Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

Posts

Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#1

Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

charlie belden

>A friend showed me what I thought was a bent laminate or steam bent sample with about a 130 degree, about 3/4" radius. The wood looked like it was probably tiger maple. And the piece was maybe 3/8" thick.

When I looked at the edges of the piece I didn't see any obvious laminate liness and the thickness seemed a bit thick for steam bending. Then I looked closer - and saw a BUNCH of very fine kerfs - all cut to the same depth and all square to the edge.

Hmmmm - he's really good with a japanese dovetail saw.

"Must've taken you a bit of time to make all those saw cuts." I commented.

"Nope - did this little sample in about ten minutes." he said - smiling (he's a Tool Phreak too). "Did this on my new JointMaker Pro." You really have to see this thing and play with it to get an idea of what it CAN do. Check YouTube for 'Joint Maker Pro' when you get home." - he continued.

Now I'm convinced he's getting even with me for turning him on to the Festool DOMINO. I took mine up to his shop and cut two mortiseses in each end of the apron parts and four mortises in each leg - of a bonsai display table - in redwood - in about 15 minutes. Offered to loan him the DOMINO for a week or two - but he opted to go buy one the next day.

He didn't mention the price of the JMP.

I found some videos on this puppy - and I have to say the reviews I'd read in the various woodworking magazines when this thing came out didn't impress me. Seeing it work - in real time - changed my opinion quite a bit. The speed and accuracy of a cabinet saw - without the noise, flying sawdust and kerf waste - at least for cross cutting and limited depth end grain cuts - finger and dovetail joints. Not intended for long rip cuts though.

Then I got to the price tag - in the high end contractor's saw, low to low medium range of a cabinet saw- $1,500+.

Is this the Missing Link - between Neanders who see all "tailed tools" as the work of the devil, and the Normites who consider ANY woodworking tool that doesn't run on 220V, preferably with a power feeder - a Luddite toy for people with more time than money? This thing blurs the line, manually operated so it techinically is a hand tool, but with some of the key features of a cabinet saw, with a corresponding price tag.

Lee Valley's Veritas Tools is rethinking and redesigning tradition hand tools. Is the JMP just another step in that evolution?

What say you? Is the JMP really a hand tool?

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#2

The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>David Pye's 1960s distinction between the workmanship of risk and the workmanship of certainty* was one quite helpful rethinking of the hand/power tool issue, although he was also clear that it was not a dichotomy but a continuum: after all, a hand plane provides a level of workmanship of certainty over a chisel or drawknife.

Using this test, the Jointmaker Pro is over a ways toward the workmanship of certainty end of the continuum.

So, what's a hand tool; what's not? I think the argument that anything powered by human exertion is a hand tool is a difficult one: that would mean that a great wheel lathe, with an apprentice sweating like mad as s/he turns the wheel, is a hand tool, while a water-powered lathe is not, even though, from the operator's perspective, the motive power makes no difference in the operation (other than being able to yell to the apprentice to speed up/slow down, instead of operating levers).

One distinction might be that hand tools depend on a sharp edge/point operated in a linear fashion, while power tools apply force through rotary motion. That falls down, though, when you consider the brace or eggbeater drill, both clearly rotary in operation and just as clearly hand tools. No easy way to plug a brace into the wall.

*To summarize, badly, his argument was that the workmanship of risk depended on the skill of the worker; the w. of certainty, by the use of jigs, fixtures, and other guides, replaced worker skill with toolmaker's skill. There's a LOT more to his argument.

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#3

Re: The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

ThomD

>Anyone who would self-describe as a normite, or a Neanderthal is caught up in an identity rather than a craft. The Jointmaker pro is clearly not a hand tool since it is not held in the hand, one doesn't hold the tool, one holds the workpiece. In that regard it is closest to the inverted plane bench used by a cooper, where the wooden piece is moved by hand over a fixed plane, though the JP uses more fences, generally.

There are many tools of an in-between sort, foot powered mortising tools, power jointer or mortiser where part of the cutting power is provided by hand. The JP looks like an extremely interesting tool. I would consider making one. The only really difficult part about them is the angle adjust, A tool that only cuts square and a second one that cuts at a preferred dovetail angle would be all one really needed. Unfortunately the inability to keep the price reasonable is a big problem for this tool as with everything BCT makes. Most of their tools could be easily replaced with other tools but this one is of real value. Too bad.

The Pye distinction is a useful one here, but not useful in the general distinction of power and hand tools. There are many power tools that both at the work and personal level embody extremes of workmanship of risk. Just about anything around a grinder or a buffer, hand held, or fixed is real risky.

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#4

Re: The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"The Pye distinction is a useful one here, but not useful in the general distinction of power and hand tools."

It's been a while since I read Pye's book that includes this argument, but, as I recall, he was not equating hand/power and risk/certainty definitions. Indeed, it is part of the point of this argument that the motive power for the tool is less relevant than the degree to which the mechanic exercises control over the finished product.

Elsewhere in the same book, he makes the argument that the irregularities that are unavoidable with the workmanship of risk are what make made objects, whether buildings, furniture, or whatever, aesthetically interesting - though he did not celebrate what he called "hairy shirts." He felt that a good worker should strive for the highest possible quality, while recognizing that irregularities are inevitable, and that the viewer should seek the highest quality, and appreciate the irregularities.

Clearly, he would not have enjoyed the chrome steel/glass aesthetic.

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#5

Agree: Certainty of Results vs Power Supply

David Cockey

>I agree the distinction between risk and certainty when applied to results is more useful than the source of power. The results of cuts made on freehand on a bandsaw are much less certain than when using a Jointmaster Pro, or a good handsaw mitre box. Similarly both boring machines and drill presses have a high degree of certainty once the item to be drilled is aligned. One being powered by hand while the other is powered by electricity (or hydraulics in some "non-electric" shops) is irrelevant to the results.

Back to the Jointmaker Pro. What would be different about either the results or skill required if someone built a simple mechanisim powered by an electric motor to move the work back and forth on a Jointmaker Pro rather than doing it manually? To me the results and skill required would be the same for both sources of power.

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#6

spectrum

paul womack

>What say you? Is the JMP really a hand tool?

Most things are continuums. The JMP is not electric, but it is massively guided. It's essentually a human powered machine.

But so (to dsome degree) are mitre saws, fenced planes and post drills. Even a bench planes is a chisel, guided better than the human hand can manage.

I regard the is it/isn't it question as less important than "do you find using it satisfying", which is of course a matter of taste, not definition.

After all, if we just wanted furniture, we'd go to a furniture shop.

BugBear

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#7

Re: spectrum

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>What difference would it make one way or the other? If we say it's a power tool will more people buy it and more people avoid it? I don't think so. I agree with Thom, it would be a great project to build one based on an old contractor saw without the circular blade.

Someone on another forum noted that when he demonstrated it, he had to clear the saw teeth with every (or every other) stroke. That could be tedious.

Pam

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#8

Re: spectrum

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>The statement that 'it would be a good project to recreate it' indicates a certain limitation in the scope of interest.

I've seen the tool. It's brilliantly executed. I don't want one. I certainly don't want to make one. To those who do: God speed!

Every week I get a better indication of how modest a sized group of enthusiasts we woodworkers are. Those of the hand tool persuasion are an even smaller crowd. There is nothing wrong with that. Just that the world is a larger place.

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#9

Not so!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"After all, if we just wanted furniture, we'd go to a furniture shop."

This Forum has attracted a small segment of the woodworking community that is more concerned with the details of how something is made than getting it made, or other motivational factors. Start hanging around places where people's motivations are building stuff rather than the details of how it is built and one will find that many (most?) of these builders are doing it because they can't find or can't afford stuff they want. To take a notable example, the 2006 SAPFM Cartouche winner lives up the road from me and when asked how he got into woodworking his reply is "because I wanted 18th century furniture I could not otherwise afford". This reply is echoed among most of the members of our woodworking club that actually make stuff on a regular basis. Our idols are the professional cabinet makers that crank out the stuff we want in 1/4 the time.

That is not to say that these "practical" (to coin an arbitrary label) woodworkers don't enjoy what they are doing. But they may well enjoy different parts of the project. For example, in my case I like design, detail work and finishing. Ripping boards on a table saw is mindless work made to pass faster than doing it with a hand saw. In the end the product and maker are judged by the design, fit and finish and not at all by the details of how it got from boards to living room.

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#10

Re: spectrum

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It's hard to get real excited about a tool of limited usefulness that I'm not going to afford. After having spent 34 years developing software, I've become a reductionist (this system is just like every other system I've built except for a, b, and c); so to me the jointmaker is a saw type I use a lot placed upside down in a contractor saw's carriage. I have some extra dozuki laying about and a spare contractor saw, so the expense to build it is about zero.

It is ingenious and appears to be very well made. Maybe it's what the power tool folk need to feel comfortable giving up table saws that produce the dust that gives them cancer? And since those people are more accustomed to $1500 saws, it might be very successful, and rightly so.

Pam

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#11

Re: UnBlurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>"What say you? Is the JMP really a hand tool?"

The JointMaker Pro is an adjustable jig that incorporates a handsaw blade intended for cutting wood. If human hands aren't making it do what it does, it would do nothing. There is no other power source than human energy that makes it work.

It's a hand tool.

Marv

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#12

Re: The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

charlie belden

>Pye - haven't seen that name in a while. The workmanship of risk and the workmanship of certainty? Doesn't matter if I use handtools or power tools, the outcome almost always seems to be risky ; ). And when it comes to woodturning - it's always risky - for me.

I initially thought of the hand tool vs the power tool in terms of wood to the tool or tool to the wood - wood still/tool moves or tool still / wood moves. The JMP doesn't meet the tool to the wood criteria - so that's no help.

Then I thought of the rate at which things are done - hand tools operate at human speed, power tools typically operate at faster to much faster rates. The former provides both tactile as well as audible feedback - and time to react, the latter provides little if any tactile feedback - and usually when something is going wrong and there's not much you can do about it - and the same goes for audible feedback. You can feel and hear while hand planing, when the grain has changed - and adjust to that.

There was an issue raised having to do with essentially the School Of Hard Knocks / Dues Paying - traditional stock prep and joinery - done with hand tools adding some level of craftsmanship to the finished piece - whether it will be seen - even by an intermediate to advanced woodworker. Unlike a relatively short period in the history of woodworking - sepcifically solid wood furniture making - The A&C Movement - joinery has traditionally been unseen - by intent. Most chinese solid wood furniture at least in the last couple of hundred years uses very complex, difficult to do, joinery - all invisible from the outside of the piece. And when you don't have modern glues and the pieces are moved with the owner - several times a year - to different climate conditions - joinery that allowed for wood movement and didn't rely on glue to hold things together was essential. You DO NOT want a chair or bench you made for a powerful man to fail - with him or any of his sitting on it.

Then there's the "Do you want to actually make things - in a reasonable amount of time - or spend a lot more time doing things the traditional way using traditional tools.

I found the DOMINO, which brings loose tenon mortise and tenon joinery to even a beginning woodworker to be a valuable tool. I mentored an absolute novice woodworker through making a floor to ceiling linen cabinet - with raised panel doors. It had to be assembled on site because of its height and the ceiling height.

Everything was put together with loose tenon M&T joinery - except for the slots for the raised panel doors - which were done on the table saw and tuned with a Lee Valley plane made for that purpose. She would never have been able to do this project without the DOMINO. I set it up, showed her how to use it and she did all the rest of the mortise cutting - literally hundreds of them - with maybe five that had to be plugged and recut.

She spent far more time on what was going to show - getting the nicest look out of the boards she bought for the project - and staining - the poplar (she wanted to go with cherry or mahogany - 'til she priced a board foot of that stuff) than she did on cutting all the mortises. The loose tenon M&Ts took care of more than enough structural strength - and allowed assembly on site.

She ended up with a four raised panel doors cabinet that looks nicer than anything she could afford to buy - and it'll last a lot longer. The fact that she made it - with a minimum of help and guidance - priceless. It was 8 or 9 weekends of here time - spread over three months - and they weren't two 8 hour days either - more like 6 to 8 hours spread over Saturday and Sunday.

Now she's wanting to do a bathroom vanity and possibly a small end table or two. Without the DOMINO - and a router table and raised panel bit - her plan would have had to be simplified quite a bit since she rejected pocket screw joinery and flat 1/4" thick ply panels.

Make furniture - or spend time doing hand tool work - because that's enjoyable - and time isn't an issue.

I must admit I was disappointed when she rejected doing some bead details - using a LN beading tool - but I did get here to use the GNT Gordon shave - just a little ; )

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#13

Re: The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

Dean J in MN

>Make furniture - or spend time doing hand tool work - because that's enjoyable - and time isn't an issue.

This comes up quite a bit when there is a conversation comparing hand vs. power work. And it is really a false dichotomy. You can work slow with power tools and you can work quickly with hand tools. It is easy to slip into the trap of looking at it from the two ends of a range of possibilities.

I know from my experience, that I, working by hand, far outproduce some friends who are for lack of better word, Normites. But that too is just turning the same false dichotomy on its end.

Both are paths to a product, if you do this for a living you need to look at the economics of it. And not reject outright hand-only solutions to some problems because "hand work is slow." But also don't fall into the trap that "power tools are faster." Neither are true absolutely.

If you do it for fun -- it makes no difference, do what you like.

-Dean

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#14

Re: The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

charlie belden

>Dean:

When I was talking about the rate at which hand vs power tools operate, it was not in terms of time to do a procedure (edge join a board, flatten a face or create a quarter round edge) the point I was trying to make is that working with hand tools can provide subtle feedback - lacking in some power tool operations.

An analogy might be in a car's steering - rack & pinion steering vs progressive power steering vs ordinary power steering. The first gives you great "feel" but is a royal PITA at low speeds - like parking. Progressive power steering provides most assistance at low speeds and none at higher speeds. Ordinary power steering is great at low speeds, but you lose "feel" at higher speeds.

So when tuning the fit or a drawer or a panel, handtools allow a level of finesse that's almost impossible to attain with a power tool for several reasons - often that you can't easily see what's going on - or where it's taking place.

And the "because it's fun" - for someone who enjoys playing with wood (as opposed to working with wood) time and effort are secondary to the "doing".

For someone who wants a piece of furniture, and has champagne tastes but a beer budget, keeping it "fun" - as the mentor - gets tricky. You want the mentoree to end up with a piece close to what he/she wants, enjoy the making, or at least not have it become an Are We There YET!? experience that'll sour her/him on woodworking, and have a sense of accomplishment - I MADE this (fill in the blank).

In the case of the linen cabinet I described, I gave her the joinery options - Cope & Stick with router bits in a router table, true mortise and tenons using a chisel and bit mortising machine, a horizontal mortising machine, pocket screws - or loose tenon M&Ts cutting the mortises with the DOMINO. I described each method and showed her examples of each. Helped to have a sketch of the piece so she could get a feel of how many she'd be doing. The DOMINO was the best solution - for this person - and, coincidently - for me. But it was her call.

I play with a balancing act. I like the feel of wood - planing, shaving and shaping, scraping or even sanding. I like to feel what had been a not quite smooth area become smooth as a sharp, hand controlled, human speed operated cutting edge brings a surface almost glassy smooth - indistinct details in the wood appearing - pleasing the eye even if just in a tiny way.

But if I've got to bead the corners of the legs of a bonsai display table, and I've got four tables to make, I'll set up a beading router bit in the router table before I'll break out the LN beading tool. One of a kinds - maybe the LN. Four - it's the router table and bit every time. No deadline - I'll use handtools when I can. But if the clock is ticking and someone is waiting for the finished piece . . .

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#15

Re: The hand/power dichotomy is confusing

Dean J in MN

>Charlie --

Just to be clear, I wasn't trying to single you out. I was rather trying to address a common thread when I see these types of conversations take place. I took your quote out of context as a springboard, sorry that wasn't clear.

-Dean

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#16

Well stated Bill!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Blurring The Lines - JointMaker Pro

#17

Well then so's a brace and bit..

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The bit guides itself for the most part. But, otherwise it is a heavily gauged man powered hole making machine.