Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Bevel up or down Smoother

Posts

Bevel up or down Smoother

#1

Bevel up or down Smoother

Wayne

>Trying to decide on a new plane I need a Smoother and cannot decide on the Veritas bevel up or bevel down. Can anybode tell me the difference and which you wood purchase.

Wayne

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#2

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother *LINK*

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi Wayne,

This can be found widely covered here in achieves on a search using your title for your post.

I have both myself, depening on the application, but the link here may help..

Take care,

Jim


Chris Schwarz....You Tube Bevel up, vs Down

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#3

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wayne

The answer may be as simple or as complex as you are prepared to make it.

Here is the simple answer ...

The Veritas bevel up smoother (BUS) is, for its price, the best performing smoother on the market, bar none. There, that is a declaritive statement. I must qualify this before going further. I am referring to its ability to smooth the surface of the gnarliest woods you can throw at it. To do this the plane must cut with a high angle, say 60 degrees. The BUS has the capacity to use a very high cutting angle. I have high angle (60 degree) bevel down smoothers, but angle-for-angle, BU smoothers are easier to push than BD smoothers.

Here is the more complex answer ...

If you are a woodworker that prefers to freehand sharpen blades, one that has an antipathy for honing guides, then don't walk but run past the BUS and head for a BD smoother. To use a BU smoother you will need to use a honing guide to obtain the high bevel angles typically needed (commonly 38 degrees for a 50 degree cutting angle and 50 degrees for a 62 degree cutting angle - I tend to leave my BUS on the latter setting). These are created by adding a secondary bevel to a 25 degree primary bevel. You cannot create them with a hollow grind and hone freehand. It is not practical. On the other hand, if you are happy to use a honing guide, then the BUS may be the magic you are looking for.

I have a number of BU and BD smoothers. I prefer honing blades freehand. BD planes make this the method of choice for me, so I will use them as much, or more, than the BU planes, especially when the wood is uncomplicated. However, when the wood grain is gnarly and I am making the money shot, then I reach for a BU smoother. Every time. If you are someone that favours a honing guide, then it is a no-brainer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#4

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

ThomD

>I also think the LV BU planes are better than their BD planes.

I actually come to the opposite conclusion to Derek on the sharpening side. If I am freehanding, I prefer a larger bevel, and the Bu one I have has a thicker blade. I made a thicker single blade for my BD so that's a wash at the same angle for either one. I haven't had any difficulty using any standard plane blade in a jig, when I want to.

I wouldn't personally shy away from a better plane design because of sharpening issues. If there are issues, I can imagine that would be important to some. I just haven't run into issues. I do prefer the ease of getting a BU in and out, no subblade,etc..., though as I mentioned I got around that with a mono blade in the BD.

Another BU advantage is that for a given adjust screw pitch the depth adjust is finer on a BU.

Also if you like an adjustible mouth (not personally), a well executed block plane mouth that adjust without compromising bedding, is more practical.

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#5

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

Ted

>I agree that sharpening the wide bevel on a "normal" bevel of the LV BU Smoother is easier than on a thinner blade. I think that what Derek was cautioning the OP about was the difficulty of hand holding the blade for sharpening at high bevel angles of 50 degrees or so. I agree with Derek on this point. It's a lot easier to freehand sharpen a low angle bevel consistently than a high angle bevel.

Ted

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#6

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

ThomD

>I also think the LV BU planes are better than their BD planes.

I actually come to the opposite conclusion to Derek on the sharpening side. If I am freehanding, I prefer a larger bevel, and the Bu one I have has a thicker blade. I made a thicker single blade for my BD so that's a wash at the same angle for either one. I haven't had any difficulty using any standard plane blade in a jig, when I want to.

I wouldn't personally shy away from a better plane design because of sharpening issues. If there are issues, I can imagine that would be important to some. I just haven't run into issues. I do prefer the ease of getting a BU in and out, no subblade,etc..., though as I mentioned I got around that with a mono blade in the BD.

Another BU advantage is that for a given adjust screw pitch the depth adjust is finer on a BU.

Also if you like an adjustible mouth (not personally), a well executed block plane mouth that adjust without compromising bedding, is more practical.

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#7

Re: Agreed

ThomD

>I agree with that, though that would be a very high angle of what, 62 degrees? With any other LV smoother you would be in double bevel territory which would be even worse, depending on what one likes or doesn't like. At least with the BU you would have the option of having a blade prepped for that angle, which is getting to a whole other area of the versatility of these planes.

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#8

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I actually come to the opposite conclusion to Derek on the sharpening side. If I am freehanding, I prefer a larger bevel, and the Bu one I have has a thicker blade. I made a thicker single blade for my BD so that's a wash at the same angle for either one.

Hi Thom

My thesis is that one must approach sharpening BU planes differently to BD planes. The issues will create frustrations for those that do not attempt to do so.

There are two basic conditions that place one in the "at risk" category here. These are ..

(1) You wish to freehand sharpen high angle BU blades, and ...

(2) You wish to add a fine camber to a bevel with a high angle (this becomes progressively more difficult as you approach a bevel of 50 degrees).

None of this applies if you do not camber the bevel.

I describe how to camber a BU blade in my article, The Secret to Cambering Bevel Up Plane Blades. This in on my website:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html

The other issue deals with stropping a blade, either BU or BD. The article I wrote was for the FWW blog, A Sharpening Strategy: beyond a sharp edge.

http://finewoodworking.taunton.com/item/8521/a-sharpening-strategy-beyond-a-sharp-edge

I look forward to all comments.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#9

Why Veritas?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'm just curious...

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#10

Just like em

Wayne Carson

>

Re: Bevel up or down Smoother

#11

Thanks Wayne!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>