Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Rebate shave?

Posts

Rebate shave?

#1

Rebate shave?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Folks,

Just had a not-much-fun episode with a stopped rebate. Have a few more to do.

While scratching my head about it, it occurred to me that a fenced rebate shave would be the very thing. Haven't I seen a rebate shave somewhere? Did Preston make one? I checked the Preston 1909 catalog, and No. 1386 looks like it might do well--Preston's Improved Circular Rabbeting and Fillister Router.

Anyway, if anyone can provide a lead on one, I would be much obliged.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Rebate shave?

#2

How about a LN 140? Not a shave, but...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Rebate shave?

#3

Oops, sorry... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Tony Murland seems to have a 1389: A very rare PRESTON 1386 filaster shave, complete with all four fences. RARE G++ (80-120). Lot # 0275

Sorry for the wrong answer above. I read "rebate," never noticed the "shave" part. So, why a shave?

Pam


img

Preston filaster shave

Re: Rebate shave?

#4

Good find!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Pam!

Gonna take a chance on it. I think, after getting it under a magnifier. Has anyone seen one of these tools (Preston 1386) in the flesh?

You asked, why a 'shave'? The job is a stopped rabbet (rebate). The reason for wanting a 'shave' is to get a short base, so that the tool can sit down into the cut for most of the length of the rebate. A regular rebate plane, or filletster, or dado, or plough, will have a long stock or skate--which is great for a through cut, but will not get down into a stopped cut very well. With the shave, I can chisel the rebate for an inch or so at both ends of the cut, and the rebate shave should do the rest of the job.

Wiley

Re: Rebate shave?

#5

Re: Good find!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, I realized that, but it seems a bull nose with a guide (can't seem to think of the right word here, starts with a "b") would do a lot better, plenty of room to hold it properly. Unless the cut is extremely short; and if it is, why not just use a chisel for the whole thing.

Pam

Re: Rebate shave?

#6

Re: Rebate shave?

James Kirkpatrick

>Didn't Stanley make one? I think it was a number 68 or some such. I have seen several on the used market lately...

Re: Rebate shave?

#7

Re: Rebate shave?

Kenneth Martin Sacramento

>When I read your message I was thinking of this type of spokeshave(see pic) but it doesn't let you get up into the corner. Not having done a stopped rebate the only other thing I can think of is a hand router.

Ken


img

Re: Rebate shave?

#8

Re: Rebate shave?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wiley

Just what have you been trying thus far?

I usually complete stopped rebates with a router plane.

If you start with a rebate plane, then it will plane an arc ..



So finish with a router plane ...





Completed carcase ..



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rebate shave?

#10

Re: Stanley 68

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Amazingly good prices there, too.

Re: Rebate shave?

#11

Re: Rebate shave?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Derek,

Thank you! I have a question about the router plane, but first let me answer your question about what have I been doing.....

I've done a couple of different things. In soft wood, like soft maple or cherry, and if the depth of rabbet is shallow, like 3/16" to 1/4", I gauge the face grain line and the side grain line and dig out the rabbet with a Preston stringing router. Brute force. That's in softish wood.

Yesterday, the wood was Ceylon satinwood, which is a bit harder. I gauged the two control lines deeply, and mortised out the ends. MY initial plan was to use a Japanese panel saw to just rip down the two control lines and remove the rabbet waste surgically. Well, that was slow going. So I picked up a 1" chisel, went down the rabbet making cross-grain vertical strikes every inch or so to interrupt the grain, and then just began splitting out the waste with the chisel, coming in first from one face, then the other. That actually worked pretty well, but it's nerve-wracking because you're keeping your fingers crossed that the grain splits the right way for you. Turned out it did, but the sawing was important in that situation, and I didn't want to repeat it. Would like to start from the initial gauge lines and start removing waste right away. That's when the rebate shave idea occurred--I was looking essentially for a short-base plough plane.

I did recall your recent tutorials on the router plane. But I have a question....and let me say right away I don't have a router plane. Because my impression is that the router is a finesse tool which is best used to level a channel bottom (that is already there), rather than to plough out waste. The flat bottomed blade looks like it wants to ride along and cut down the high places, rather than dig in, get a fresh bite, and plough. But maybe my supposing is wrong--can you comment further as to how well the router plane digs in and ploughs.

Everyone else's comments also most welcome-I'm looking for a solution.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Rebate shave?

#12

Using a Router Plane  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The flat bottomed blade looks like it wants to ride along and cut down the high places, rather than dig in, get a fresh bite, and plough. But maybe my supposing is wrong--can you comment further as to how well the router plane digs in and ploughs.

Hi Wiley

I see where you are coming from. The fact is that a router plane blade is not really "flat bottomed" - it is set at an angle (15 degrees ?), so will bite into the wood.

You can see this more easily in the blade in the lower picture at the right ...



Router planes do a fair imitation of a plough plane and can cut grooves very well ..



Here planing a stopped groove.



My earlier post showed a stopped rebate.

Using a router plane is somewhat similar to a Stanleyt #45 - both lack support around the blade, such as a mouth to hold down the wood fibres. It is important to use a sharp blade and work with the grain where you can. Use a chisel to clean up at the stopped end that runs against the grain.

If you do not have a router plane, you can always knock up an Old Woman's Tooth (OWT) ..



Regards from Perth

Derek


OWT

Re: Rebate shave?

#13

Re: Using a Router Plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Derek,

That's very helpful indeed. I get it about the blade geometry. That's my solution.

Wiley

Re: Rebate shave?

#14

Insteresting little beast you have there.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Kenneth, do you own it? Care to share more about it.

South Park is on tonight you better be careful Kenny...;^)

Re: Rebate shave?

#15

Re: Insteresting little beast you have there.

Kenneth Martin Sacramento

>No I don't. I found the pic online.

Ken

Re: Rebate shave?

#16

Stanley 68

roninkokomo

>

Re: Rebate shave?

#17

Re: Rebate shave?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>It is a rebate shave for leatherworking.

Stephen

Re: Rebate shave?

#18

Re: Stanley 68

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Each picture has a "click for pic" link to the right of the main picture; these extra pictures are mainly the shaves upside down from the main picture.

I'm struck by the length of the soles on the No. 68 rabbet shaves. They're more nearly short rabbet planes with handles on the sides - much longer than the soles on the conventional shaves.

I wonder what the original design brief was - what problem Stanley intended to solve in developing these?

Re: Rebate shave?

#19

Thanks Ken. Hope you don't mind...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>My shortening of your name.

Re: Rebate shave?

#20

Re: Good find!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Pam,

As I recall, bullnoses are maybe 4" long, is that about right? I have not seen a fenced one, but an LN140, which you mentioned before is fenced, but is 5" or 6" long. The reason for asking about a shave (or router) is so I don't need to chisel a 4" to 6" open mortise at one end to get started.

Your thought about the chisel is a good one. I mentioned above in a reply to Derek that I did the first one with a chisel from beginning to end. And it works. And you have to chisel out terminations at each end of the stopped rebate anyway. BTW, these rebates are about two feet long. 1/4" x 1/2" or so. The thing is, using a 1" chisel, I made 3 passes the length of the rebate on each of the two faces--to control the cut. Starter cut, deeper, cut, and paring cut--on each face. This was after making deep scribes to define the mortise. If I try to bust it out any faster, it's a huge risk of having a chunk come out that tears out 'live wood' under the scribe line. The satinwood splinters out readily along grain lines.

So my take is that the router plane that Derek describes is just gonna be a quicker and more controlled way for me to do the work--it's a ploughing operation, and I think 10 passes down the board just as fast as I can do them will get me through 1/4", and it won't take much length of mortise at the ends to get started.

However, it wouldn't surprise me to learn that back in the day, plenty of rebates were done with chisels only. It could get real efficient with lots of practice.

Wiley

Re: Rebate shave?

#21

Re: Good find!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The word I was trying to remember is batten, that's all you'd need in a fence for a bullnose. And the bullnose doesn't care which way it's being pushed; so on a 2' cut you'd be able to do all but the last inch on each end.

I think that maybe you think a router plane will be faster because you've never used one of these beasts. :) My experience is with the Stanley version, and I spent so much time adjusting the blade (the blades don't take off all that much at one pass) that I returned to the chisel with azebiki. However, the LV/LN versions may be far superior. And sharpening the blades is such a joy.

I also think there's probably no convenient, elegant way to do a stopped rebate/dado.

Pam

Re: Rebate shave?

#22

Re: Good find!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"...it wouldn't surprise me to learn that back in the day, plenty of rebates were done with chisels only."

It's my understanding that a lot of rabbets on wooden boats (on the planking, for instance, where they're curved) are still done that way. Somewhere, I've got a copy of "Wooden Boat" with an article on making a gouge from a tire lug nut wrench for hogging out the rabbet prior to finishing.