Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

Posts

Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#1

Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

wilbur

>I was doing a bit of tune up recently on the Stanley Bailey bench planes that I have. I've always thought that having an older type Bailey than the ones that I have would be nice, and one of the pieces of conventional wisdom that explained why the older types were better was the design of the frog -- specifically, the face of the frog that supports the blade. I cobbled these two pictures together from the internet to illustrate what I mean. My Stanley planes have the newer design, like the one on the right.

In the older frog design, most of the face is flat, whereas with the new design, more hollows are built into the frog face. My guess is that this made flattening the face easier, since you only had to flatten the raised areas instead of the entire face.

The conventional wisdom is that the older design provides more support for the blade due to the increased area of contact. But this doesn't make much sense to me, just looking at the frogs. I find it hard to believe that any real blade flex occurs in the hollowed areas during use. To me, the area of the blade that needs the most support is towards the cutting edge, and the newer frog does have a notch cut out in that area, but again, I find it hard to believe that the blade flexes to any degree across that short gap.

Now, a lot of this is speculation, since I've never seen an older-style frog in person. But it does make sense to me that the hollows in the newer style frog allow you to get the face of the frog perfectly flat more easily.

Assuming that both style frogs are equally flat, is there a real difference in blade support? Or are there other aspects to the design of the older frogs that leads to better performance?


img

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#2

Can't help in a positive way; I can add confusion *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Wilbur and colleagues:

A year or maybe two ago (losing track...), I picked up an older Stanley No. 4 with the flat-faced frog* on the left side of your picture, thinking I'd found a Really Cool Plane. I have yet to have time to do any serious messing with this, but did discover that it's got the frog design that appears to have been used on Type 4-8 planes (1874-1902 - I even looked up the type of mine, but have now forgotten it); you can see the body where the frog would sit on Patrick Leach's Blood and Gore discussion of the Nos. 1-8 plane, linked below - scroll down into the discussion of the No. 3. In my preliminary messing about, I discovered I could fit a rather substantial feeler gauge underneath the front of the frog. In other words, the frog is cantilevered out over the body right at the mouth, which seems like an invitation to chatter. This discovery rather put me off, which has been one of the reasons I haven't experimented with it - sheer lack of time, and a must-do list that has expanded like my waistline at Christmas and worse, being the other reasons.

I'd be interested, as part of this discussion, to hear from those with experience whether the more comprehensive bearing surface on the earlier frog offsets the more limited bearing surface between frog and body.

*Sounds rather more biological even than most references to "frog", doesn't it? "The flat-faced frog native to the area around Fargo is famous for its consumption of fireflies."


Some useful Blood and Gore information

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#3

Not on critical path

David Miller from Iowa

>IMHO, it doesn't matter compared to other factors. Blade sharpness, technique and quality of wood are the primary factors. A decently tuned plane of either style will perform fine on decently behaved wood. If you are talking chatter protection from going against the grain on curly hardwoods, you may need a different plane altogether.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#4

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design mat

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

"But it does make sense to me that the hollows in the newer style frog allow you to get the face of the frog perfectly flat more easily."

That is an interesting speculation as to why Stanley chose to cast the hollows into the face of the frog. Probably right. But let me ask this, if there is a physicist in the crowd: Do the hollows in principle reduce friction between blade and frog? If so, it would ease the strain on the adjuster mechanism. I have marvelled frequently at how efficiently the Bailey adjuster works, in that you don't have to loosen the lever cap screw to make it work.

Wiley

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#5

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design mat

James Watriss

>Hey Wilbur

I think in theory, you're probably right. Flattening this one (For stanley, or for you) might be a little easier. I think they showed up around WWII, though, so they may also be the result of an effort to save on material. How much material is saved is really anyone's guess. I'm sure there's a better explanation.

What I can say is that the planes I own with the flat faced frog are, in general, better made overall. I've heard some folks say that the WWII era planes signaled the beginning of a general decline... which sort of makes sense, since it also coincides with a point in time where hand held power tools were coming into being. (First circular saw hit the market in the late 20's, early 30's, and cost roughly $1000 in today's money.)

When I started tuning up my planes at school, I had a couple of SW-era planes that I really liked. (type 12-15, I think? Type 15 discontinued in '32) Among the overall fit and finish, one of hte things I noticed was that the frog, once the screws were taken out, slid back and forth like it was on a rail. The parts on these planes were very well machined, and in general, they fit together very well. Handles were comfortable, and overall, it just felt a lot better. Coincidentally, one of these was the #3 that just sold on the BA board. I'll keep my eye out for other cheap ones on the 'bay, one of these days I'll do a photo-documented tune up for an article if people are interested.

So, my short answer... I don't know if the flat faced frog really offers that much more support. But my impression, from the specimens that I own, is that the rest of the plane probably does.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#6

Re: Can't help in a positive way; I can add confus

James Watriss

>I just picked one of these up on eBay... see my post from earlier today.

In general, the frog to sole mating looks to me like an early ancestor of the bedrock plane... lots of flat surfaces in the same geometrical plane that probably worked very well together.

It'll probably be a week or two til this one hits the shop, and another week til it's tuned up and ready to work. I'll let you know what I think when that day comes.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#7

Re: Can't help in a positive way; I can add confus

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>james,

I know about that late-night ebay thang. Some deals just look too good to pass up.

Hey, it would be helpful to many if you would take a few photos as you tune up the new No. 4, and post the show and tell. You mentioned you could do that if there is interest, and I can assure you there will be.

Wiley

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#8

Tangential question - LN and LV frogs

wilbur

>Does anyone have a picture of the face of the frogs that are in the LV and LN bevel down planes? I just realized I've never seen that part of their planes, and that might be an interesting point of comparison.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#9

Re: Can't help in a positive way; I can add confus

James Watriss

>Oh, I'll be taking pictures, I was just thinking along the lines of something that was a lil more beaten up, to show a more marked transformation.

Maybe Todd can come up with something worthy for me...

Go from zero to hero, and then on to the auction board again...

(don't think this old #4 will be up for auction if I really decide I like it... but you never can tell.)

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#10

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design mat

Stuart Hough

>From what I've read, the biggest reason for the hollows is economy. The hollows allow less cast iron to be used, saving money (especially when you're talking production of thousands of planes) and also it cuts down on machining time...less surface to cut meant faster production. just my "dos centavos"

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#11

LN frog

David Miller from Iowa

>Pic below. Just to clarify, are we discussing Stanley's intent that a 3 dimensional frog face is easier for them to flatten at the factory or for us to flatten at home? Has to be a factory question because once they put the cutter advance lever on it is hard to flatten a frog at home. The few times I have tried it, I had to remove the lever to get anything done.


img

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#12

Re: LN frog

wilbur

>As far as whether it was easier for Stanley or for the user to flatten the frog face, I was thinking of the user (me). I was able to improve the flatness by working around the lever by flattening one side for a while, then across the bottom, then the opposite side, and going back to the first side again.

Is there a good way of getting the lever off? I've never tried doing that myself.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#13

P.S. Thanks for the pic!

wilbur

>

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#14

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design mat

ThomD

>I wonder if having the notch in the end would stop a bow from happening that would cause the forward edge to distort. Clamping down on the two screws is bound to cause some distortion.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#15

Amen

roninkokomo

>I think we are talking about a distinction that makes no difference. I so very much agree with David.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#16

Re: Amen

ThomD

>That is right about just about everything at a certain level of performance, and untrue about almost any detail no mater how small at a refined enough level of performance. Since low performance is what gets the vast majority of the work done, you are probably right, up to a point.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#17

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design mat

James Watriss

>Actually, it's not as much of an issue as you'd think. Quite the opposite really... I've seen some plane soles lapped very, very flat, only to warp a little bit when the owner tightened up the frog screws. Not horribly warped... but noticeable with a straight edge.

lesson learned... lap your sole AFTER you bed in the frog and tighten it down.

Re: Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?

#18

Just arrived in the mail

James Watriss

>Hi Bill,

I just got my hands on a plane just like the one you're talking about.

I see your point about the frog being cantilevered out, and we'll see what happens when I get this thing tuned up. But the bearing surface looks pretty solid to me, and the part of the frog that slopes down from there is 1/4" thick of cast iron, so I don't think it's going to chatter.

That said, the thing that does concern me is that the frog doesn't have anything to reference it at 90 degrees, so I'll have to make sure it's square before I tighten it down.

One last thing... this plane is OLD. 100+ years old. Now, I don't know who owned it last, or when they used it last... it's been a while. But they did camber the iron very nicely.

Just figured I'd throw that out there.

More as it comes, and when I get this thing tuned up.

Maybe this weekend?