Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Milk paint question

Posts

Milk paint question

#1

Milk paint question

Dave Mount, another snowstorm coming

>My wife requested a set of utilitarian shelves for the mud room (aptly named at our place). As per her specification, the shelves will hold wood boxes of various sizes to hold all the miscellany that collects in the mud room. She wants milk paint as the finish.

Given that it was to be painted, I decided to use the opportunity to make use of some sap-stained white pine that I've been trying to find a purpose for. This was air dried (i.e., sap not set).

My question involves sealing the knots (or not). Searching around I found an article by Mike Dunbar that says to apply milk paint only to raw wood. Yet, on the Milk Paint Co. website they talk about sealing knots with shellac. This is a rustic piece, so I'm not really worried about the knots telegraphing, nor am I looking for a highly finished look. Being made of pine and given that wood boxes will be being dragged on and off the shelves routinely, this will end up with "patina" very quickly I expect.

This will be my first experience with milk paint -- I rarely paint furniture. Based on what I've outlined, should I put some Seal Coat down first or just put the milk paint on raw wood? Any other tips while I'm asking?

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Milk paint question

#2

Adjustment

paul womack

>From memory the OLDTOOLS list went through milk paint obsession at one stage (most forums go through obsesssions).

You might want to check the archive.

BugBear

Re: Milk paint question

#3

use something else

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The only reason to use milk paint is in authentic reproductions. And even in that case I don't know that the current formulation matches that used in ancient times. Milk paint is ground pigment in a film forming polymer, in this case milk protein, that does not make a lustrous film. The look of milk paint can be simulated with a synthetic polymer film former that similarly does not make a lustrous film.

I will make a guess that either wife wants the dull look of milk paint or you want practice dealing with it. If the situation is the former then use a water based paint in a dull luster and apply it thinned if it is not already thin. The paint will apply better and hold up better. General Finishes used to sell a paint called "Country Colors" that was available from Woodcraft. I have used it on lots of stuff and it looks like milk paint to me. Alternatively, any latex paint in a dull luster will be similar. It will come premixed, it won't settle while using it, it won't rot if stored, it will cost less, it will brush on vastly easier and more uniform and you won't have to practice to learn how to use it.

It is sobering that white pine stains even in N. MN. It will stain here in TN in a day when sawed in hot weather. Someone posted on the main message board some time ago that drying lumber was easy if one just read some article and followed the directions. Apparently they didn't have much experience yet.

Re: Milk paint question

#4

Err, Bill

David Miller from Iowa

>Bill -

Your logic is great, but you forget a cardinal rule of marriage - it doesn't matter why she wants it that way, if she wants milk paint you give her milk paint. And if she doesn't like it you redo it in latex or whatever with a smile on your face.

Took me 25 years to figure this out and my life is markedly improved:)

Re: Milk paint question

#5

Re: Milk paint question

Dean J in MN

>Paint the raw wood. I've not had any issues with that method on two pine toolchests.

I find the modern milk paint to be nearly bullet-proof after application. It seems, for lack of a better description, to be thin colored plaster. It doesn't chip or crack and wears very well. It is harder to brush on than latex, but really isn't difficult to deal with. If this is your first time, don't be alarmed at how crappy it will look after the first coat -- Be assured it will be fine after the second!

-Dean

Re: Milk paint question

#6

Re: Milk paint question

John Veerkamp,Western Mo

>Dave, I've used milk paint on several projects. It will stick just fine over the shellacked knots. As a final protective coat I lightly sand the paint after it is very dry and then top coat with Poly. Use a satin to keep the look. This makes your project much more durable.

John

Re: Milk paint question

#7

I like the stuff...

John in NM

>And I've done several cabinets and an entire kitchen with it. In all fairness I've not tried Country Colors, I might like them even better.

Milk paint is very easy to apply and get a nice satin finish IMHO. Fine sanding after the first coat, followed by fine steel wool after the next one (or two), then a high resin oil like Waterlox gives an easy, smooth, satin finish that is just rustic enough without beating the viewer over the head with it. And its not all sticky like latex.

As to pine knots bleeding through, I can't help you there... I've mostly used poplar and maple. A couple small painted projects were pine, but pretty much clear.

Re: Milk paint question

#8

I'm a milk paint fan too.

Hank Knight

>Dave,

I've used a lot if milk paint and I like it a lot. It's pretty bullet proof and sticks to most anything, but it does best on raw wood. I wouldn't seal the whole piece with Seal Coat, just the knots. I've used epoxy on loose knots with good results and have never had a problem with the milk paint not adhering to the epoxy. Everybody has their own preference for finishing milk paint. I've used polyurethane with good results. My preference is to apply several coats of milk paint to get a good opaque finish; sand or rub it smooth with steel wool and apply BLO, then wax when the BLO cures. The finish can be buffed up with an occasioinal waxing. In your mud room case, polyurethane would probably be preferable to BLO and wax.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Milk paint question

#9

a variant on your sage advise

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When I was first married an old timer advised me that "it was easier to keep a woman happy than dealing with one that wasn't". I can't say that I have see evidence to the contrary.

Re: Milk paint question

#10

Let's be fair

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think it runs both ways.

Re: Milk paint question

#11

Re: Milk paint question *LINK*

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>A lot of Windsor chair makers use milk paint, myself included. One brand of milk paint says to cover knots with shellac, and paint over it with milk paint before it dries. There is also a product called "Extra Bond" that lets you use milk paint over surfaces other than bare wood.

One chair maker that will make you change your mind about milk paint is Peter Galbert. He is a great innovator and experimenter. And, he also shares his findings in his blog. He has indexed his blog, and the link below has his postings on finishing. Not all of them are about milk paint, so scroll through.


Peter Galbert's Blog - Postings on Finishing

Re: Milk paint question

#12

Milk Paint

R.J. Whelan

>Dave ... the knots will almost definitely telegraph through: it's been my experience that shellac will stop this. I have done a few cabinets with pine that had milk paint applied over shellaced knots and I did notice a difference in the look of the milk paint with shellac under it (after the 1st coat); but with the 2nd coat everything evened out.

That being said: I did a cabinet with milk paint without sealing the knots and they did show through (after a few months) and I think it looks kind of cool.

Good luck - rj

Re: Milk paint question

#13

Re: Thanks all, lots to think about

Dave Mount

>Thanks to everyone for the info, pointers, and warnings, all of them were very useful -- I got a lot of useful reading. Seems the best plan is to go in with no particular expectations and learn from what comes out, even if what comes out is a decision not to use milk paint again.

Best,

Dave

Re: Milk paint question

#14

Re: sapstain and drying your own wood

Dave Mount

>Yes, sapstain will definitely happen up here in MN too. Red pine is worse than white, but both will stain easily -- both the grey/blue and the brown varieties. In the case of this batch, I should have known better. I stacked and stripped it immediately off the saw on a flatbed, for the express purpose of getting it out for some quick air. Putting pine out in the open air and breeze is usually enough to keep the stain away, same for maple. However, we had a couple rainy days after sawing and I parked the load in the barn, then didn't get it out again right away. Even though it was on sticks and out of the weather, the damp air and lack of air movement (not much air moving in the barn) got the sapstain going. Fortunately, the stain is limited to the sapwood and the heartwood is unaffected. Since I only had about 20 cents a bf into it, it's no catastrophe.

Years ago we sawed a couple thousand feet of white pine and treated it with fungicide. That was very effective, but it was a pain going through the whole pile board by board and spraying all four sides. The fungicide was not exactly cheap, but it kept the wood very bright.

Despite this tale of mini-woe, I don't like to discourage people from drying their own wood. Yes, you can damage some wood if you screw up, but most of those mistakes can be avoided by reading a lot on the topic and getting advice from those that have done it. But I agree with your basic tenet, that there is a little more to it than just throwing planks on sticks. In my case, with a sawmill in the family, my mistakes are cheap.

If anyone is interested in getting into drying their own wood, I'd strongly suggest walnut. I never dealt with a more forgiving wood to dry. I've dried pieces of walnut that had the pith angling through the middle of the board (i.e., pith was one one side of the board and one end, passed through the middle and was on the other side of the board at the other end). If that was cherry, it would have been a cracked pretzel when dry. The walnut dried straight and didn't check, even where the pith went through. Not that you won't ever get pith checks in walnut, but it is very forgiving. Walnut sapwood can stain a little if you abuse it, but the heartwood won't. Thick oak on the other hand. . .not so easy.

Anyway, my point is that Bill's cautions about the consequences of improper drying shouldn't be ignored, but I wouldn't want that to discourage someone that's inclined to try it. Like most things, it's not hard once you are armed with a little knowledge.

Best,

Dave

Re: Milk paint question

#15

Re: sapstain and drying your own wood

ThomD

>I agree. I haven't had much trouble with drying wood, and I have dried lots of it. Possibly the local climate is just very compliant. As long as I seal the ends and give it lots of time, I wil normally get a very good yield. I have bough wood that yielded poorly, so even when someone else does it one isn't out of the woods.

Re: Milk paint question

#16

Re: use something else

ThomD

>I largely agree with that. One other reason for using it is to easily stack colours that one can then sand through for an "authentic" worn look. Always wonder how authentic that really is since in most cases people in the past seemed more than willing to top coat a chair the moment it showed wear.

You can always break down and just do some tests! The shelac will keep the resin at bay to some extent, and almost all finishes will bond to it. For instance if you were to top coat with Watco it would bond to the shelac, so all you really need to ensure is that the top coat penetrates well, and that the milk paint doesn't fall off before you hit it with the clearcoat. Milk paint dries really fast, so you can slap a coat onto a scrap, and then do a masking tape test just to see that it stays in place relatively well over the shelac coated knot. No mater what anyone else says will happen a test is a better way of being sure before you create a huge mess.

Since milk paint is cut with water, you can probably mix in a little acrylic sealer to add some stick to it. Acrylibond is something I often try when I wonder whether something water based will stick. I am not recomending it but I would probably try it if my initial tests struck out. I wouldn't use too much of it, since it will seal out the top coat. But one could prime with shelac, then prime with some milk paint with the binder in it, and then the whole thing with milk paint, then hit it with watco. At which point latex will look like a bargain.

Re: Milk paint question

#17

fairness is way overrated

roninkokomo

>

Re: Milk paint question

#18

AMEN twice

roninkokomo

>

Re: Milk paint question

#19

Ummm, Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Milk paint was made to have a top coat applied to it. Wax, BLO (my fav) or poly, etc...

It was never meant to used alone, it would be as dull as me...

Re: Milk paint question

#20

I like it...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Takes a little bit of getting use to Dave. I use a old hand blender to mix it with. I prefer "Real Milk Paint". Keep knocking down the froth that comes with mixing it. I wouldn't worry about knots, but it won't hurt to seal them first (dontcha love pine eh?). I never used it on pine but I have covered a bit of the green to purple shaded poplar with no problems.

Just do it, it's fun and a good learning experience too!

Yea, that first coat will look scary, sand or steel wool and go for it again. You won't have time for a beer between coats, unless you want one...