Re: Am I crazy? I want to sell me table saw
James Watriss
>I'm of two minds on the topic, David.
My background... I went to school for woodworking for two years. I did have a minor table saw accident, which trimmed my left index fingernail, and nailbed. You'd never know, to look at it now. But it definitely woke me up and got rid of a lot of my illusions about how being smart or well trained would protect me.
I'm now one of three guys in a startup professional woodshop. We have my Sawstop cabinet saw (that accident did teach me about the value of safety... the added cost of the saw is worth the peace of mind) a 16" dual arbor Oliver sliding table saw, and a Delta contractor saw with cast iron router tables for extension wings. We use all 3, but the Sawstop and the Oliver are the primary saws. The Ollie definitely gives me the willies... it was the 16" tannewitz at school that nibbled my finger, but man... that saw is an incredibly capable machine.
-The Sawstop is a dream. If you decide that a table saw is something you'd really like to use more, their contractor saw is pricey, but their equipment is overbuilt, and thoughtfully designed. I don't work for them, or any of their vendors... I just really like my saw. BUT, that's an expensive option, and there are other options.
-I hear what the other guys are saying about breaking down plywood and whatnot... but I hate breaking down sheet goods on the table saw. 4x8 sheets are heavy, awkward, backbreaking, nerve wracking, obnoxious things to lift and feed in. In addition to my table saw, I have a Festool track saw. There are other track saws on the market now, but Festool also has a larger version, which I'd consider very strongly if I didn't want to have a table saw anymore. Don't get me wrong, I know this is another expensive option, but for sheet goods, it's a back saver, and a huge space saver. No need for infeed and outfeed, Festool does make a ripping guide now for repeatable cuts, and I've read stories and seen designs of cutting tables that have served a few guys very well. For some of them, it's not only much easier to break plywood down this way, it's much faster. No need to worry about wood that's just too wide for a crosscut sled, or just too wide to use a miter jig... it doesn't really matter. If you visit the Festool Owner's Group website, and look around, there are a lot of guys who do just fine, and things are developing to the point where some of them are making the argument that a table saw is almost not necessary anymore.
Another benefit of the Festool saw, there's no need to have a straight edge to run against your fence. Breaking down live edge stock for straight and square projects is incredibly easy to do, without having to bandsaw, and then joint anything. Just lay the track down and go. Yes, it's expensive if you view it as just another circular saw. But it's not, really. It's a surprisingly accurate piece of serious equipment. And if you're looking to get rid of the table saw but still be able to do certain things... it's worth looking at, and it can be a lot less nerve wracking to use, since it really is a circ saw at heart.
-The bandsaw option. I don't know what size band saw you own. Again, big shop... we have several. I use the 14" powermatic for curvy scrolly work, and the big 18" Laguna for all kinds of stuff. Last weekend I upgraded to the new Laguna guides and their fancy resaw blade with the carbide teeth. I was really knocked sideways by the price, but I was shocked by the cutting ability of the blade. It's the smoothest cutting blade on pretty much any of our tools... the surface it produces is pretty much a glue surface. No jointing or planing necessary, if everything is set up properly. Which leads me to this next point... a band saw can do a LOT of things that a table saw can do, and a few things that it can't. Once I had the Laguna, I learned very quickly that a good steel framed bandsaw is great for breaking down rough lumber. You still have to joint and plane, but once the kickback factor is removed from the equation, it's easy to break down lumber that's a little bit bowed and twisted. I don't think you need the Laguna blade to do most break down work.. but I can tell already that it's going to save me a lot of time since I won't have to joint and plane as much when I'm using this blade.
If you take the time to learn more about how to set up and tune up a band saw, and get to the point where the wood isn't drifting away from the fence on you, you may find that you really don't use that table saw much anymore, if at all. And you may want to consider spending time on better infeed and outfeed support for the band saw. If you're using a 14" saw, a 12" x 12" table to support stock is NOT as easy to work with as a table saw... sometimes.
That said, you can't do dadoes on a band saw, or plunge cuts, or grooves, can't cut rabbets, etc, etc. A decent router can take care of a lot of this, but you get the idea.
----------------------------
My current shop is actually my second shop since I let school. The first one lasted a year. Knowing what I know now, I think if I had to do it all over again, I'm not sure if I'd have the table saw or not. I think it's a very useful tool to have if you're trained on how to use it, and you're comfortable working around it. But it also took up a lot of precious space. Things have progressed to the point where I use my Festool saw and my bandsaw for much more than I was taught to at school, and I'm really becoming aware of the fact that there are a lot of ways to work through any given problem. And really, sometimes it's worth it to sacrifice something just to get the space back.
I think if I had to do it again, I'd probably try to do without the table saw, and stick with a good band saw, and the track saw. 8 feet in front and back of the saw, times 5 or 6 feet to include the extension table, and the cast iron to the let of the blade... the working space required for the table saw comes to around 80 square feet... and that's a lot of room to lose sometimes.
--------------
What you're describing is a healthy fear. It's something I deal with regularly myself... keep the fear alive, man! The injury timeline looks like an inverse bell curve. There are a lot of injuries among new woodworkers who don't know any better, aren't taught any better, and generally lack guidance or experience. Those who make it past that are generally good for a long while, though it's not uncommon to see professionals who are missing a little bit of a finger or two. This can happen on a tablesaw, a router table, a jointer, a sliding miter saw, and a band saw. I've heard of people chopping entire hands off on chop saws... it happens. You HAVE to be careful, and keep your wits about you, and use every ounce of comon sense that you possess. The end of the bell curve is the old timers who have finally gotten a little too comfortable around the saw. The three inch rule turns into the 3 inch suggestion, fingers get closer, or the unexpected happens... statistically speaking, the longer you work with power tools, the more opportunities you have for something bad to happen. But again, it could happen with almost any tool.
If you've never taken a class on table saw safety and proper usage, it's very worthwhile to look into that. I'd start there. Find a local tech school, woodworking club, trade school... any place that has a legitimate training program. Once you learn how to properly use the saw, and learn more about safety features and possible aftermarket safety things, you may decide that practice makes perfect, and you'll have an easier time using it. But learn from a professional instructor, not from a contractor friend.
I've seen contractors that really don't know their way around the saw, and still manage to survive, but I have no idea how. And many people learn from a friend who learned on the job and never got the serious and for-real safety lecture. There are issues with large cabinet saws that you don't have with contractor's saws, and issues with contractor saws that you don't get with the benchtop models. Once you take the class, you should be in a better position to make up your mind. Benchtop models can jam up pretty easily. Contractor saws can jam up, but once in a while they might throw something at you if you're not careful. A 5hp 12" saw will throw things through you if you're cocky and inexperienced... and some guys make the upgrade from a bench top model to a much bigger saw, without understanding what they're getting into.
There are may ways to skin a cat, Dave. I suppose you could even use a table saw to skin one. I wouldn't recommend it, but you could do it.
If you decide to sell your saw, I'd look around and see what to replace it with. The guys are right... a saw that it bought, sold and paid for is a good thing to have. But if you're not comfortable with it, and it's really been eating at you, my suspicion is that it will start to affect the way you approach the saw, and that may lead to bad practices, too. Peace of mind is worth having, I think. And the truth of the matter is that a contractor's saw is just big enough that it really does claim a significant chunk of the available shop space for its own. There's no way around that. You can shove it into a corner, but even then... contractor saws are pretty big. It's a lot of tool to keep around if you're not using it, because you're not comfortable using it.
On the other hand, if you decided to take the plunge, and sold your table saw for a newer, upgraded band saw, or a track saw, you'll get the space back, regain a little peace of mind, and maintain the ability to do meaningful work. But be aware... this is not the time to sell tools. They go for pennies on the dollar now, and you'll have a hard time getting a lot of money back on it.
It's a lot to digest. I think I'd have a hard time with that kind of decision, too. Start with looking for a class if you haven't taken one. Also, take the time to get to know your band saw better, and see how you feel about using it as your primary saw.