Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Squaring up plane irons

Posts

Squaring up plane irons

#1

Dale Lenz

Squaring up plane irons

Dale Lenz

>Once every year or two I notice my irons are out of square. In years past I turn my screaming belt sander up side down and grind the iron square. container of water near by. Any one else have other ideas?

TIA

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Dedicated square

Jim in Burlington On

>I have a dedicated square for my sharpening kit. That way I don't have to worry about it getting dirty. Checking often when sharpening will help you keep from going off course. Hollow ground irons are also easier to square up than irons off the sander.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#3

Re: Squaring up plane irons

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Nearly every time I sharpen, I hold the blade up to the light right quick before sharpening, check the camber, and judge if it is creeping up higher on one side than the other. It jumps out at you against backlighting, so I don't use a square. If it's getting higher on one side, I bias the sharpening to that side. The only irons I check with a square are shoulder plane blades.

With Japanese blades, the sides angle in so you have to eyeball it (or do something complicated). I had an insane sharpening session for about 15 minutes maybe 10 years ago, before I figured out that there ain't nothing square on a Japanese iron.

Wiley

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#4

Re: Squaring up plane irons

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I square up plane irons on a stone.

Orient the iron so it is vertical on the stone, edge down. Incline the iron a degree or two toward you and pull the iron across the stone. While doing this apply most or all of the down force on the high side of the iron. Check frequently with a square.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#5

Waste of time

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have often read that the edge of a plane iron has to be "perfectly square". This is not true. Most planes have a mechanism whereby one can adjust the angle of the iron so that it cuts evenly on both sides. About ten years ago I retired a plane iron that had 3/16" left to the hole. I had used it from brand new to almost unusable, never having used a grinder on it and never having "squared it up".

If you sharpen an iron on stones only like this, you will find that you tend to favor one side. A little compensation each time you sharpen will keep the iron within the bounds that the plane can accommodate.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#6

Depends

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>On my Lie-Nielsen 62 there's no room to skew an out-of-square iron. Agreed, squareness is not critical on Bailey-type planes.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Thanks, folks,

Dale Lenz

>guess checking for square is something else I need to do while sharpening my irons. Correct a small degree of out of square is easier than a lot, : ' >. Sharpening plane irons is not my favorite part of the job, but realize the importance of it. As I tell my boys...attitude is everything, : " > Thanks and welcome any other's input. Dale

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#8

Re: Squaring up plane irons

Mark in Texas

>I also have done the belt sander thing. I usually don't use water. The plane iron doesn't feel very hot, and never turns colors, so it seemed to me that it wasn't negatively impacting the metallurgy. Am I missing something?

Mark

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: I have a time or two...

Dale Lenz

>seen a bright red glow on my iron's edge, I'm thinking that's a no no, besides my fingers tell me when the iron is getting hot, : ' >. Should have blacken fingers' tips before shop lights are turn off for the night.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: Word of caution...

Dale Lenz

>to any body that tries grinding metal on a sander: clean the sander out well. Told my cousin once about the above and he looked over at his floor mounted sander after grinding and it was smoking.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#11

Re: Squaring up plane irons

ThomD

>Normally it has to turn blue to draw the temper, though for some tools straw yellow is too much. Also the oxide change only shows what the heat was like on the surface. I have been lucky the odd time in my early career, when I hit the blade hard, yet it was not changed. HSS doesn't care if you get it extremely hot. Any colour change is really grinding too agressively on a hardened iron in my view. I dip blades in water sometimes, and re-dip when they have dried out. That is a very visual clue to the iron heating up only mildly, and yet you can get a lot of grinding done that way.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#12

Re: Squaring up plane irons

ThomD

>One thing to do is to do all the grinding square at a 90 degree angle. This will leave you with a square edge, but a lopsided bevel. Then grind the bevel so it is sharp. That is good shop practice, and will reduce the chance of burning the steel. If you try to grind back the edge without first blunting it, you do not have the mass present as a heat sink to save the edge. Of course care is required whichever way you do it.

Re: Squaring up plane irons

#13

Dale Lenz

Re: 7 planes ready to go

Dale Lenz

>Pull the old belt sander down and did a little bit of grinding on my worse iron, 07 Hock. Got most of the iron square, went to hand lapping on my blue diamond stone using side lapping technique, got two bloody finger from lapping fingers, denatured alcohol does burn, : ' >. Still like maybe an 1/8" of the total length of the edge to get if square. Figured I'll gradually get it square with sharpening in the future, spent way to much time, 1.5 hours +, @#$%! Other irons took 10 min. or so each. Shot 8 feet of square edges and called it quit for the night, too tired now to work, : ' >. Calls for a Jack and Coke and a nice hot shower.

Thanks to everyone that volunteered their assistance. Dale