Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

question on making new handle

Posts

question on making new handle

#1

question on making new handle

-e-

>How to build a new chisel handle:

1) how do i get the old out without destroying it (want to use it as template)

2)other than oak, other good woods for handles?

3)how to secure new handle -- glue?


img

Re: question on making new handle

#2

Re: question on making new handle 

-e-

>


img

Re: question on making new handle

#3

Re: question on making new handle

-e-

>

Re: question on making new handle

#4

Re: question on making new handle 

-e-

>


img

Re: question on making new handle

#5

Re: question on making new handle

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>You wrote:

"1) how do i get the old out without destroying it (want to use it as template)"

That's a socket chisel you got there e and typically the friction fit of the taper was all the was used to hold the handle in place. I would hold the chisel in a wood vice (sandwiched between some scrap to protect the jaws) and then get a vice grip or pliers and twist the old handle off. If it;s glued, a judicious application of heat may work.

As far as using the old handle as a template, it looks like the same style as the ones I have. Here's a drawing I made to help me make my handles. it's based off of an old Wards Masters Chisel that felt great to hold. It also looks a lot like the new ones on LN Chisels.

Drawing of "typical" Handle:

Photobucket

You wrote:

"2)other than oak, other good woods for handles?"

I used bubinga. But any straight grained hard, dense hardwood works. Dogwood, Hickory, Ash, Hornbeam, Apple and White oak were typically used.

Sample of handles in Bubinga

Photobucket

You wrote:

"3)how to secure new handle -- glue?"

Like I mentioned above, the taper fit is all that is "typically" used. And that's how I made em'. But I've known people to epoxy the handles in place.

I hope this helps

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: question on making new handle

#6

Don't glue it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You want the handle to get driven further and further into the socket with use. Glue would get in the way.

I've removed dead handles as Dominic suggests, though I've reversed the process, clamping the handle in a (metal/machinist's) vise and gripping the chisel in a large crescent-type ("adjustable jaw," to be technically correct) wrench.

If it dies in the removal, there are a whole bunch of ways to measure for the new handle. Query the archives here for ideas.

Re: question on making new handle

#7

Re: question on making new handle

-e-

>wow -- those are beautiful!

Thanks so much for the pattern and instructions -- i'll try it out tomorrow!

e

Re: question on making new handle

#8

Re: Don't glue it

-e-

>thanks,bill ...i'll try both ways

and "no glue" now makes sense.

e

Re: question on making new handle

#9

Re: question on making new handle

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Amazing work my friend!!

Re: question on making new handle

#10

Re: Don't glue it, well maybe....

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Hi e,

I've also heard of using hide glue, a lot more forgiving and reversable than epoxy.

Bob_in_NJ

Re: question on making new handle

#11

Re: Don't glue it

ThomD

>I probably wouldn't use glue with that kind of handle, but epoxy does a great job, and while rare on most bench chisels it's comon on woodturning chisels. Epoxy really integreates the handle and the chisel, sure it's permanent, but most people don't mess around with the handles once they are on, unless they fall off. The only real downside is that epoxy is pretty much the one word answer to everything involving wood, to the extent there wouldn't be much need for chisels if you had enough epoxy. So it's part of the art of cabinetmaking to keep the epoxy out of the picture, but if you wanted to make a high performance wood product like a glider, you would probably have more use for epoxy than dovetails.

Re: question on making new handle

#12

knock, knock...

James Watriss

>I usually grab the bit end of the chisel, and rap the edge or end of the bench with the handle a few times. Seems to do a good job of rattling the handle right out.

Ditto what the others said about no glue. In the highly unlikely event that your handle cracks, you want to be able to get it back out.

Re: question on making new handle

#13

Re: question on making new handle

Ernie Miller

>Geez Dom you got that all backwards! there should be a grove in the handle for every 1/8" of chisel width you have it bassakwards the 1/4" chisel shoule have 2 grooves the 7/8 should have 7 that way you can tell right off which chisel you want. other than that they look great!

Re: question on making new handle

#14

I think epoxy solves the problem...

Alan DuBoff

>These large paring chisels do not get a lot of stress on the handle typically, and I find it easier to secure them with epoxy.

Epoxy can be heated up to r&r if needed, but it just seems to keep the handle from falling out, which most do eventually.

I have a few of these similar paring chisels, and at least 2 of them are epoxied. One was given to me as a gift a few years ago, and the maker of the new handle also epoxied it (Galootaclaus present).

I think what Bill mentioned about the wood compressing over time makes sense, but not for a paring chisel where you are not wacking it with a mallet. Also, wood that will compress will also uncompress, since wood changes with climate, so in the end your handle will most likely fall out as the seasons change.

The reason the handle is so smashed up is most likely that someone was using a mallet on it. I believe this is a paring chisel, not a bench chisel.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: question on making new handle

#15

Exactly!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>My sediments too 8^)

Re: question on making new handle

#16

Re: I think epoxy solves the problem...

ThomD

>"These large paring chisels do not get a lot of stress on the handle typically, and I find it easier to secure them with epoxy."

I get what you are saying, but in addition, if a person wanted a chisel they could fire out of a canon to penetrate a tank, the blade would be epoxied in. The more oversized the hole, the more epoxy, the better the result, up to a point. If you think of something like a 2 inch deep, .5" hole it would have 3 square inches of sidewall surface, which amounts to 5000 pound of shear strength minimum. Meanwhile, the epoxy will perfectly fit the metal, and will be a unit with it, and now the forces on the wood from the blade are spread over a much wider area in the wood. Wood is very strong stuff but is easily cruched and deformed from point loads, etc... The big horror is just how it look, sorta a Crayola crayon level of craftsmanship. One either puts up with it or learns to conceil it.

Re: question on making new handle

#17

Re: I think epoxy solves the problem...

Tony Zaffuto

>If your last sentence refers to the use of epoxy, then ya gotta be like the old bull and take your time, instead of like the young bull when he first goes in the cow pen.

T.Z.

Re: question on making new handle

#18

Re: question on making new handle

Wayne

>I bought this nice 1/2" 750 a few years ago and spent a bunch of time getting it in shape and sharp as a rasor and picked it up by the handle and quess what out pops the blade and to the floor it went, yep nicked it up something terable and to the cabinet I went for the epoxy let it dry and re-sharpened it and haven't had a problem since and if my grandchildern want the handle off I'll let them figure out how to get it off. By then they will need the mental excersize as no one will even know what the heck the thing is anyway. Now for the 8x10 color glossy photos with the writing on the back, are you listening Alice, man that was a long time ago!!

Re: question on making new handle

#19

wrong

Todd Hughes

>Those handles look great and I appreciate the work involved ....but all of them are made incorrectly.

A properly made and fitted handle will have a gap between the end of the metal socket and the shoulder on the wood handle. This way with use the handle is driven into the socket and stays tight and also if the wood drys out and shrinks it is driven in further and tightened.If you make the handle with out this space as yours were it can't be tightened and when loose it is loose. This is why people have to glue handles in because handles were not fitted correctly. A chisel that has seen lots of use will eventually loose this gap as the handle gets driven into the socket and won't be able to tightened but you don't want to start off like that....Todd


img

Re: question on making new handle

#20

Re: wrong

ThomD

>My bad. sometimes the pictures don't download that fast... For a socket, I would be anti glue like a lot of people around here. I was talking tangs. Sockets might well survive being fired from a canon, they certainly survive being fired from a bow. (Actualy come to think of it, arrow heads are glued on. Bohning Fereltite is very exfective, comes in meltable sticks like sealing wax. I use five minute epoxy myself. It isn't as reversible, but I guess that is why they make reamers.)

The only day in day out chisels I have that are socket only, are the Barrs, and he makes them without a shoulder. that said, they don't seem to move an iota. I thik he dries them out before he pounds them home, and they stay tight and never loosen. One also needs to leave a little gap on the inside.

Todd is that gap you have in your pic not excessive, wouldn't it be more in the order of 1/16" or 1/8". That handle looks like it met it's blade at a fea market.

Re: question on making new handle

#21

Re: wrong

Todd Hughes

>I think the handle in the chisel I shown is original and is about what i would expect it to look like on a Stanley 750 that saw minimal use...here is a photo taken from a Stanley catalog that shows this gap and it's size...Todd


img

Re: question on making new handle

#22

Re: question on making new handle

-e-

>OK -- i finally spent some time on replacing the handle and sprucing up the old chisel (1 3/4" x 6)... the lessons learned:

a1)set the iron in a vise and twist handle with pipe wrench to remove old wood.

1) use wood that isn't prone to splitting--first attempt was with iron bark eucalyptus ... one wack and it split into 50 pieces...went back to reliable oak.

2) the end ring requires a double shoulder, and this fit is critical to successful pounding with a mallet.

3) don't glue -- it will interfere with the wood setting into the iron cone.

4) don't make it pretty if you plan on pounding on it.

i'm using this to split off the bark from wood when i mount a half-round on the lathe.

also, i spent a consider amount of time correcting the damaged corner -- originally, i thought it didn't matter but discovered that the damage extended onto the back and prevented a clean penetration. after grinding and regrinding, the chisel is now effective and i'm ready for the next one.

thanks everyone for your thoughts and ideas!


img

Re: question on making new handle

#23

Re: question on making new handle

ThomD

>The way to remove a chisel handle is to hold the blade, and whack the handle against something solid, working it around. This will back out just about any handle, and they can be reused if one is careful and needs that option. Probably best to use a blade protector or some tape to avoid cuts.