Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Posts

Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#1

Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

wilbur

>...or why I like Japanese saws.

I got the legs cut down to size last night. I took some photos showing how I did this, because it shows why I like using Japanese saws so much. This is probably old hat for a lot of you, I know, but I was having fun with this.

These legs are about 5-1/4" square, and I'm using a 270 mm single edged Japanese saw with a disposable blade. This saw is probably a bit too small for this type of cut, but it was the biggest one I had. ;)

First, mark the lines for the cut.


There are two ways that I've made this cut. The first way is to make a cut, going around the leg as you go. I start the cut on the near corner of the leg, and saw, trying to hit both lines at once.


When I get about halfway down, I rotate the leg so that the part I was cutting is away from me. Then I saw along the top line, using the kerf as a guide.


Sawing straight across is very easy, as the pull cut action automatically tenses the blade. Some people complain that the pull cut also throws sawdust on the line, obscuring it. This is true, but once the cut is started, I am no longer looking at where the saw is cutting. Instead, I'm looking at where I want to end up. Remember, the pull action will keep the saw straight.

Then, I angle down the front of the leg. Again, I am looking at where I want the cut to end.


I continue this around the leg, and eventually you finish cutting through the middle.


The advantage of this method is that you can completely support the piece on the table, since you aren't cutting straight through the piece. Instead, you're going around the perimeter, eventually cutting through the middle. The downside is that if you look closely at the cut surface, you can see that you came at different angles, and it's hard to leave a perfectly smooth cut surface. Since this will eventually be tenons, I don't really care. ;)

The second way is the one that I use more often. Here I start at the far side of the line, and saw across the top.



Then, I continue down the side, eventually cutting all the way through.



Again, I'm just looking at where the cut will end, not where the saw is actually cutting. Since the saw is under tension while cutting, it's easy to follow a straight line. Here's the back side of this cut. I didn't look at this side at all until I took this picture.


Not bad, if I do say so myself. Eventually you'll cut all the way through.


The advantage with this technique is that the sawn surface is smoother, since you're coming at it from one direction. The downside is that it takes a little practice to get the technique down. Also, since you're going straight through, the cutoff needs to be supported as you get to the end of the cut, which was a little difficult due to the size of the cutoff. But once you have the technique down, it's like riding a bike. And just to be clear, I don't think I have any particular talent at sawing. I do think using a Japanese saw is this easy.

Besides, my understanding that the real way to do this is to start at the top near corner and cut straight through. I'm not that good. :@)

Next up: cutting the tenons.

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#2

isn't there a band saw next door to this need?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#3

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Nice tutorial, Wilbur.

I've used both techniques with western saws, with similar results.

I picked up a ryoba, of the disposable blade/two cutting edge flavor, last summer at a garage sale, and, for a variety of reasons, have had almost no opportunity to use it. I'll be interested to experiment with it, and see what I've been missing.

Part of me is nervous about getting converted, though - what would I do with the 50+ western saws hanging from my shop's ceiling joists like steel vampire bats?

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#4

Re: willing to help, send em to me....

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#5

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

Part of me is nervous about getting converted, though - what would I do with the 50+ western saws hanging from my shop's ceiling joists like steel vampire bats?

Send them to me....

Marv

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#6

This group's generosity and helpfulness is great!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#7

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

MikeW

>Very nice Wilbur.

fwiw, I think two things. One is that you do not allow yourself enough credit for your ability to saw. This is the main fwiw. Two is that it really doesn't matter which type of saw (west/east) is used.

I prefer the second method.

Take care, Mike

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#8

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Raney

>Very nice work Wilbur. I agree completely with Mike's sentiments. I've lately been doing a lot of work with ryoba, trying to increase my proficiency with them, and I've been doing a lot of thinking about western vs. eastern saws.

With one very specific exception, I've yet to find anything that I couldn't get equally fine results at with either western or eastern saws - in the long run it's all about proficiency.

...and I think your saw skills have a lot more to do with this than you're admitting. Getting such clean results, with no wandering at the rear of the cut (and with a saw that's undersized for the work) is much more a function of the sawyer than the saw. Take a little credit, man ;)

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#9

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

MikeW

>To continue the tag-team backslapping Raney and I are apparently doing, Wilbur, I will lightly explain...

One of the hardest skills to master for a sawyer is patience. Couple that with understanding the saw in use.

In your cutting with an under-sized saw, you demonstrate patience in not pushing the saw beyond that which it is capable of. You understand the saw and its abilities.

If you pushed that saw beyond its capabilities--if you didn't demonstrate your patience--the cut would have wandered. You would have needed to correct the cut at some point. With an Eastern saw, forcing the cut often results in a cup within the cut. Once the plate progresses past or into this cupping within the cut, the leading and/or the trailing edges of the cut will want to deviate. This is easily seen on a band saw--the ultimate powered pull saw.

On a western hand saw, the problem begins to show at the leading edge of the cut. This is due to the saw plate rippling behind the point of entry. The problem with correcting this effect improperly is correction can cause the trailing edge of such a deep, wide cut to go astray. And then the cut needs cleaned up more than it should.

The main correction begins with that which you demonstrate: Patience in not pushing the saw and understanding the saw in use.

In both those respects, you demonstrate great proficiency.

Take care, Mike

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#10

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Dean J in MN

>Besides, my understanding that the real way to do this is to start at the top near corner and cut straight through. I'm not that good. :@)

I'd say that the thought that starting at the top near corner and cutting straight through is the "real way" is a common misunderstanding. What you did shows your understanding of how to saw. That it was a Western/Eastern saws make little (no) difference in my mind. Either way, you follow two lines as long as you can and use existing kerfs when you can. What you illustrated is what you would see me do for any crosscut that was important. I happen to push my saw, but advance on two lines and rotate the stock and use the existing kerf to continue the cut on track.

Nice job by the way!

-Dean

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#11

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Chicago Bob

>Wilbur,

Your workbench adventure and write-up feels like the old time radio serials with anticipation for next week's show!

I would hope that when this grand bench is finished that you would consolidated all of the discussions into one article. The photos are very good and helpful. Continue to have fun and I will stay tuned for the next addition.

Thanks

Bob Haines

Chicago Bob heading back to East Tennessee for retirement!

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#12

Alls I can say Wilbur is...

Stuart Hough

>WOW! I am impressed! You should give yourself more credit. you have the patience of a saint...at least when it comes to sawing (sawyering?). Kudos to you for the end result, and thanx in a big way for the post!

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#13

And, you got it done backwards!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#14

Re: isn't there a band saw next door to this need?

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

Actually, there's a bandsaw within a foot of where I was sawing. :@)

But the problem with using a bandsaw is that given the size of my bandsaw table, I would have to either:

1. Hold up 24" of essentially a 20/4 timber hanging off the table in midair while trying to cut straight, or

B. Build myself a support stand just for this cut, which I would need a workbench for, which is what these legs are for, hence a Catch-22.

Sawing by hand turned out to be the easiest solution. It only took me 3-4 minutes to make the cut.

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#15

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

wilbur

>Thanks for the compliments -- that really gave me a warm fuzzy feeling that I needed today.

Maybe it's just me, but not pushing the saw just seems to be the natural thing to do. There were times when the saw was slowing down, most notably if I was at a stage where I was cutting across the diagonal at its widest point. When this happened, I just adjusted the angle of the cut so that the saw was cutting more freely. This came very naturally, as I am a pretty lazy guy at heart. :@)

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#16

Lazy

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It's my opinion, gained from 34 years developing software, that it's the lazy people who do the best, most innovative work. There must be something in the process of trying to determine why you don't have to do anything that allows one to derive the most elegant solutions.

Pam

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#17

Indeed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Band saws would be a much more used tool if they came with larger tables.

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#18

But harder to fit in the shop

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#19

Re: Indeed

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>When I read Wilbur's great response last night, I recalled a pile of red oak 12X12 timbers we once had to cut to length. Some were to be 16 feet, others were to be 25 feet long. Not really band saw material. I still have a few of the cutoffs and used them last summer as blocking for a 21X22X 13' white oak mantle. That stick would have made about five nice Roubo benches. And a lot easier to cut with a handsaw than to try to move it to a machine.

Wilbur, thanks again for letting me try your saw at the Philadelphia Workshop. I had never used a Japanese saw before.

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#20

Re: NOT Lazy

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>It isn't laziness that fuels innovation and elegant solutions; but often it is a desire to not waste effort on anything that is boring and pointless. Some observers can't see past the "don't waste effort" part and so attach the label "lazy" to some of the most creative thinkers around.

Fortunately, there are a few so called "lazy" creative people here at WoodCentral.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#21

Re: Indeed

Raney

>Warren,

I did not realize you'd made it to the philadelphia event - I'd really liked to have met you. I'd be really interested to know what your thoughts on the Ryoba were, especially given the sorts of work you do, and the amount of time you've been working with western tools...

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#22

Japanese saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I'm not a very good person to evaluate a Japanese saw. Yesterday I was sawing with a Disston saw that I first used as a young boy in 1955. It would take quite a long time for me to give the Ryoba a fair evaluation and to be able to find and take advantage of its strengths. I do think the Disston saws were designed for carpenters and in that way are not as good as some made today which are more delicate.

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#23

Re: NOT Lazy

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Well, yeah, but you've got to use the language that's understood.

Pam

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#24

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wilbur,

I'm impressed with your sawing skills. Nice work.

I'm curious about the size of the legs. Why so large? Seems that about a 4" to 4-1/2" square leg would be plenty sturdy enough.

I like how you were careful with back to back grain orientation.

How do you plan to finish the floor end of the leg? Will you include some kind of adjustments for leveling or stabilizing?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

#25

Re: Cutting BIG workbench legs to length...

wilbur

>Hi Marv,

Thanks for the compliment! The bench is going to be a Roubo design, which means it has a leg vise. Tradition and the plans I'm working off of calls for wide legs. I actually have some 4x4's that I milled up for legs, figuring that the actual width didn't matter much, until I saw the leg and realized that in addition to supporting the bench, the leg also serves as a clamping surface, so that the width does contribute to that function. So that's why I made up these wider legs.

I'm not going to do much more with the end of the legs other than to chamfer the corners. I won't have leveling devices -- if I have to, I'll stick some wedges under the legs to account for the unevenness of the floor in my shop.