Stanley bench planes: does the frog design matter?
wilbur
>I was doing a bit of tune up recently on the Stanley Bailey bench planes that I have. I've always thought that having an older type Bailey than the ones that I have would be nice, and one of the pieces of conventional wisdom that explained why the older types were better was the design of the frog -- specifically, the face of the frog that supports the blade. I cobbled these two pictures together from the internet to illustrate what I mean. My Stanley planes have the newer design, like the one on the right.
In the older frog design, most of the face is flat, whereas with the new design, more hollows are built into the frog face. My guess is that this made flattening the face easier, since you only had to flatten the raised areas instead of the entire face.
The conventional wisdom is that the older design provides more support for the blade due to the increased area of contact. But this doesn't make much sense to me, just looking at the frogs. I find it hard to believe that any real blade flex occurs in the hollowed areas during use. To me, the area of the blade that needs the most support is towards the cutting edge, and the newer frog does have a notch cut out in that area, but again, I find it hard to believe that the blade flexes to any degree across that short gap.
Now, a lot of this is speculation, since I've never seen an older-style frog in person. But it does make sense to me that the hollows in the newer style frog allow you to get the face of the frog perfectly flat more easily.
Assuming that both style frogs are equally flat, is there a real difference in blade support? Or are there other aspects to the design of the older frogs that leads to better performance?




