Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

Posts

Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#1

Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang,

I've been messing around with that wooden coffin smoother again and have determined that it would benefit from a new wedge. So I've decided to make one. I assume that any dry, stable, dense hardwood would work. I have a piece of bubinga that'll probably work nicely.

I seem to remember seeing an article on making a new wedge for a wooden plane. But I can't seem to find it in my "archives", or in the hand plane websites I have bookmarked. I believe it was Bob Smasler that wrote the article I'm talking about.

I have read and re-read Michael Dunbar's book "Restoring, Tuning & Using Classic Woodworking Tools". However, the actual process of making the wedge and fitting it properly is not gone over in enough detail (for me that is).

Does anyone have a source for an online document that details the fabrication and fitting of a wedge for a (non-Krenov style) wooden plane?

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#2

And another question...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I don' t know how this relates to plane wedges, but I like to use softer, springier hardwoods for tusk tenon wedges and such because they compress a bit when you drive them home and that applies a better grip to whatever it is you're wedging. I have two C&W planes now, and they both have rather dense wedges that require a strong tap to seat them. That's fine, but I was wondering if something a little softer would be more secure?

Ellis

Re: Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#3

Re: And another question...

ThomD

>My exact response also. I made a plane out of Andaman paduak, and I made the wedge out of iron hard Osage. I was not that great at holding a blade, and felt brittle in adjustment. Sorta like a putter. People talk about hard and soft materials though testing seems to indicate the real "touch" factor is sound. blind tests with different materials, but with sound replacement technology will cause users to identify softness on the basis of the sound they hear, not the material. Whatever the reason I prefer a soft touch for adjusting, in addition to the retention factors.

I wish I could recommend a source for a wedge article. On the other hand you do have a wedge. My suggestion would be, as before, to double check you plane for geometric purity. Take small pieces of 1/8" ply and experiment with tapers until you get a perfect fit to the abutments. Then check to be sure you have bilateral symmetry. Then use the existing wedge to determine the cutouts you are going to make. It isn't that complicated. I have one Jack plane I made and it worked so well I never got around to cutting out the center of the wedge. So job one is the basic wedge, and job two is cutting away everything you can that will allow the shaving to pass without undermining the wedging action in the abutments area. Might even be worth your while to make a plain vanilla maple wedge, and then proceed from there as interest allows.

Re: Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#4

Re: And another question...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Ellis,

Not long ago, Warren Mickley made a comment that one reason beech is so good as a plane-making material, is because the wedge seats so well. That's been my experience too.

Let me suggest a quick check for your C&W's, if you haven't already done this. Put a straight edge along the face side of the wedge, the face that contacts the blade top. Check along both horns. It sounds to me like your wedges may have gotten ever so slightly convex along the length. They work best when they're either dead flat or ever so slightly concave, so that they take a spring set. Ever so slight. Check, and if you think they'll benefit, take a scraper and scrape the slightest little concavity into the wedge. Makes a huge difference in the action. The wedges should not require a heavy tap, if they're right.

Wiley

Re: Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#5

Thanks guys & article found!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Ellis, Thom, and Wiley,

Thank you all for the input!

I had posted this question on SMC and was pointed in the direction of the Norse Woodsmith Website. Particularly, the article there titled "Building a Traditional Coffin Smoother". In this article is a pretty detailed section on building and fine tuning the wedge.

In regards to to answer YOUR question Ellis (and in support of your statement Thom), I noticed that in the section that describes the wood selection for the wedge there is a short blurb that reads, "For contrast, for a wood that isn't as hard as the wood used in the body of the plane, and because I had some - I chose a piece of walnut to make the wedge."

With that in mind, I may end up using a piece of Walnut or maybe even Soft Maple.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#6

TRIED to make a new wedge

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Well, I tried to make a new wedge today out of some walnut. Twice actually. Neither fit without side to side wobble. I also learned that making a wedge to fit the plane WITHOUT the iron in place first is a real waste of time!

I can get the primary wedge shape pretty easily. It's the side to side fit that eludes me. I made a plywood template as is suggested on the Norse Woodsmith Website. That was a great help on the primary bevel. But I just tried to fit the side to side by trial and error. BIG Mistake that! Oh well, live and learn.

One of the things I ended up doing was to flatten the chip breaker. Someone had bent it, probably in an aborted effort to make it fit the iron better. But I re-bent it and sanded and polished the the surface. I also used the belt sander to take a bit off the sides of the iron. This helped with the fit. But I'm still getting clogging at the side of the mouth.

When I make ANOTHER new wedge I'm going to be more mindful of the side to side fit. I'll take advice I receive on another forum and make a template out of some card stock. I'll keep you all posted.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Article on making a new wedge for a woodie?

#7

Re: TRIED to make a new wedge

ThomD

>What you might try is two pieces of card that overlap in the middle, stick them in and spread them apart, then use a few tick marks to record the spacing. This approach will allow you a little more flexibility to get around any taper issues or problems with a slide in fit hanging up etc...

Do you have a plane to allow you to fit the wedge progressively? I haven't really had a problem with side to side fit., myself, but if you are working up your first plane and don't have a means of planing the wedge...