the mortise straight.

What do you all do?

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#2

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

ThomD

>Well two things seem obvious:

- If you find one method better than another already...

- Probably should fix up your chisel before relying on impressions based on it asymmetry.

I learned mortising when I was all Japanese in style and tools, to the extent I could find out what that was all about. They seem to start in the middle. For the aspect ratio of stuff like Shoji this works quickly and well. This technique allows one to cut the mortise for many situation zero prying required. Though there are Japanese prying tools so it isn't as though they never get there. It seems to be a tougher job to V deeper mortises that are blind as in a lot of western frame and panel work. For the center V technique it really pays to get a chisel and sit on the carpet in front of the TV and practice flopping it, because of all the 180 reversals required, and also picking up lines quickly while holding the chisel by the handle. I have a Cold Steel Tanto rubber practice knife that is pretty good for practicing manipulations. I have a foot powered mortiser, and it seems be designed for the 180 stuff, since it has a 180 pivot in the quill.

The method will vary a bit depending on the bevel angle because this determines how deep you can go without prying.

Western style for large mortises often starts with drilling. I even saw one of the cleanest working Japanese cabinetmakers I have seen video of, do small mortises that way. He whipped out a brace. The drilling is such a fast way to go that it makes a number of options worth the effort that otherwise wouldn't be. Like paring the sidewalls. Though one can drill undersized and use regular technique also.

My own preference is to not pare walls when it is a blind mortise since it is time consuming getting them parallel. However when working with the timber framer's guild, I had to do it that way because that appears to be the way it was done on blond mortise. They test with the square. It is relatively easy to get walls parallel if one can come at the walls from either side. One just pares at a slight angle until one has these shallow triangular ramps. Then one sets the chisel to a low angle and slices the tops off.

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#3

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

Great question. For me, it takes one of two directions, depending on the hardness of the wood, and the depth of the mortise. To back up a bit, one of the early considerations is how hard do you want to hit the chisel, and with what? I started out years ago with a 13 oz hammer, then went to 16 oz, and now use a 1-1/2 lb smithing hammer. Cause I want to hit the chisel with less velocity and more mass--that is a controlled strike (for me). Controlled, meaning the chisel ends up where intended, rather than driven offline.

Now on temperate zone hardwoods, like cherry, birch, soft maple, I like to start in the middle and make a V. Because I can line the chisel up, hit it two controlled licks in quick succession with the 1-1/2 lb hammer, and sink it 3/4" into the middle of the mortise. Then reverse the chisel and do it again--orient the chisel, hit it twice in succession--and now there is a pretty deep V in the middle of the mortise. I do this with the bevel facing inwards by the way--no reason, it's just more intuitive for me. Now at that point, there is room for the waste. So it's easy to just starting widening the V, slicing away about 1/8" at a time, down to the end of the mortise on one side; then repeat for the other arm of the V. At that point, you've completed your first course, and it's about 3/4" deep. If it's a blind mortise, then keep going to depth; if it's through, I start from the other side, and meet in the middle.

Back to the depth of the controlled strike.....My current project is in Ceylon satinwood. I hit it a controlled strike, and the 7.5mm chisel sinks in 1/4" to 3/8". Not 3/4". So instead of making a V, I just go from one end to the other like a typewriter making 1/4" deep strikes, and go down in 1/4" deep courses. It's like....you stay under control and take what the defense is willing to give you.

Also, if it's a shallow mortise, then the typewriter method is more intuitive for me.

Two cents.

Wiley

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#4

the drill one hole apporach

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I drill a pilot hole just shy of the mortise width (so that I don't have to locate it precisely to keep the hole between the scribe lines) close to one end. This hole provides chip clearance and establishes target depth. Then I chop from this hole to the end, reverse and clean out the small amount from hole to other end. I think the hole makes things go significantly faster, and because the hole does not need to be precisely located it is very quick to locate and drill.

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#5

I tend to do one end to the other....

John in NM

>Stopping and starting short of the finished ends by about 1/8" or more til I get to finished depth, then chop the ends in one swell foop.

Never tried it the other way, seems like thats putting too much thought into something fairly straightforward.

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#6

Until I saw Frank Klausz in action

Roy Anderson

>I was a drill one hole kind of guy. I used the method of drilling a hole for the wood fibers to compress into. Then, driving the chisel in to full depth, working my way from the middle out to the edges. This worked reasonably well, but Frank's method is so much more sensible.

He starts a little bit away from the end of a mortise and works his way across in a shallow cut, prying out the chips as he goes, stopping short of the other end.

Then he starts over again, a little closer to the first end, works his way across, and stops a little closer to the other end.

Repeat until the proper depth is reached. Pare the ends. Voila!

The big trick is to not try to pound the chisel in to full depth. Just go in part way, enough to pry the chips out. This results in a relatively flat bottom mortise with no time wasted drilling a hole. It also reduces the risk of blowing out the sides of the mortise, or as I managed to do once, blow out the entire end of the mortise, shearing out the end grain.

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#7

Re: Until I saw Frank Klausz in action *LINK*

Roy Anderson

>I've got a brief write up of Frank's method and Adam Cherubini's method in my blog. See link.


my blog

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#8

Re: Until I saw Frank Klausz in action

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think you lose any time gained by drilling by having to even up, neaten the sides. Plus, this introduces more occasions for sloppiness.

Pam

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#9

The vee in the middle, usually, Wilbur

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Wilbur,

I normally cut the vee in the middle, then sneak up onto the ends.

For a shallow housing or socket, etc... I'll just start at one end.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#10

Brian Boggs does this too

roninkokomo

>I find that the small cuts are much easier to manage and keep precise and they go very quickly. Very lite mallet taps

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#11

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I learned a method for mortising in 1978 from fellow who was a pioneer in hand woodworking. I have used this method ever since, whether it be for a nice temperate hardwood like Maclura pomifera or a nasty tropical hardwood like Ochroma lagopus. In 1979 Frank Klausz published a method in Fine Woodworking which I thought was rather clumsy in comparison. Apparently he got the same idea because he abandoned that method.

Start in the middle of the mortise, bevel facing away. Gradually move toward the far end, bevel still facing away, until 1/8 or 1/16 from end. Then turn the chisel around and work from the far end to the near end, bevel toward you (always faces the direction you are moving). Then either reverse the bevel again and go back, or start mortising form the other side.

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or

#12

Re: Mortise chopping: from the middle out, or *LINK*

David Brown

>I am no kind of expert, considering that I have never hand cut a mortise. Hey I'm just getting into these hand tools, but this thread reminded me that Christopher Schwarz tested various methods. I thought this link might be interesting to some, but they are clearly much smaller than the size mortises the original poster was making.

--Dave


Mortise methods