Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

Posts

I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#1

I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Bronze back and split-nuts, mother of perl inlays in handle, .025" 1095 spring steel, 12" long blade, with 14 ppi xcut teeth.

Dedicated to and in memory of Lance McCollum, 1958 - 2009, The LM-51 Pro.


img

Dedication and blog entry w/gallery

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#2

Nice

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You left out mentioning the lovely wood used for the handle.

Great way to honor a friend.

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#3

Curly Olive!

Alan DuBoff

>Or so it had more curl before finishing, but it still has some.:-)

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#4

Very nice saw Alan. A question...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Why is the outside edges of the handle so sharp?

Nice piece of work. Thanks for sharing.

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#5

Re: I made this saw for a friend...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan,

I'm sure that custom saw will always evoke for your friend the old days surfing with friends. The wood is just grand. Course, so is that amazing quartered ebony board right behind it!

Alan, when did you get interested in making saws? And why saws, as opposed to some other tool? I ask, because I love saws too.

Wiley

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#6

Not exactly sure why, it just is...:-)

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

I'm not sure why I do handles like that, a few have some sharp aspects to them. I tend to think in flat and/or round, but if you look at the design of this handle, the sides which are flat remain flat for most of the side. IOW, under the tongue, it is flat on the bottom, and that continue to the step and bottom flat of the handle, wrapping around. The top flat is flat along the entire top, down to the handle mortise. I do keep those 2 sections flat with sharp corners on purpose, but can't tell you why exactly...just that I like to keep the flat and round separate from each other.

The grip and inside of the handle are rounded, and stay round, in a similar way that the flat stays flat, again, I'm not sure why...:-/

The front chamfer is done with a spokeshave, and a different texture, most of my original designs have used a unique chamfer on the edge of the cheek in a similar way, but on this one I tried to keep the cheek a tad triangular. The chamfers and front edge of the cheek are not sanded, just shaved. Most of the rounds are rasped and sanded after.

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#7

Saws are some of my favorites...

Alan DuBoff

>Wylie,

That ebony will transform into some saw handles soon, hopefully! :-)

I have some ivory that I will be inlaying to the ebony. I got it from a friend who owns a guitar/music store, he gave me some pieces off old guitars and such.

Good question on the saws...it all started back a few years ago when trying to figure out what to craft for a Galootaclaus gift over on the oldtools list. I pondered, and figured I could make a saw by getting an 8" Crown Gent's saw, and cutting the handle off, and crafting a handle of my own for it. That saw was given to a another galoot...this was before Mike Wenzloff was making saws, and LN and Adria were the primary players, and Vlad Spehar was making saws.

There are more saws being produced today, of western style. I actually do admire the Japanese saws (and tools), and have been thinking about forging a Japanese saw of my own, possibly, and scrape it like has been done traditionally.

The newer slotted backsaws are much sexier than the older counter parts (talking western), not to mention that from the later part of the 19th century, and up to the middle of the 20th century, the quality of handsaws continued to be more and more process oriented. One can argue that slotting the back is done with modern mills, but that is yet but one component of making a saw. While a handsaw is fairly simple, it's not easy to get them together with clean fit/finish. I am just getting to the stage where the fit/finish has gotten good enough to be proud of.

All of this led me down the path to use better materials, and to me, bronze is clearly superior to brass. This is mainly due to a few basic reasons, strength being one factor, color being another, but the immunity to dezincification (yes, that is actually a word;-) being the primary one.

My friend I'm giving the saw to built the cabinets in my kitchen, which was gutted after a fire. He does high end cabinet work (although mine is fairly moderate), and he wanted a saw to cut moulding and cabinet carcasses when he builds/installs. My cabinets he made for me are basic craftsman frame/panel with stile/rail type m&t construction, but the crown molding is a 4 piece that is one of the more complicated he's done. AFAIK, me and his parents are the only ones that have this molding, he built them at the same time. I've known his parents for 40 years. After our friend Lance McCollum passed, it seemed like a good time to make one for Ken Neill, I want him to use it and know that it was handcrafted by a friend, in memory of another. He is mostly into veneers nowadays, but the molding and carcasses require trimming, hence the xcut.

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#8

Re: I made this saw for a friend...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Alan

My condolensces for the loss of your dear friend. The dedication to him will no doubt make this gift even more special.

This is a beautiful saw. I like the way you have been seeking to express your art through saw designs. It seems to have become a vehicle for some of late, but I have been watching your progress since your first attempt that must go back about three years - I remember well that Crown gent saw that you transformed with a pistol tote of burr wood for a Galootclaus gift.

This ones reminds me of Federal style furniture.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#9

Yeah, quite a bit evolved over the past few years!

Alan DuBoff

>Derek,

Yeah, quite a bit has evolved since making that first saw, and in all honesty it was a very smart place to start. For the average person, getting the working plate with a back on it makes it very easy. That saw was selected as it very closely matched a Disston 70, which I have a few of. I believe size/weight/balance have something to do with each saw, but it seems something that many makers search for, in some cases forever...That saw was made for Galootaclaus 2005.

Fast forward to today, and this saw I just finished. It is entirely crafted from raw materials that are commonly available. And it uses materials not commonly used in the crafting of handsaws (bronze) and I would like to think some expression with the inlay. I have had several ideas with inlays that I would like to try and see which ones work and/or which ones don't.

Clearly for some, art expression is a piece of the puzzle, and for others it is not. I see similar expression in your own tools and actually something I admire about your work.;-)

It is important to understand that, which I think we both do, that to some the combination of art expression in regards to tools is foreign...and rightfully so...we are all different and have different likes and dislikes.

As my son often says, "it's all good".:-)

As always, thanks for the kind words...the Federal Period is quite an interesting comment, some things are too ornate for me in that period, but there are certain aspects I think I like. Certainly some great inlay work out of that period.

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#10

Thanks Alan, I can explane why...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It's all about ergonomics. The human hand when grasping an object to use as a tool or such tends to grasp a handle, what ever tighter by the fingrrs using the palm of the habd as rest/pivot point for balance.

Now for something you'll realy enjoy...

Take the hand you hold a saw with and mimic the grasp you would have on a saw handle... Now look down top of your hand, through it like your the handle...

See, your fingers are curved more than your thumb is. See how there's a flat spot between your thumb and index finger (that spot we all fear of cutting).

It's pretty flat yes? No?

Anyway that the reason you don't round them off.

They don't need to be.

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#11

I'm not sure I fully follow you...

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

I'm not sure I understand completely what you describe, but I do see the flat spot between the thumb and forefinger, that however seems like the section that rests up against the rounded section on the back of the handle. I round the entire inside between the horns on the outer rear, as well as all around for the inside grip also.

But maybe you are taking about the sharp line where the round/flat meet for the side of the grip and rear rounded portion? That line, if what you refer to, is VERY hard to keep straight/clean, IMO. Requires a certain finesse to keep that crisp.

I have 2 more saws I started to make, and trying to get them finished before I take a hiatus from my saw making for a couple months. I'm about to embark on what I consider to be one of the ultimate woodworking projects...a Appalachian style log home, using large white oak timbers. I'll be flying back east for a couple months to work on it with a wonderful craftsman that I truly consider to be a master, Tim Bullock. A real honor to be able to build a home with his assistance for my family, and a unique opportunity that he is willing to help me with.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: I made this saw for a friend... *LINK*

#12

I'm not sure I fully follow you, me either Alan...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'll try to 'splain. The rounds I was talking about we're pointed to the shape of the handle but, the rounding of the top flat edges rockin' your handle shape.

I questioned why you make your handles the way you do. After a bit of study, I answered my own question...

Very nicely done handles sir!