Re: Abrasive Comparison Chart *LINK*
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I think that anybody who actually used these various media will realize the futility of making this kind of comparison. As an example of how misleading this chart can be, consider three stones which I use. The Queer Creek stone (now marketed as Clear Creek) is listed in the same range as the 1200 Japanese water stone. In practice the Japanese stone is considerably finer. The Washita stone is much finer than either, but is listed as much coarser than the other two. I could get a good edge going from Queer Creek to 1200 to Washita, but you would never know it from the chart.
In addition, different people will get different results from a stone depending on their technique. This is illustrated nicely by these pictures from Zowada razor which David Barnett brought to our attention a couple years ago.
Razor Bevels