We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Took an unofficially adopted niece and a friend to the Winchester Mystery House up the roadfrom home. Actually I went in with them to pay for the tour tickets and while hanging around before the tour started wandered through one of their mini-museums - this one of flashlights and hand tools.
Was surprised to see cast iron body hand planes - which looked like the familiar Bailey/Stanley planes, but with Winchester in embossed letters on the lever cap.
Anyone know how long Winchester made hand planes - and when?
Bill, whose only connection with Winchester is having one Winchester chisel, awaiting a handle...well, and, like a lot of little kids from my era, being just flat fascinated by their rifle design.
>For a time, Stanley made Winchester's planes using the roundside Bedrock design. These planes are identifiable as having a "W" and the plane size (e.g., W 5) cast into the toe. Unlike the Keen Kutter-branded Bedrocks of the same period, which have a blank lever cap, I believe the Winchester planes of this vintage have the Winchester logo cast into the lever cap and painted Winchester red (not totally sure about the lever cap logo part).
The Bedrock type study linked below says that these Winchester-branded Bedrocks were Bedrock type 3, dating to 1908-1910. That site also says that the Winchester Bedrocks were made in sizes 3 to 7, don't know about half sizes.
It seems odd that a company with the primary business of making hand planes oact as a sub contractor to manufacture a product identical to their flagship products except for the name changes for other companies.
Learn something new everyday - but this one's surprising.
>As I understand it, all the major companies - Stanley, Sargent, Millers Falls, probably Union too - made planes for other companies with the company logos on them. This was true not just of the "hardware" brands, like Winchester and Keen Kutter, but of Sears, Montgomery Ward, etc.
And not just planes. I've got a little backsaw etched with the Charles Strelinger (I think that's right - saw in shop, brain in Timbuktu) logo with a handle indistinguishable from a Disston handle - and probably made by Disston. Strelinger was an East Coast hardware store.
I've always loved the gently sarcastic British phrase for this: "badge engineering." The British used to make a lot of new brands of cars by slapping logos (which the British called then, and may still, badges) on existing cars. For instance, Morris Garages made Morrises and MGs that way, and, after they acquired Austin, Austins as well. The late MG Midget/Austin-Healey Sprite were identical but for the logos, for instance.
>I can see the point, why would they make their product for someone else? My stuff, my reputation, better than generic, etc, etc.
On the other hand, it means it's a batch that is already sold. It's a pretty decent sized order, I'm sure stanley's brand name sales weren't hurt by it... and really, it's sales for them either way. In the event that a trend emerges that people think the winchester planes are better than Stanley, well... I guess that's still more sales for Stanley.
I have a feeling that management's hearing perked up at "we have an order..." and then was less interested when they heard "...but they are going to be red."
Personally, I think it would also have been a good test bed for any new ideas. If they fail, hey, it's a Winchester plane. Stanley planes are still good, though.
I can think of examples in bicycle manufacturing today where a well known company had a spin off that was made slightly differently, with subtle tweaks that lay just off the conservative path that the main company was taking. The flagship brand name is insulated, and the new ideas can be tested.
>I have seen it written that the tools made for other labels were often made with name-brand-specific features missing, although I'd be hard pressed to see any difference between, say, a Sargent fenced double rabbet (like the Stanley No. 78) and the Sears Craftsman version made by Sargent.
This may not be the best example, because this tool is about as basic as you could get - not many features to remove.
But even the Dunlap and Craftsman planes I own are pretty respectable tools, and the Wards Master No. 4 I own can hold its head up in any Bailey-style plane gathering.
>Perhaps it's the design specs and the QC is what may distinguish the Stanley brand name planes from those Stanley made to be sold under other brand names. I know that Stanley made a line of hand planes for carpenters and one for furniture makers. Furniture makers needed "flatter", "square sides" and tighter mouth than the carpenters. The time and effort to get the former over the time and effort to get the latter justified different price points - and expectations.
You CAN put in the time and effort to turn a "tradesman" model to a "furniture maker" model - but just flattening the sole can take FOREVER.
>What is often overlooked is that the "Bed Rocks" stanley made for Winchester were thier obsolite older round top design. Winchester didn't enter the hardware / plane market till 1920 by which time Stanley had been making the improved flat top bed rock for almost 10 years so what winchester got was the old design. I often wonder if the only reason some winchester planes are the old bed rock style is that Stanley had lots of round top frogs they needed to get rid of.
After WWI Winchester had planes to get into the hardware bussiness in a BIG way, wasn't going to a side line but they hoped it to become thier main bussiness. Bought up companys as well as retooled to make lots of the stuff they planned on selling...not all was made by some other tool company for them for example Winchester made thier own chisels.
Winchester had this plan of opening up hardware stores that were only allowed to sell winchester items in effect having a monopoly.Once this became evident they did have trouble with some tool makers, namely Sargent, that wasn't keen to supply tools to a company that was in bussiness to put them out of bussiness. Winchester had lots of trouble with this idea of a Winchester Store and in 1922 merged with Simmons [of Keen Kutter fame] which was probably the largest hardware store in the USA. They then sold Winchester marked items....This lasted only till 1929 when winchester was re organized and got out of the hardware bussiness.
Winchester net worth went from 22 1/2 million to only 8 million during the time they were in the hardware bussiness. Winchester probably actually made money on thier tool line but lost money big time on expensive things like washing machines and fridges. Finaly got smart and cut back and stuck to what they were known for...Guns
I always wondered if there were ever any talk at Stanley about making or selling guns. Think about it...Stanley made lots of stuff had access to hardware stores and you would think they would be the perfect company to make and sell guns too....OH well...it would be neat to have a Stanley pistol now wouldn't it?.....Todd